[
  {
    "content": "You are DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max acting as Round 2 critic. Return JSON only. Be strict about advisory-only status, no evidence, no route authority, no provider execution, no candidate activation, and no content-specific runtime branching.",
    "role": "system"
  },
  {
    "content": "{\n  \"version\": \"project_retrospective_post_now32_round2_input.v1\",\n  \"created_at\": \"2026-06-05T19:03:24.646394Z\",\n  \"role\": \"DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max second-round critic; advisory only.\",\n  \"task\": \"Critique Round 1 for overreach, hallucination, boundary violations, missing assumptions, and operator constraints. Produce final project retrospective/mainline recalibration basis. Return JSON only.\",\n  \"context\": {\n    \"project\": \"Novel2Video / novel2video-writer-core\",\n    \"operator_request\": \"Now-32 如果已经收口完毕，请进行完整项目复盘，并用复盘结果结合项目目标校正后续主线更新方向。\",\n    \"current_date_local\": \"2026-06-06T03:00:00+08:00\",\n    \"project_goal\": \"Build a program-first pipeline: source -> KG -> entity/context -> scene/chronology -> adaptation -> AI-executable screenplay -> shooting_script -> shot context -> provider-neutral prompt packet / adapter payload -> review/handoff -> feedback/repair/replay. Providers are adapter/benchmark/feedback/diagnostic targets, not canonical schema owners.\",\n    \"authority_order\": [\n      \"execution_state.json.next_entrypoint\",\n      \"phase_acceptance.json\",\n      \"workflow.json\",\n      \"AGENTS.md\",\n      \"todo.md\",\n      \"projectreport.md\",\n      \"patchnote.md\"\n    ],\n    \"active_route_authority\": {\n      \"id\": \"platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract\",\n      \"title\": \"Prompt Readiness QA And Manual Execution Log Contract\",\n      \"owner_layer\": \"Pipeline Orchestrator / Video Prompt Packet & Adapter Render Agent / Video Generation Agent / Provider Adapter & Payload Agent / QA & Consistency Agent / Visualization & Review UI Agent\",\n      \"why_now\": \"Now-32 remains the active evidence-gated route; P计划 V2 creative-quality work is a sidecar and does not authorize provider/manual/feedback execution.\"\n    },\n    \"phase_acceptance_gate_status\": \"open\",\n    \"current_status\": \"now32_control_plane_hardening_contract_landed_validated\",\n    \"current_implementation_priority\": \"Now-32_control_plane_hardening_contract_landed_validated\",\n    \"current_p_plan_stage\": \"P计划_V2_closed_after_P2V24_final_closeout\",\n    \"now32_contract_status\": \"now32_control_plane_hardening_contract_landed_validated\",\n    \"p2v24_key_counts\": {\n      \"chapter_package_count\": 20,\n      \"draft_row_count\": 1638,\n      \"held_row_count\": 240,\n      \"fully_ready_chapter_count\": 13,\n      \"partial_or_held_chapter_count\": 7,\n      \"debt_row_count\": 247,\n      \"chapter_readiness_debt_count\": 7,\n      \"held_row_debt_count\": 240,\n      \"provider_prompt_syntax_count\": 0,\n      \"production_lane_accepted_count\": 0,\n      \"validator_failure_count\": 0,\n      \"provider_prompt_count\": 0,\n      \"adapter_payload_count\": 0,\n      \"provider_job_execution_count\": 0,\n      \"media_generation_count\": 0,\n      \"manual_provider_evidence_count\": 0,\n      \"operator_evidence_creation_count\": 0,\n      \"feedback_intake_count\": 0,\n      \"repair_execution_count\": 0,\n      \"replay_action_count\": 0,\n      \"accepted_overlay_write_count\": 0,\n      \"operator_overlay_write_count\": 0,\n      \"canonical_kg_writeback_count\": 0,\n      \"raw_kg_writeback_count\": 0,\n      \"outputs_index_mutation_count\": 0\n    },\n    \"p2v24_report\": {\n      \"final_closeout_status\": \"p_plan_ready_to_close_pending_deepseek_advisory_and_control_plane_sync\",\n      \"p_plan_proved\": [\n        \"Operator-accepted C-version director-level script constraints were converted into structured extraction and validation constraints.\",\n        \"First20 pipeline director scripts were generated, structurally extracted, packetized, neutral-drafted, and packaged with traceability.\",\n        \"Strong direct DeepSeek output remains a challenger/repair oracle, not a silent replacement lane.\",\n        \"DeepSeek advisory became a standing expert consultation lane while remaining advisory-only.\",\n        \"Now-32 remains the route for provider/manual/evidence work.\"\n      ],\n      \"remaining_debt\": [\n        \"240 held rows remain pending explicit QA/repair/evidence contract.\",\n        \"Chapter 18 remains held_only_no_ready_drafts and must not be promoted to ready.\",\n        \"Provider/manual/media execution has not started and is outside P计划 closeout.\"\n      ],\n      \"now32_handoff_status\": \"ready_for_now32_planning_pending_evidence_not_execution\",\n      \"production_lane_accepted\": false,\n      \"provider_manual_execution_allowed\": false\n    },\n    \"p2v24_traceability\": {\n      \"input_fingerprint\": \"86d518b490df279b93282eab2e912f0df6de97bcaaeddf35f3873905f3e6e3e4\",\n      \"p2v23_counts\": {\n        \"chapter_package_count\": 20,\n        \"neutral_draft_row_count\": 1638,\n        \"held_row_count\": 240,\n        \"fully_ready_chapter_count\": 13,\n        \"partial_or_held_chapter_count\": 7,\n        \"readiness_label_counts\": {\n          \"partial_ready_with_holds\": 6,\n          \"ready_for_now32_packaging\": 13,\n          \"held_only_no_ready_drafts\": 1\n        }\n      },\n      \"p2v23_traceability\": {\n        \"all_draft_rows_represented\": true,\n        \"all_held_rows_represented\": true,\n        \"missing_draft_row_ids\": [],\n        \"missing_held_row_ids\": [],\n        \"duplicate_draft_row_ids\": [],\n        \"duplicate_held_row_ids\": []\n      },\n      \"debt_register_counts\": {\n        \"chapter_readiness_debt\": 7,\n        \"held_row_debt\": 240\n      }\n    },\n    \"now32_handoff\": {\n      \"handoff_status\": \"ready_for_now32_planning_pending_evidence_not_execution\",\n      \"readiness_package_ref\": {\n        \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p_plan_v2_23_prompt_readiness_packaging_boundary_20260605_0730/P2V_23_prompt_readiness_package.json\",\n        \"exists\": true,\n        \"sha256\": \"a57ebbac6bef7390e5f5ff4abf46c479f3cd2f612fb66f356541dab5eee748d5\",\n        \"size_bytes\": 11758\n      },\n      \"neutral_draft_row_count\": 1638,\n      \"held_row_count\": 240,\n      \"debt_row_count\": 247,\n      \"chapter_18_status\": \"held_only_no_ready_drafts\",\n      \"requires_future_contracts\": [\n        \"manual_or_provider_execution_evidence_contract\",\n        \"held_row_QA_or_repair_contract\",\n        \"feedback_repair_replay_contract_if_real_feedback_exists\"\n      ],\n      \"blocked_work\": [\n        \"provider_specific_prompt_rendering\",\n        \"adapter_payload_creation\",\n        \"provider_job_execution\",\n        \"media_generation\",\n        \"manual_provider_operator_evidence_creation\",\n        \"feedback_intake\",\n        \"repair_execution\",\n        \"replay_execution\",\n        \"accepted_or_operator_overlay_writeback\",\n        \"canonical_or_raw_KG_writeback\",\n        \"outputs_index_mutation\",\n        \"old_B7_continuation\"\n      ],\n      \"policy\": {\n        \"stage\": \"P计划_V2_24_p_plan_final_closeout\",\n        \"p_plan_final_closeout_only\": true,\n        \"provider_specific_prompt_allowed\": false,\n        \"adapter_payload_allowed\": false,\n        \"provider_job_execution_allowed\": false,\n        \"media_generation_allowed\": false,\n        \"manual_provider_evidence_creation_allowed\": false,\n        \"operator_evidence_creation_allowed\": false,\n        \"feedback_intake_allowed\": false,\n        \"repair_execution_allowed\": false,\n        \"replay_execution_allowed\": false,\n        \"accepted_overlay_writeback_allowed\": false,\n        \"operator_overlay_writeback_allowed\": false,\n        \"canonical_kg_writeback_allowed\": false,\n        \"raw_kg_writeback_allowed\": false,\n        \"outputs_index_mutation_allowed\": false,\n        \"operator_production_acceptance_claimed\": false,\n        \"deepseek_advisory_may_substitute_for_expert_advice\": true,\n        \"deepseek_advisory_is_operator_production_acceptance\": false,\n        \"runtime_branch_by_work_title_entity_name_or_sample_text_allowed\": false,\n        \"active_route_authority\": \"execution_state.json.next_entrypoint\",\n        \"execution_state_next_entrypoint_unchanged\": true\n      }\n    },\n    \"retrospective_state_summary\": {\n      \"outcome\": \"p_plan_v2_closed_after_p2v24_final_closeout\",\n      \"summary\": \"P2V-24 P计划 final closeout completed after deterministic final gate/report generation, source-to-readiness traceability summary, readiness debt register, Now-32 handoff calibration, focused tests, DeepSeek advisory, and final retrospective. Final closeout preserves 20 chapter packages, 1638 neutral draft rows, 240 held rows, fully-ready/partial-or-held chapters=13/7, debt register rows=247 (7 chapter readiness + 240 held-row debt), validator_failure_count=0, provider_prompt_syntax_count=0, forbidden side-effect counts=0. DeepSeek advisory supports P2V-24 with finding/blocker/high/medium/low=2/0/0/0/2 and recommends mark_P计划_closed_and_continue_Now32_evidence_gate. P计划 is closed as an implementation umbrella; Now-32 next_entrypoint remains unchanged and evidence/provider/manual work still requires explicit contract/evidence.\",\n      \"actual_landed\": [\n        \"P2V-24 code module, deterministic runner, DeepSeek runner, and focused tests landed.\",\n        \"Final P2V-24 deterministic run exists at outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742 with final report, traceability summary, debt register, Now-32 handoff calibration, and final HTML.\",\n        \"DeepSeek advisory passed and recommended marking P计划 closed while continuing Now-32 evidence gate.\",\n        \"P2V-24 final closeout retrospective landed and P计划 control plane is marked closed.\",\n        \"Now-32 control-plane hardening contract landed as a post-P计划 active-route control artifact.\",\n        \"Two-round DeepSeek advisory basis recorded for Now-32 hardening; Round 1 parse repaired transparently and Round 2 passed.\"\n      ],\n      \"not_landed\": [\n        \"Provider-specific prompts, adapter payloads, provider/media execution, manual/provider/operator evidence, feedback/replay, KG/overlay writeback, outputs index mutation, and old B7 continuation remain unlanded and blocked.\",\n        \"Held-row repair and chapter 18 readiness repair remain future explicit-contract work.\",\n        \"Now-32 hardening does not land real manual/provider/operator evidence, provider execution, feedback/repair/replay, KG/overlay writeback, outputs index mutation, or Now-33/34/35/36 activation.\"\n      ],\n      \"fragility_or_debt\": [\n        \"240 held rows remain visible readiness debt.\",\n        \"Chapter 18 remains held_only_no_ready_drafts.\",\n        \"P计划 closeout is not production acceptance.\",\n        \"Control-plane hardening must avoid content-specific runtime branching; held/debt checks are manifest-driven.\"\n      ],\n      \"next_stage_recommendation\": \"P计划 is closed. Continue through Now-32 control-plane hardening/evidence taxonomy only; future manual/provider/evidence/repair/activation work requires explicit contract.\"\n    },\n    \"workflow_index_notes\": [\n      \"P计划 V2 is closed after P2V-24 final closeout.\",\n      \"Now-32 next_entrypoint remains the active route authority and is unchanged.\",\n      \"Final closeout preserves 1638 neutral draft rows, 240 held rows, and 247 debt rows.\",\n      \"Chapter 18 remains held_only_no_ready_drafts and must not be promoted without future explicit repair/evidence contract.\",\n      \"DeepSeek delegated advice may substitute for expert consultation but not production acceptance or evidence writeback.\",\n      \"Provider/manual/feedback/KG/overlay/replay/output-index work remains blocked until explicit contract.\",\n      \"Post-P计划 candidate mainlines Now-33..36 are defined but inactive; Now-32 remains active route authority.\",\n      \"New thread handoff prompt is updated in docs/midterm_autopilot_prompt.md.\",\n      \"Short-entry control-plane files are compacted; historical P/P2V detail remains in patchnote.md, workflow.json, docs, and outputs.\",\n      \"Now-32 control-plane hardening contract landed; validated.\",\n      \"Round 1 DeepSeek advisory parse was deterministically repaired for one duplicate comma, then Round 2 repaired critique passed.\"\n    ],\n    \"candidate_strategy_excerpt\": \"# Post-P计划 Now-32..36 Candidate Mainline Strategy\\n\\n更新时间：`2026-06-05T13:42:00+08:00`\\n\\n## Status\\n\\n- Current active route: `Now-32 / Prompt-Readiness-Manual-Execution-Log-Contract`\\n- Active route authority: `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`\\n- P计划 status: `P计划_V2_closed_after_P2V24_final_closeout`\\n- This document is a definition-phase strategy record only. It does not activate Now-33, Now-34, Now-35, or Now-36.\\n- `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint` must remain `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`.\\n\\n## Evidence Basis\\n\\n- Operator direction on 2026-06-05: keep DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max as standing third-party consultant; use its advice dialectically; require at least two deep consultation rounds for high-impact strategy, quality gate, and schema decisions.\\n- Round 1 DeepSeek consultation: `outputs/post_p_plan_now32_36_strategy_deepseek_consultation_20260605_1232`\\n- Round 2 DeepSeek critique/refinement: `outputs/post_p_plan_now32_36_strategy_deepseek_consultation_round2_20260605_1245`\\n- Industry resources inspected:\\n  - `docs/resource/【对客】Doubao-Seedance-2.0：企业级业务场景指南.zip`\\n  - `docs/resource/火山剧创优秀短剧作品赏析--动画短片 PV 剧本：《微光巢穴》.zip`\\n- Format reference resource classified for Now-36:\\n  - `docs/resource/Dramart_标准剧本格式参考_1775308799.pdf`\\n  - sha256: `2d1dfa9e989c2218ca10115d9e2b11d5f791c7a43bd99511c78e49f0a5324f30`\\n  - size: `4708454` bytes\\n  - classification: Dramart script format reference only; not a creative-quality benchmark, not a schema migration trigger, and not an active production/evidence artifact.\\n\\n## Strategic Diagnosis\\n\\nThe pipeline should not define its value as beating `deepseek_strong_direct` in one-off prose quality. Direct generation can produce strong scripts, but it does not reliably produce a stable production graph.\\n\\nThe pipeline's durable advantage is:\\n\\n- stable KG/entity links for characters, locations, props, motifs, organizations, and narrative functions;\\n- shot-level binding from screenplay text to entity refs, location refs, prop refs, source refs, and reference assets;\\n- provider-neutral production packet lineage;\\n- deterministic validators, debt registers, review surfaces, and handoff logs;\\n- explicit separation of advisory, readiness, evidence, acceptance, and production execution.\\n\\nIndustry benchmark resources reinforce this direction. The Seedance guide treats production prompts as structured control packets: subject, action, camera language, reference assets, style/aesthetics, audio/SFX, and restrictions. The `微光巢穴` sample treats script output as a production bible: high-level style and tempo, scene/dialogue layer, time-coded shot layer, character/prop/scene asset tables, and sound/subtitle/action rhythm.\\n\\nTherefore, future work should optimize toward asset-linked, entity-linked, traceable production packets, not literary script text alone.\\n\\n## Candidate Mainlines\\n\\n### Now-32 Active: Prompt Readiness QA And Manual Execution Log Contract\\n\\nObjective: Keep the active evidence gate after P计划 closeout. Now-32 governs readiness handoff, manual execution log structure, and evidence boundaries.\\n\\nStatus: `active`\\n\\nAllowed now:\\n\\n- Define and inspect readiness/handoff controls.\\n- Keep held-row debt explicit.\\n- Prepare manual/evidence contract details without generating provider evidence.\\n- Record DeepSeek advisory as advisory-only.\\n\\nBlocked:\\n\\n- Provider execution.\\n- Media generation.\\n- Manual/provider/operator evidence creation.\\n- Feedback intake, repair replay, KG/overlay writeback, outputs index mutation, production acceptance.\\n\\n### Now-33 Candidate: KG/Entity-Link And Asset Binding Strengthening\\n\\nObjective: Define and, after explicit activation only, bind prompt/readiness rows to stable KG/entity refs and reference assets so every shot becomes part of a traceable production graph.\\n\\nStatus: `candidate_blocked_until_explicit_contract`\\n\\nActivation condition: operator issues an explicit Now-33 activation contract authorizing entity-link and asset-binding work, with canonical KG writeback remaining blocked unless separately authorized.\\n\\nDefinition-phase allowed work:\\n\\n- Design entity-link and asset-binding schemas for prompt packets.\\n- Define linkage rules, disambiguation strategy, and asset binding criteria.\\n- Create templates for `entity_link_manifest` and `asset_binding_registry`.\\n\\nBlocked until activation:\\n\\n- Running automated entity extraction/linking against production rows.\\n- Augmenting prompt packets with `entity_refs` or `asset_refs`.\\n- Mutating draft rows, prompt packets, canonical KG, accepted overlays, or production data.\\n\\n### Now-34 Candidate: Industry-Benchmark Schema And Gate Upgrade\\n\\nObjective: Translate the industry resource constraints into formal schema, validator, QA rubric, and benchmark-gate requirements.\\n\\nStatus: `candidate_blocked_until_explicit_contract`\\n\\nActivation condition: operator issues an explicit Now-34 activation contract after Now-33 completion or an explicit decision to skip Now-33.\\n\\nDefinition-phase allowed work:\\n\\n- Draft VideoPromptPacket schema v2 based on Seedance and `微光巢穴` benchmark patterns.\\n- Define validator specs and adversarial benchmark examples.\\n- Design migration rules for future approved rows.\\n\\nBlocked until activation:\\n\\n- Applying schema migration to actual prompt packets.\\n- Running validators on production data.\\n- Enforcing aesthetic or stylistic judgments as hard gate failures beyond structural checks.\\n\\n### Now-35 Candidate: DeepSeek Consultant-As-Reviewer Systematic Integration\\n\\nObjective: Operationalize DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max as a standing non-voting reviewer for prompt readiness, entity consistency, asset binding, and industry compliance.\\n\\nStatus: `candidate_blocked_until_explicit_contract`\\n\\nActivation condition: operator issues an explicit Now-35 activation contract, likely after Now-34, to build/run the review harness against approved rows.\\n\\nDefinition-phase allowed work:\\n\\n- Design review harness architecture.\\n- Define scoring dimensions, calibration methodology, and inter-rater comparison plan.\\n- Define advisory log schema and review dashboard design.\\n\\nBlocked until activation:\\n\\n- Building or executing automated review harnesses on prompt packets.\\n- Storing DeepSeek scores in evidence or production indexes.\\n- Using DeepSeek scores to auto-accept or auto-reject prompts.\\n\\n### Now-36 Candidate: Production Readiness Evidence Pack Assembly\\n\\nObjective: Assemble a self-contained pre-execution evidence pack proving readiness for provider dispatch, still without executing provider calls.\\n\\nStatus: `candidate_blocked_until_explicit_contract`\\n\\nActivation condition: operator issues an explicit Now-36 activation contract after prior candidate mainlines complete and required artifacts exist.\\n\\nDefinition-phase allowed work:\\n\\n- Design evidence pack structure and manifest schema.\\n- Define mandatory gap analysis fields for held rows, missing assets, unresolved debts, and non-ready chapters.\\n- Define operator signature validity criteria.\\n- Register downstream deliverable-format references, including Dramart script format references, as non-execution formatting constraints for future evidence pack design.\\n\\nBlocked until activation:\\n\\n- Compiling, generating, or signing an evidence pack.\\n- Claiming production readiness.\\n- Triggering downstream execution.\\n- Applying Dramart formatting to production packets or treating format conformance as provider execution readiness before Now-36 activation.\\n\\n## Two-Round DeepSeek Consultant Protocol\\n\\nFor any high-impact strategy, quality gate, schema design, route transition, evidence contract, or production-readiness decision:\\n\\n1. Minimum two DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max consultation rounds are required before finalizing the advisory basis.\\n2. Round 1 is scoping and initial advice: options, risks, artifacts, gates, and recommended direction.\\n3. Round 2 is critique and refinement: explicitly review Round 1 for overreach, hallucination, boundary violations, missing assumptions, and operator constraints; confirm or correct each major point.\\n4. If the operator adds material constraints or resources between rounds, Round 2 must address them. If the new information materially changes the advice basis, run a third round.\\n5. Consultation records must preserve input refs/fingerprints, provider/model/thinking metadata, raw response, parsed result, parse status, and skipped/timeout/unavailable status.\\n6. DeepSeek output may serve as final expert advice basis under operator delegation, but never becomes provider evidence, manual execution evidence, operator production acceptance, accepted/operator overlay, canonical/raw KG writeback, feedback intake, replay action, runtime route authority, or outputs index mutation.\\n7. DeepSeek must not propose runtime branching by work title, character/entity name, block title, or sample text. Recommendations must be generic and structural.\\n\\n## Control Plane Actions\\n\\n- Keep `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint` unchanged.\\n- Record candidate mainlines as inactive/future routes only.\\n- Record the two-round consultant protocol as a standing governance rule.\\n- Add the two consultation output directories as advisory artifacts.\\n- Keep provider/manual/feedback/KG/overlay/replay/output-index work blocked until explicit contract.\\n\\n## Do Not Do\\n\\n- Do not advance Now-33, Now-34, Now-35, or Now-36 implementation from this document alone.\\n- Do not treat DeepSeek advisory as evidence or acceptance.\\n- Do not mutate prompt packets, entity links, KG, overlays, generated indexes, or evidence stores in definition phase.\\n- Do not claim production readiness while held rows, chapter 18 held-only status, or missing assets remain unresolved or undisclosed.\\n\",\n    \"p2v24_retrospective_excerpt\": \"# P计划 V2-24 Final Closeout Retrospective\\n\\n更新时间：`2026-06-05T07:48:00+08:00`\\n\\n## Stage\\n\\n- stage_id: `P计划_V2_24_p_plan_final_closeout`\\n- implementation umbrella: `P计划 / Pipeline Rebuild Plan` V2 creative-quality redesign sidecar\\n- active route authority: `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`\\n- active route unchanged: `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`\\n- outcome: `P计划_V2_closed_after_P2V24_final_closeout`\\n\\nP2V-24 generated the final P计划 closeout gate/report, source-to-readiness traceability summary, readiness debt register, Now-32 handoff calibration, final review HTML, focused tests, and DeepSeek advisory. It did not create provider-specific prompts, adapter payloads, provider jobs, media, manual/provider/operator evidence, feedback, repair execution, replay actions, KG/overlay writeback, production acceptance, or output-index mutations.\\n\\n## Macro Mainline Served\\n\\n- Mainline 0: Governance And Evidence\\n- Mainline 5: Structured Production Packet\\n- Mainline 6: Feedback, Repair, Replay, boundary planning only\\n\\n## Actual Landed Work\\n\\n- Code module: `src/novel2video/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout.py`\\n- Deterministic runner: `scripts/run_p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout.py`\\n- DeepSeek advisory runner: `scripts/run_p_plan_v2_24_deepseek_advisory.py`\\n- Focused tests: `tests/test_p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout.py`\\n- Deterministic run: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742`\\n- DeepSeek advisory: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_deepseek_advisory_20260605_0743`\\n\\n## Evidence Basis\\n\\n### Deterministic Run\\n\\n- run: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742`\\n- gate: `pending_deepseek_advisory_and_final_control_plane_sync` / `p2v_24_final_closeout_pass_pending_deepseek_and_control_plane_sync`\\n- validator: `pass`\\n- chapter packages preserved: `20`\\n- neutral draft rows preserved: `1638`\\n- held rows preserved: `240`\\n- fully ready chapters: `13`\\n- partial-or-held chapters: `7`\\n- debt register rows: `247`\\n- chapter readiness debt rows: `7`\\n- held-row debt rows: `240`\\n- provider prompt syntax count: `0`\\n- production lane accepted count: `0`\\n- validator failures: `0`\\n- forbidden side-effect counts: `0`\\n\\nKey artifacts:\\n\\n- final gate: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_final_closeout_gate.json`\\n- final report: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_final_closeout_report.json`\\n- traceability summary: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_source_to_readiness_traceability_summary.json`\\n- readiness debt register: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_readiness_debt_register.jsonl`\\n- Now-32 handoff calibration: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_now32_handoff_calibration.json`\\n- final review HTML: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_final_closeout_review.html`\\n\\n### DeepSeek Advisory\\n\\n- run: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_deepseek_advisory_20260605_0743`\\n- gate: `pass` / `deepseek_advisory_supports_p2v_24_p_plan_final_closeout`\\n- verdict: `supports_p2v_24_p_plan_final_closeout`\\n- parse status: `pass`\\n- finding/blocker/high/medium/low: `2/0/0/0/2`\\n- recommended next entrypoint: `mark_P计划_closed_and_continue_Now32_evidence_gate`\\n\\nDeepSeek assessment:\\n\\n- final closeout is structurally complete and traceable;\\n- all remaining debt is explicitly registered and transferred to Now-32/future contracts;\\n- no forbidden operations were detected;\\n- P计划 can be marked closed after final control-plane sync.\\n\\nDeepSeek low findings:\\n\\n- `240` held rows and `7` chapter readiness debt rows remain and must be honored after closeout.\\n- Boundary enforcement is complete; no side-effect finding requires repair.\\n\\nThese low findings are final state notes, not blockers.\\n\\n## Final Retrospective Findings\\n\\n1. P计划 achieved its rebuild objective.\\n\\nThe project now has a traceable path from the accepted C-version director-level script constraints through structured extraction, first20 generation, structured packetization, neutral prompt drafting, readiness packaging, and final closeout.\\n\\n2. The pipeline is valuable as a production system, not as a one-off creativity contest.\\n\\nP计划 preserved direct strong DeepSeek output as challenger/repair oracle while making pipeline output traceable, testable, packageable, and reviewable. That answers the earlier concern that a direct prompt can produce high-quality scripts: direct generation remains a benchmark and repair source; the pipeline provides repeatable structure, auditability, extraction, packaging, and controlled handoff.\\n\\n3. P计划 does not claim full production readiness.\\n\\n`13` chapters are ready for Now-32 planning, `7` are partial-or-held, and chapter 18 is explicitly `held_only_no_ready_drafts`. P计划 closes because the rebuild and handoff boundary are complete, not because every row is production-accepted.\\n\\n4. Now-32 remains the correct next route.\\n\\nP计划 final handoff status is `ready_for_now32_planning_pending_evidence_not_execution`. Any future provider/manual execution, held-row QA/repair, feedback/replay, adapter rendering, or accepted KG/overlay writes require explicit Now-32 or downstream evidence contracts.\\n\\n## Remaining Debt\\n\\n- `240` held rows remain pending explicit QA/repair/evidence contract.\\n- Chapter 18 remains `held_only_no_ready_drafts`.\\n- No provider job, media generation, manual/provider/operator evidence, feedback, repair/replay, KG/overlay writeback, adapter payload, provider-specific prompt rendering, or outputs index mutation has occurred.\\n- `outputs/index.json` and `outputs/index-lite.json` were not manually mutated.\\n\\n## Final Control-Plane Calibration\\n\\nRecommended state:\\n\\n- P计划 status: `P计划_V2_closed_after_P2V24_final_closeout`\\n- active route: `Now-32 / Prompt-Readiness-Manual-Execution-Log-Contract`\\n- active route authority: unchanged `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`\\n- next non-P计划 work: Now-32 evidence/manual/repair planning only under explicit contract.\\n\\nNo further P计划 substage is opened by this closeout.\\n\\n## Verification\\n\\n- `PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 PYTHONPATH=src:. pytest -q tests/test_p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout.py` -> `3 passed`\\n- `python -m py_compile src/novel2video/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout.py scripts/run_p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout.py scripts/run_p_plan_v2_24_deepseek_advisory.py` -> pass\\n- P2V-24 deterministic run: `PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 PYTHONPATH=src python scripts/run_p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout.py --output-run-dir outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742` -> `validator pass`\\n- P2V-24 DeepSeek advisory: `PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 PYTHONPATH=src python scripts/run_p_plan_v2_24_deepseek_advisory.py --source-run-dir outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742 --output-run-dir outputs/p_plan_v2_24_deepseek_advisory_20260605_0743 --timeout-seconds 1200 --call-watchdog-seconds 1260 --max-tokens 32000 --temperature 0.0` -> `pass`\\n\\n## Boundary Confirmation\\n\\n- `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint` unchanged.\\n- No provider job was executed.\\n- No image/audio/TTS/video/media was generated.\\n- No manual/provider/operator evidence was created.\\n- No feedback was ingested.\\n- No repair/replay action was executed.\\n- No accepted/operator overlay, canonical KG, raw KG, or replay writeback occurred.\\n- No `outputs/index.json` or `outputs/index-lite.json` mutation occurred.\\n- Old B7 downstream was not resumed.\\n\",\n    \"now32_hardening_contract_excerpt\": \"# Now-32 Prompt Readiness Manual Execution Control Plane Hardening Contract\\n\\n更新时间：`2026-06-06T01:57:11+08:00`\\n\\n## Status\\n\\n- stage: `Now-32 / Prompt-Readiness-Manual-Execution-Log-Contract`\\n- workflow: `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`\\n- active route authority: `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`\\n- required next_entrypoint: `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`\\n- status: `now32_control_plane_hardening_contract_landed_validated`\\n\\nThis contract lands Now-32 detail rules for prompt-readiness governance and manual-execution evidence boundaries. It does not authorize provider execution, media generation, filled manual/provider/operator evidence, feedback intake, repair/replay, KG/overlay writeback, outputs-index mutation, production acceptance, or activation of Now-33/34/35/36.\\n\\nValidation status: `pass`.\\n\\n## Advisory Basis\\n\\nThis is a high-impact evidence/control-plane contract, so two DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max advisory rounds were run and logged as advisory-only:\\n\\n- Round 1: `outputs/now32_control_plane_hardening_deepseek_consultation_20260606_0136`\\n- Round 1 parse repair: `outputs/now32_control_plane_hardening_deepseek_consultation_20260606_0136/consultation_parse_repair_record.json`\\n- Round 2 final critique: `outputs/now32_control_plane_hardening_deepseek_consultation_round2_repaired_20260606_0143`\\n\\nRound 1 raw response succeeded but contained one duplicate comma in `validation_commands_or_checks`; the repair removed only that duplicate punctuation and wrote `consultation_parsed_repaired.json`. Round 2 then critiqued the repaired Round 1 and returned `parse_status=pass`, `confidence=high`.\\n\\nDeepSeek remains advisory-only. It is not provider/manual/operator evidence, not production acceptance, not route authority, not KG/overlay/replay/writeback authority, and not outputs-index authority.\\n\\n## Scope\\n\\nNow-32 hardening owns these definition-phase controls:\\n\\n- Define and version-lock the future manual execution log contract schema.\\n- Establish evidence taxonomy and storage boundaries.\\n- Define template-only artifacts for future manual execution entries; templates must remain non-evidence and contain no operational data.\\n- Specify pre-execution gate conditions for any later manual evidence creation.\\n- Bind all blocked actions to policy flags and control-plane invariants.\\n- Provide dry-run validation and integrity checks that do not modify state.\\n- Preserve all held/debt rows as unresolved until an explicit QA/repair/evidence contract releases them.\\n- Record advisory consultations with full metadata and advisory-only classification.\\n\\n## Out Of Scope\\n\\nNow-32 hardening must not perform or imply:\\n\\n- Provider-specific prompt rendering, adapter payload creation, provider dispatch, or media generation.\\n- Filled manual/provider/operator evidence entries, evidence manifests with live data, operator signatures, or production acceptance.\\n- Feedback intake, repair execution, replay execution, or replay action records.\\n- Accepted/operator overlay writeback, canonical KG writeback, raw KG writeback, or generated outputs-index mutation.\\n- Now-33/34/35/36 activation or implementation.\\n- Runtime branching by work title, entity name, character name, block title, sample text, or specific chapter title.\\n\\n## Evidence Taxonomy\\n\\n`advisory`\\n\\n- Non-execution review output from DeepSeek or another reviewer.\\n- Must carry `advisory_only=true`, provider/model/thinking metadata, input/message fingerprints, raw response or unavailable status, and parse status.\\n- May inform design decisions.\\n- Never satisfies readiness, evidence, acceptance, KG, overlay, replay, provider, or output-index gates.\\n\\n`template`\\n\\n- Schema definition or empty example for future evidence intake.\\n- Must carry `template_only=true` and a visible `TEMPLATE_ONLY_DO_NOT_EXECUTE` marker.\\n- Operational fields must be `null`, empty, or `PLACEHOLDER_*`.\\n- Must not live in evidence or production directories.\\n\\n`manual`\\n\\n- Future human-operator evidence after explicit authorization only.\\n- Requires `manual_execution_authorized=true`, verified operator identity, timestamp, signature or equivalent audit token, source readiness refs, evidence body hash, and chain of custody.\\n- Cannot be simulated, backfilled, or generated by a template.\\n\\n`provider`\\n\\n- Future external provider response evidence after explicit provider execution authorization only.\\n- Requires provider request fingerprint, adapter metadata, raw response body, parsed result, timestamps, and traceable task refs.\\n- Cannot be hand-crafted, inferred, or replayed as evidence.\\n\\n`operator`\\n\\n- Future production acceptance evidence by operator.\\n- Forbidden until production-lane acceptance is explicitly authorized and upstream manual/provider evidence exists where required.\\n\\n`pending`\\n\\n- Placeholder for expected but absent evidence.\\n- May appear only in tracking/debt/register surfaces.\\n- Does not satisfy any readiness or acceptance gate.\\n\\n## Manual Execution Log Contract Fields\\n\\nFuture real manual evidence rows, if authorized by a later contract, must include:\\n\\n- `log_entry_uuid`\\n- `schema_version`\\n- `contract_reference`\\n- `contract_fingerprint`\\n- `readiness_package_path`\\n- `readiness_package_sha256`\\n- `operator_identity`\\n- `operator_authentication_method`\\n- `execution_timestamp`\\n- `row_reference`\\n- `manual_action_description`\\n- `manual_output_evidence`\\n- `evidence_classification`\\n- `evidence_body_sha256`\\n- `digital_signature_or_audit_token`\\n- `chain_of_custody`\\n- `advisory_attestation`\\n\\nTemplate-only rows must keep all real evidence fields unpopulated and must include:\\n\\n- `template_only=true`\\n- `template_marker=TEMPLATE_ONLY_DO_NOT_EXECUTE`\\n- `manual_output_evidence=null`\\n- `digital_signature_or_audit_token=null`\\n- `execution_timestamp=null`\\n\\nForbidden defaults:\\n\\n- `operator_identity` must not default to `system`, `auto`, or `pipeline`.\\n- `execution_timestamp` must not default to current time in templates.\\n- `evidence_classification` must not default to `provider`, `operator`, or `accepted`.\\n- `digital_signature_or_audit_token` must not be dummy-filled.\\n- Example output text must not appear where real evidence would later live.\\n\\n## Held-Entity Invariant\\n\\nControl-plane logic must not hardcode a specific chapter, work title, entity name, character name, block title, or sample text.\\n\\nThe invariant is generic:\\n\\n- Every held/debt item recorded at Now-32 entry must remain held/debt unless a traceable, explicit QA/repair/evidence contract authorizes a status change.\\n- The status monitor must iterate over a held/debt manifest and compare stable IDs and statuses.\\n- Current facts such as `240` held rows and chapter 18 being `held_only_no_ready_drafts` may be reported as factual state, but runtime gates must use manifest-driven rules rather than hardcoded chapter-specific conditions.\\n\\n## Allowed Transitions\\n\\nNow-32 control-plane hardening may:\\n\\n- Create or update definition-phase contracts in docs/control-plane files.\\n- Record advisory consultation metadata and parse status as advisory-only.\\n- Define template schemas and template rules without producing real evidence rows.\\n- Run dry-run validation checks that only read, compare, hash, or parse.\\n- Update short-entry control-plane files to point to the landed contract and advisory basis.\\n\\n## Blocked Transitions\\n\\nNow-32 control-plane hardening must block:\\n\\n- Any `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint` change.\\n- Any policy flag transition from false to true for provider/manual/media/evidence/feedback/repair/replay/KG/overlay/output-index/production acceptance.\\n- Any held/debt row promotion without an explicit downstream contract.\\n- Any real evidence row in manual/provider/operator/evidence/production locations.\\n- Any activation of Now-33/34/35/36.\\n- Any outputs-index mutation.\\n- Any provider job or media-generation path.\\n\\n## Required Control-Plane Fields\\n\\nControl-plane files should keep these fields synchronized:\\n\\n- `now32_control_plane_hardening_status`\\n- `now32_control_plane_hardening_contract`\\n- `now32_control_plane_hardening_deepseek_round1`\\n- `now32_control_plane_hardening_deepseek_round1_parse_repair`\\n- `now32_control_plane_hardening_deepseek_round2`\\n- `now32_control_plane_hardening_advisory_basis`\\n- `now32_evidence_taxonomy_status`\\n- `now32_manual_execution_log_contract_status`\\n- `now32_held_entity_invariant`\\n- `now32_pre_execution_gate_status`\\n\\n## Preflight Checks\\n\\nBefore any future Now-32 closeout, candidate-route activation, or manual/provider/evidence work, run these checks:\\n\\n- Confirm `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint.id == platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`.\\n- Confirm current workflow remains `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`.\\n- Confirm P2V-24 forbidden side-effect counts remain zero.\\n- Confirm advisory records carry `advisory_only=true`, provider/model/thinking metadata, raw/unavailable status, input/message fingerprints, and parse status.\\n- Confirm all template artifacts carry `TEMPLATE_ONLY_DO_NOT_EXECUTE` and have no operational fields populated.\\n- Confirm no manual/provider/operator evidence entries exist unless explicitly authorized by a future contract.\\n- Confirm held/debt manifests preserve status for every recorded held/debt item.\\n- Confirm no runtime branch uses work title, entity name, character name, block title, sample text, or specific chapter title.\\n- Confirm Now-33/34/35/36 remain candidate-blocked unless an explicit activation contract exists.\\n\\n## Verification Commands\\n\\n- `python -m json.tool workflow.json >/dev/null && python -m json.tool execution_state.json >/dev/null && python -m json.tool phase_acceptance.json >/dev/null && python -m json.tool workflow_index.json >/dev/null && python -m json.tool retrospective_state.json >/dev/null`\\n- `PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 PYTHONPATH=src python scripts/workflow_guard.py --root .`\\n- `PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 PYTHONPATH=src:. pytest -q tests/test_p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout.py`\\n- `git diff --c\",\n    \"hard_boundaries\": [\n      \"Do not change execution_state.json.next_entrypoint.\",\n      \"Do not execute provider jobs or media generation.\",\n      \"Do not create filled manual/provider/operator evidence.\",\n      \"Do not ingest feedback, execute repair/replay, write overlays/KG, or mutate outputs index.\",\n      \"Do not activate Now-33/34/35/36; only recommend candidate direction unless explicit activation contract exists.\",\n      \"DeepSeek remains advisory-only and cannot become evidence, operator acceptance, KG/overlay/replay/writeback, route authority, or outputs index authority.\",\n      \"Held/debt facts may be reported, but runtime/control gates must be manifest-driven, not chapter/entity/title/sample-specific.\"\n    ]\n  },\n  \"round1_ref\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/project_retrospective_post_now32_deepseek_consultation_20260606_0300\",\n  \"round1_parsed\": {\n    \"parse_status\": \"pass\",\n    \"overall_verdict\": \"The project has successfully completed the P计划 V2 pipeline rebuild and Now-32 control-plane hardening, establishing a traceable, governed readiness pipeline. The durable advantage lies in the production graph—entity links, asset binding, shot-level traceability—not one‑off prose generation. The mainline must now progress toward entity‑linked, asset‑bound, industry‑aligned production packets, with explicit operator activation contracts required for each step. The 240 held rows and chapter‑18 readiness debt remain blockers to any production acceptance claim. DeepSeek advisory remains a powerful, non‑voting consultant and must never become evidence or authority.\",\n    \"project_goal_alignment\": [\n      \"P计划 V2 rebuilt the pipeline from source constraints through neutral prompt readiness, achieving traceability, packaging, and debt registration—directly serving the program‑first goal up to the 'provider‑neutral prompt packet' stage.\",\n      \"Now‑32 control‑plane hardening defined evidence taxonomy and a manual execution log contract, reinforcing the required separation of advisory, readiness, evidence, acceptance, and execution layers.\",\n      \"The pipeline now holds 1638 neutral draft rows with readiness labels, ready for the next phases of entity‑/asset‑binding and industry schema alignment, exactly as targeted by the project goal.\",\n      \"Remaining work (entity linking, asset binding, industry benchmark integration, reviewer harness, evidence pack assembly) maps directly to the 'source → KG → entity/context → … → provider‑neutral prompt packet / adapter payload → review/handoff' chain.\",\n      \"Providers are correctly treated as adapter/benchmark/feedback targets; no provider‑specific schema has been allowed to corrupt the canonical neutral packets.\"\n    ],\n    \"actual_landed_work\": [\n      \"P计划 V2 closed after P2V24 final closeout: 20 chapter packages, 1638 neutral draft rows, 240 held rows, 247 debt rows, deterministic validators, traceability summary, readiness debt register, Now‑32 handoff calibration, final review HTML, focused tests (3 passed).\",\n      \"Now‑32 control‑plane hardening contract landed and validated: evidence taxonomy (advisory/template/manual/provider/operator/pending), manual execution log contract schema with template‑only rules, held‑entity invariant, allowed/blocked transition policies, preflight checks, and dry‑run verification commands.\",\n      \"Two‑round DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max advisory protocol executed for Now‑32 hardening; Round 1 parse repair applied transparently; Round 2 critique returned pass/high confidence.\",\n      \"DeepSeek advisory records created as advisory‑only, with full provider/model/thinking metadata, input fingerprints, raw responses, and parse status.\",\n      \"Control‑plane files synchronized: now32_control_plane_hardening_status, evidence taxonomy status, manual execution log contract status, held‑entity invariant, pre‑execution gate status.\",\n      \"P2V24 final report and Now‑32 hardening contract both confirm zero forbidden side‑effect counts and unchanged execution_state.json.next_entrypoint.\"\n    ],\n    \"not_landed_or_blocked\": [\n      \"Provider‑specific prompt rendering, adapter payload creation, provider dispatch, media generation.\",\n      \"Filled manual/provider/operator evidence entries, operator production acceptance, evidence manifests with live data.\",\n      \"Feedback intake, repair execution, replay actions, accepted/operator overlay writeback, canonical/raw KG writeback, outputs index mutation.\",\n      \"Resolution of the 240 held rows and chapter‑18 readiness debt (requires explicit repair/QA contract).\",\n      \"Activation of any candidate mainline Now‑33, Now‑34, Now‑35, or Now‑36.\",\n      \"Runtime branching by work title, entity name, character name, block title, or sample text.\",\n      \"Any claim of production readiness or evidence‑backed execution.\"\n    ],\n    \"retrospective_findings\": [\n      \"The P计划 V2 rebuild successfully transformed the pipeline from an ad‑hoc creative‑quality prototype into a traceable, packageable, and reviewable production‑oriented system, proving the program‑first approach.\",\n      \"The layered governance model (advisory/readiness/evidence/acceptance/execution) is now structurally enforced via contracts, policy flags, and control‑plane fields, significantly reducing the risk of accidental authority leakage.\",\n      \"The pipeline’s durable value lies in its ability to produce a stable production graph—KG/entity links, asset references, shot‑level binding—rather than competing on one‑off literary script quality with direct LLM generation.\",\n      \"Now‑32 hardening has established a rigorous evidence boundary, but real manual/provider evidence remains hypothetical until an explicit execution contract authorizes it; the manual execution log contract is defined but untested with live data.\",\n      \"The 240 held rows and chapter‑18 held‑only status constitute visible, registered readiness debt that must be transparently addressed before any production acceptance or evidence pack assembly.\",\n      \"The candidate mainlines Now‑33..36 provide a logical, gated technical progression that aligns with industry benchmarks (Seedance, 微光巢穴) and reinforces the production‑graph advantage; their sequential activation, controlled by operator contracts, preserves control‑plane integrity.\",\n      \"DeepSeek advisory protocol has demonstrated high‑quality, dialectical guidance for governance decisions without contaminating evidence, acceptance, or production layers—a pattern worth extending as a formal review harness (Now‑35).\",\n      \"The project’s current fragility centers on the unresolved held‑row debt and the absence of any end‑to‑end evidence flow; until a repair contract and at least one manual evidence exercise are completed, production readiness cannot be demonstrated.\"\n    ],\n    \"risks_and_debt\": [\n      \"240 held rows and chapter‑18 readiness debt persist; if not resolved via an explicit repair/QA contract before or during Now‑33/34, they will block production acceptance and erode trust in the readiness labels.\",\n      \"Manual execution log contract remains schematic; without at least one authorized manual evidence exercise, latent design gaps (e.g., chain‑of‑custody recording, operator authentication) cannot be validated.\",\n      \"Entity‑link and asset‑binding work (Now‑33) may introduce schema complexity that conflicts with existing neutral prompt packets; careful migration rules and backward‑compatibility validation are required.\",\n      \"Industry‑benchmark schema upgrade (Now‑34) risks creeping aesthetic or subjective judgment into hard validator gates; structural checks must be the only hard failures, with stylistic advisories kept separate.\",\n      \"DeepSeek reviewer integration (Now‑35) could be misinterpreted as a substitute for human acceptance if its advisory‑only nature is not rigorously enforced; automated acceptance or rejection by DeepSeek scores must remain forbidden.\",\n      \"Activation contracts that skip prerequisites (e.g., starting Now‑34 without completing Now‑33) could create fragmented artifacts and hidden debt; the recommended sequence must be respected.\",\n      \"The pipeline is a single‑developer, file‑based prototype; production scaling, multi‑user access, and secure key management for provider adapters are not yet addressed and may require a dedicated infrastructure hardening phase.\"\n    ],\n    \"mainline_recalibration\": [\n      \"Reaffirm the program‑first project goal: future work must optimize for entity‑linked, asset‑bound, traceable production packets—not for literary script quality alone. Industry benchmarks (Seedance, 微光巢穴) confirm the value of structured control packets with subject, action, camera language, reference assets, sound, and restrictions.\",\n      \"Adopt the candidate mainline sequence Now‑33 → Now‑34 → Now‑35 → Now‑36 as the primary technical progression, with each step gated by an explicit operator activation contract that defines scope, allowed mutations, and evidence boundaries.\",\n      \"Introduce a prerequisite 'Now‑32 Repair and Debt Clearance Contract' (or a parallel repair track) to address the 240 held rows and chapter‑18 readiness before production evidence pack assembly (Now‑36). This contract must define QA criteria, repair authorization limits, and evidence logging for any status promotions.\",\n      \"Strengthen Mainline 6 (Feedback, Repair, Replay) by ensuring that after Now‑36, future contracts explicitly close the loop: provider execution → evidence intake → automated review (including DeepSeek) → repair/replay actions, with all loops maintaining traceable provenance.\",\n      \"Maintain the two‑round DeepSeek consultant protocol for all high‑impact strategy, quality gate, schema design, and route transition decisions; record every consultation as an advisory‑only artifact.\",\n      \"Keep execution_state.json.next_entrypoint unchanged; any route transition (e.g., from Now‑32 to Now‑33) must be authorized by an explicit transition contract that verifies prerequisite completion and control‑plane invariants.\",\n      \"Continue to treat provider‑specific formats as adapter targets, not canonical schema owners; the provider‑neutral prompt packet must remain the source of truth and the foundation for all adapter payload rendering.\",\n      \"Schedule a post‑Now‑36 infrastructure audit to assess production scaling, access control, and secure credential management for provider adapters; this may become a future Now‑37 or separate infrastructure stream.\"\n    ],\n    \"recommended_sequence\": [\n      {\n        \"id\": \"now32_retrospective_and_recalibration_consolidation\",\n        \"status\": \"active_after_advisory\",\n        \"why\": \"Record the full retrospective and mainline recalibration as an advisory control‑plane artifact; update retrospective_state.json and workflow index without changing active route authority or execution state.\",\n        \"activation_boundary\": \"This advisory itself (returned JSON) must be recorded by the operator as a control‑plane document; no automated state mutation is authorized.\",\n        \"required_artifacts_or_contracts\": [\n          \"This retrospective JSON (to be stored as an advisory artifact)\",\n          \"Updated retrospective_state.json to reference the recalibration\",\n          \"Updated workflow_index.json entry noting retrospective completion (advisory)\",\n          \"Validation that execution_state.json.next_entrypoint remains unchanged\"\n        ]\n      },\n      {\n        \"id\": \"now32_repair_and_debt_clearance_contract\",\n        \"status\": \"recommended_candidate\",\n        \"why\": \"240 held rows and chapter‑18 readiness debt directly block production acceptance. An explicit repair/QA contract is needed to authorize triage, repair criteria, and evidence‑backed promotion of held rows to ready status where appropriate.\",\n        \"activation_boundary\": \"Operator issues an explicit Now‑32 Repair Contract defining allowed repair actions, QA gates, evidence log schema, and the maximum promotion that can occur. No automatic promotion is allowed; every change must be evidence‑gated.\",\n        \"required_artifacts_or_contracts\": [\n          \"Repair contract definition (scope, repair categories, QA rubrics)\",\n          \"Held‑row repair evidence log schema (manual/operator evidence entries)\",\n          \"Chapter‑18 readiness triage plan\",\n          \"Integration with Now‑32 manual execution log contract for any manual repair evidence\",\n          \"Policy: repair evidence is advisory‑gated but does not constitute production acceptance\"\n        ]\n      },\n      {\n        \"id\": \"now33_kg_entity_link_and_asset_binding\",\n        \"status\": \"candidate_blocked_until_explicit_contract\",\n        \"why\": \"Strengthens the production graph by binding neutral prompt rows to stable KG entities and reference assets, turning every shot into a traceable, asset‑linked production packet—directly serving the project goal.\",\n        \"activation_boundary\": \"Operator issues an explicit Now‑33 activation contract authorizing entity‑link and asset‑binding work. Canonical KG writeback remains blocked unless separately authorized; the contract must distinguish between read‑only linking and writeback.\",\n        \"required_artifacts_or_contracts\": [\n          \"Entity‑link manifest schema and linkage rules\",\n          \"Asset binding registry design with reference criteria\",\n          \"Disambiguation strategy for ambiguous entities\",\n          \"Migration plan for augmenting existing 1638 prompt rows with entity/asset refs (read‑only or overlay only)\",\n          \"Validation that no canonical KG is mutated without explicit KG writeback contract\"\n        ]\n      },\n      {\n        \"id\": \"now34_industry_benchmark_schema_and_gate_upgrade\",\n        \"status\": \"candidate_blocked_until_explicit_contract\",\n        \"why\": \"Translates industry resource constraints (Seedance, 微光巢穴, Dramart) into formal schema, validator, and QA rubric, aligning the pipeline’s prompt packets with real‑world production packet expectations.\",\n        \"activation_boundary\": \"Operator issues an explicit Now‑34 activation contract after Now‑33 is complete or an explicit decision to skip Now‑33 is recorded. The contract must forbid aesthetic judgments as hard gate failures.\",\n        \"required_artifacts_or_contracts\": [\n          \"VideoPromptPacket schema v2 (incorporating subject, action, camera language, reference assets, style, audio, restrictions)\",\n          \"Validator specifications and adversarial benchmark examples\",\n          \"Migration rules for approved rows to the new schema (non‑destructive read‑only application until acceptance)\",\n          \"Policy: hard failures only for structural violations; aesthetic/stylistic findings are advisory\"\n        ]\n      },\n      {\n        \"id\": \"now35_deepseek_consultant_as_reviewer\",\n        \"status\": \"candidate_blocked_until_explicit_contract\",\n        \"why\": \"Operationalizes DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max as a systematic, non‑voting reviewer for prompt readiness, entity consistency, asset binding, and industry compliance—providing high‑quality dialectical feedback without granting acceptance authority.\",\n        \"activation_boundary\": \"Operator issues an explicit Now‑35 activation contract, likely after Now‑34 or a decision that the review harness can be built in parallel. The contract must enforce advisory‑only status and forbid score‑based auto‑acceptance.\",\n        \"required_artifacts_or_contracts\": [\n          \"Review harness architecture and integration points\",\n          \"Scoring dimensions, calibration methodology, and inter‑rater comparison framework\",\n          \"Advisory log schema and review dashboard design\",\n          \"Policy: DeepSeek scores are advisory; they must never auto‑accept, auto‑reject, or mutate canonical data\"\n        ]\n      },\n      {\n        \"id\": \"now36_production_readiness_evidence_pack\",\n        \"status\": \"candidate_blocked_until_explicit_contract\",\n        \"why\": \"Assembles a self‑contained pre‑execution evidence pack that proves readiness for provider dispatch, disclosing all remaining debt and missing assets—the final governance gate before any provider execution.\",\n        \"activation_boundary\": \"Operator issues an explicit Now‑36 activation contract. Prerequisites: Now‑32 repair contract resolved most held/debt rows; Now‑33 and Now‑34 substantially complete; Now‑35 harness available for review. The evidence pack does not itself authorize execution.\",\n        \"required_artifacts_or_contracts\": [\n          \"Evidence pack structure and manifest schema\",\n          \"Mandatory gap analysis fields for held rows, missing assets, unresolved debts, and non‑ready chapters\",\n          \"Operator signature validity criteria and chain‑of‑custody rules\",\n          \"Integration with downstream deliverable format references (e.g., Dramart) as non‑execution formatting constraints only\",\n          \"Policy: assembly of the pack is not production acceptance; a separate operator acceptance step is required after review\"\n        ]\n      }\n    ],\n    \"control_plane_update_recommendations\": [\n      \"Record this full retrospective JSON as an advisory control‑plane artifact (e.g., outputs/retrospective_post_now32_round1_20260606.json) without mutating execution_state.json.next_entrypoint.\",\n      \"Update retrospective_state.json to reflect that the retrospective and mainline recalibration have been completed in advisory mode, with a reference to the artifact and the recommended sequence.\",\n      \"Add a brief entry to workflow_index.json or patchnote.md documenting the retrospective’s completion and the recommended mainline recalibration, flagged as advisory‑only.\",\n      \"Synchronize any short‑entry control‑plane fields (e.g., now32_retrospective_status) to point to this advisory, but keep all policy flags for provider execution and evidence false.\",\n      \"Run the prescribed verification commands (json‑tool, workflow_guard, pytest) to confirm that no forbidden state change has occurred as a side effect of recording the retrospective.\",\n      \"Do not create any new active route entry, execution state transition, or acceptance gate based on this retrospective; it remains strictly advisory.\"\n    ],\n    \"do_not_do\": [\n      \"Do not activate Now‑33, Now‑34, Now‑35, Now‑36, or any repair contract from this advisory alone; explicit operator activation contracts are mandatory.\",\n      \"Do not change execution_state.json.next_entrypoint or the active route authority.\",\n      \"Do not generate provider‑specific prompts, adapter payloads, provider jobs, media, or any filled evidence entries.\",\n      \"Do not treat DeepSeek output as provider evidence, operator acceptance, KG/overlay writeback, or outputs index authority.\",\n      \"Do not hardcode chapter titles, entity names, character names, or sample text in any control‑plane logic, validator, or gate.\",\n      \"Do not claim production readiness, operator acceptance, or evidence completeness while 240 held rows and chapter‑18 readiness debt remain unresolved.\",\n      \"Do not mutate outputs/index.json, outputs/index‑lite.json, or any canonical KG without an explicit, separate writeback contract.\"\n    ],\n    \"confidence\": \"high\"\n  },\n  \"required_response_schema\": {\n    \"parse_status\": \"pass\",\n    \"round2_verdict\": \"string\",\n    \"round1_confirmed_points\": [\n      \"string\"\n    ],\n    \"round1_corrections_or_overreach\": [\n      \"string\"\n    ],\n    \"final_project_retrospective\": [\n      \"string\"\n    ],\n    \"final_mainline_recalibration\": [\n      \"string\"\n    ],\n    \"final_recommended_sequence\": [\n      {\n        \"id\": \"string\",\n        \"status\": \"string\",\n        \"why\": \"string\",\n        \"activation_boundary\": \"string\",\n        \"must_not_do\": [\n          \"string\"\n        ]\n      }\n    ],\n    \"required_control_plane_updates\": [\n      \"string\"\n    ],\n    \"residual_risks\": [\n      \"string\"\n    ],\n    \"boundary_confirmations\": [\n      \"string\"\n    ],\n    \"confidence\": \"high|medium|low\"\n  }\n}",
    "role": "user"
  }
]