{
  "version": "real_uid_writeback_execution_contract_deepseek.v1",
  "created_at": "2026-06-07T21:33:47.861751Z",
  "round_id": "round2",
  "call_status": "success",
  "parse_status": "pass",
  "parse_error": "",
  "overall_verdict": "",
  "round2_verdict": "round1_supported_with_corrections",
  "confidence": "high",
  "finding_counts": {
    "low": 1
  },
  "findings": [
    {
      "category": "validation",
      "description": "The validator for control-plane files checks for forbidden classifications (e.g., canonical writeback execution) and assertions of denied authority, but does not verify that the files positively record the next implementation as 'no-writeback eligibility reconciliation' as required by the exit criteria. A control-plane file could omit the forbidden content yet fail to affirm the correct step, leaving an ambiguous or incomplete state that undermines the exit criteria.",
      "required_fix": "Add a validator that confirms the relevant control-plane files (e.g., execution_state.json, phase_acceptance.json, workflow.json, workflow_index.json, retrospective_state.json) contain an explicit field or value positively identifying the next implementation as eligibility reconciliation (e.g., next_step=no_writeback_eligibility_reconciliation), or that the absence of such a positive record triggers a validation failure.",
      "severity": "low"
    }
  ],
  "required_corrections": [
    "Add a validator that verifies control-plane files positively record the next implementation as no-writeback eligibility reconciliation, not merely the absence of forbidden classifications."
  ],
  "raw_payload": {
    "parse_status": "pass",
    "confidence": "high",
    "findings": [
      {
        "category": "validation",
        "description": "The validator for control-plane files checks for forbidden classifications (e.g., canonical writeback execution) and assertions of denied authority, but does not verify that the files positively record the next implementation as 'no-writeback eligibility reconciliation' as required by the exit criteria. A control-plane file could omit the forbidden content yet fail to affirm the correct step, leaving an ambiguous or incomplete state that undermines the exit criteria.",
        "required_fix": "Add a validator that confirms the relevant control-plane files (e.g., execution_state.json, phase_acceptance.json, workflow.json, workflow_index.json, retrospective_state.json) contain an explicit field or value positively identifying the next implementation as eligibility reconciliation (e.g., next_step=no_writeback_eligibility_reconciliation), or that the absence of such a positive record triggers a validation failure.",
        "severity": "low"
      }
    ],
    "required_corrections": [
      "Add a validator that verifies control-plane files positively record the next implementation as no-writeback eligibility reconciliation, not merely the absence of forbidden classifications."
    ],
    "round2_verdict": "round1_supported_with_corrections"
  },
  "advisory_only": true,
  "not_evidence_or_acceptance_or_route_authority": true
}