[
  {
    "content": "You are DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max acting as advisory-only external consultant for Novel2Video. Return JSON only. Do not claim evidence, route authority, production acceptance, or execution authorization.",
    "role": "system"
  },
  {
    "content": "{\n  \"version\": \"project_retrospective_post_now32_round1_input.v1\",\n  \"created_at\": \"2026-06-05T19:00:38.848502Z\",\n  \"role\": \"DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max independent project retrospective consultant; advisory only.\",\n  \"task\": \"After Now-32 control-plane hardening landed, provide full project retrospective and mainline recalibration aligned to project goal. Scope options, risks, artifacts, and recommended next candidate direction. Return JSON only.\",\n  \"context\": {\n    \"project\": \"Novel2Video / novel2video-writer-core\",\n    \"operator_request\": \"Now-32 如果已经收口完毕，请进行完整项目复盘，并用复盘结果结合项目目标校正后续主线更新方向。\",\n    \"current_date_local\": \"2026-06-06T03:00:00+08:00\",\n    \"project_goal\": \"Build a program-first pipeline: source -> KG -> entity/context -> scene/chronology -> adaptation -> AI-executable screenplay -> shooting_script -> shot context -> provider-neutral prompt packet / adapter payload -> review/handoff -> feedback/repair/replay. Providers are adapter/benchmark/feedback/diagnostic targets, not canonical schema owners.\",\n    \"authority_order\": [\n      \"execution_state.json.next_entrypoint\",\n      \"phase_acceptance.json\",\n      \"workflow.json\",\n      \"AGENTS.md\",\n      \"todo.md\",\n      \"projectreport.md\",\n      \"patchnote.md\"\n    ],\n    \"active_route_authority\": {\n      \"id\": \"platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract\",\n      \"title\": \"Prompt Readiness QA And Manual Execution Log Contract\",\n      \"owner_layer\": \"Pipeline Orchestrator / Video Prompt Packet & Adapter Render Agent / Video Generation Agent / Provider Adapter & Payload Agent / QA & Consistency Agent / Visualization & Review UI Agent\",\n      \"why_now\": \"Now-32 remains the active evidence-gated route; P计划 V2 creative-quality work is a sidecar and does not authorize provider/manual/feedback execution.\"\n    },\n    \"phase_acceptance_gate_status\": \"open\",\n    \"current_status\": \"now32_control_plane_hardening_contract_landed_validated\",\n    \"current_implementation_priority\": \"Now-32_control_plane_hardening_contract_landed_validated\",\n    \"current_p_plan_stage\": \"P计划_V2_closed_after_P2V24_final_closeout\",\n    \"now32_contract_status\": \"now32_control_plane_hardening_contract_landed_validated\",\n    \"p2v24_key_counts\": {\n      \"chapter_package_count\": 20,\n      \"draft_row_count\": 1638,\n      \"held_row_count\": 240,\n      \"fully_ready_chapter_count\": 13,\n      \"partial_or_held_chapter_count\": 7,\n      \"debt_row_count\": 247,\n      \"chapter_readiness_debt_count\": 7,\n      \"held_row_debt_count\": 240,\n      \"provider_prompt_syntax_count\": 0,\n      \"production_lane_accepted_count\": 0,\n      \"validator_failure_count\": 0,\n      \"provider_prompt_count\": 0,\n      \"adapter_payload_count\": 0,\n      \"provider_job_execution_count\": 0,\n      \"media_generation_count\": 0,\n      \"manual_provider_evidence_count\": 0,\n      \"operator_evidence_creation_count\": 0,\n      \"feedback_intake_count\": 0,\n      \"repair_execution_count\": 0,\n      \"replay_action_count\": 0,\n      \"accepted_overlay_write_count\": 0,\n      \"operator_overlay_write_count\": 0,\n      \"canonical_kg_writeback_count\": 0,\n      \"raw_kg_writeback_count\": 0,\n      \"outputs_index_mutation_count\": 0\n    },\n    \"p2v24_report\": {\n      \"final_closeout_status\": \"p_plan_ready_to_close_pending_deepseek_advisory_and_control_plane_sync\",\n      \"p_plan_proved\": [\n        \"Operator-accepted C-version director-level script constraints were converted into structured extraction and validation constraints.\",\n        \"First20 pipeline director scripts were generated, structurally extracted, packetized, neutral-drafted, and packaged with traceability.\",\n        \"Strong direct DeepSeek output remains a challenger/repair oracle, not a silent replacement lane.\",\n        \"DeepSeek advisory became a standing expert consultation lane while remaining advisory-only.\",\n        \"Now-32 remains the route for provider/manual/evidence work.\"\n      ],\n      \"remaining_debt\": [\n        \"240 held rows remain pending explicit QA/repair/evidence contract.\",\n        \"Chapter 18 remains held_only_no_ready_drafts and must not be promoted to ready.\",\n        \"Provider/manual/media execution has not started and is outside P计划 closeout.\"\n      ],\n      \"now32_handoff_status\": \"ready_for_now32_planning_pending_evidence_not_execution\",\n      \"production_lane_accepted\": false,\n      \"provider_manual_execution_allowed\": false\n    },\n    \"p2v24_traceability\": {\n      \"input_fingerprint\": \"86d518b490df279b93282eab2e912f0df6de97bcaaeddf35f3873905f3e6e3e4\",\n      \"p2v23_counts\": {\n        \"chapter_package_count\": 20,\n        \"neutral_draft_row_count\": 1638,\n        \"held_row_count\": 240,\n        \"fully_ready_chapter_count\": 13,\n        \"partial_or_held_chapter_count\": 7,\n        \"readiness_label_counts\": {\n          \"partial_ready_with_holds\": 6,\n          \"ready_for_now32_packaging\": 13,\n          \"held_only_no_ready_drafts\": 1\n        }\n      },\n      \"p2v23_traceability\": {\n        \"all_draft_rows_represented\": true,\n        \"all_held_rows_represented\": true,\n        \"missing_draft_row_ids\": [],\n        \"missing_held_row_ids\": [],\n        \"duplicate_draft_row_ids\": [],\n        \"duplicate_held_row_ids\": []\n      },\n      \"debt_register_counts\": {\n        \"chapter_readiness_debt\": 7,\n        \"held_row_debt\": 240\n      }\n    },\n    \"now32_handoff\": {\n      \"handoff_status\": \"ready_for_now32_planning_pending_evidence_not_execution\",\n      \"readiness_package_ref\": {\n        \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p_plan_v2_23_prompt_readiness_packaging_boundary_20260605_0730/P2V_23_prompt_readiness_package.json\",\n        \"exists\": true,\n        \"sha256\": \"a57ebbac6bef7390e5f5ff4abf46c479f3cd2f612fb66f356541dab5eee748d5\",\n        \"size_bytes\": 11758\n      },\n      \"neutral_draft_row_count\": 1638,\n      \"held_row_count\": 240,\n      \"debt_row_count\": 247,\n      \"chapter_18_status\": \"held_only_no_ready_drafts\",\n      \"requires_future_contracts\": [\n        \"manual_or_provider_execution_evidence_contract\",\n        \"held_row_QA_or_repair_contract\",\n        \"feedback_repair_replay_contract_if_real_feedback_exists\"\n      ],\n      \"blocked_work\": [\n        \"provider_specific_prompt_rendering\",\n        \"adapter_payload_creation\",\n        \"provider_job_execution\",\n        \"media_generation\",\n        \"manual_provider_operator_evidence_creation\",\n        \"feedback_intake\",\n        \"repair_execution\",\n        \"replay_execution\",\n        \"accepted_or_operator_overlay_writeback\",\n        \"canonical_or_raw_KG_writeback\",\n        \"outputs_index_mutation\",\n        \"old_B7_continuation\"\n      ],\n      \"policy\": {\n        \"stage\": \"P计划_V2_24_p_plan_final_closeout\",\n        \"p_plan_final_closeout_only\": true,\n        \"provider_specific_prompt_allowed\": false,\n        \"adapter_payload_allowed\": false,\n        \"provider_job_execution_allowed\": false,\n        \"media_generation_allowed\": false,\n        \"manual_provider_evidence_creation_allowed\": false,\n        \"operator_evidence_creation_allowed\": false,\n        \"feedback_intake_allowed\": false,\n        \"repair_execution_allowed\": false,\n        \"replay_execution_allowed\": false,\n        \"accepted_overlay_writeback_allowed\": false,\n        \"operator_overlay_writeback_allowed\": false,\n        \"canonical_kg_writeback_allowed\": false,\n        \"raw_kg_writeback_allowed\": false,\n        \"outputs_index_mutation_allowed\": false,\n        \"operator_production_acceptance_claimed\": false,\n        \"deepseek_advisory_may_substitute_for_expert_advice\": true,\n        \"deepseek_advisory_is_operator_production_acceptance\": false,\n        \"runtime_branch_by_work_title_entity_name_or_sample_text_allowed\": false,\n        \"active_route_authority\": \"execution_state.json.next_entrypoint\",\n        \"execution_state_next_entrypoint_unchanged\": true\n      }\n    },\n    \"retrospective_state_summary\": {\n      \"outcome\": \"p_plan_v2_closed_after_p2v24_final_closeout\",\n      \"summary\": \"P2V-24 P计划 final closeout completed after deterministic final gate/report generation, source-to-readiness traceability summary, readiness debt register, Now-32 handoff calibration, focused tests, DeepSeek advisory, and final retrospective. Final closeout preserves 20 chapter packages, 1638 neutral draft rows, 240 held rows, fully-ready/partial-or-held chapters=13/7, debt register rows=247 (7 chapter readiness + 240 held-row debt), validator_failure_count=0, provider_prompt_syntax_count=0, forbidden side-effect counts=0. DeepSeek advisory supports P2V-24 with finding/blocker/high/medium/low=2/0/0/0/2 and recommends mark_P计划_closed_and_continue_Now32_evidence_gate. P计划 is closed as an implementation umbrella; Now-32 next_entrypoint remains unchanged and evidence/provider/manual work still requires explicit contract/evidence.\",\n      \"actual_landed\": [\n        \"P2V-24 code module, deterministic runner, DeepSeek runner, and focused tests landed.\",\n        \"Final P2V-24 deterministic run exists at outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742 with final report, traceability summary, debt register, Now-32 handoff calibration, and final HTML.\",\n        \"DeepSeek advisory passed and recommended marking P计划 closed while continuing Now-32 evidence gate.\",\n        \"P2V-24 final closeout retrospective landed and P计划 control plane is marked closed.\",\n        \"Now-32 control-plane hardening contract landed as a post-P计划 active-route control artifact.\",\n        \"Two-round DeepSeek advisory basis recorded for Now-32 hardening; Round 1 parse repaired transparently and Round 2 passed.\"\n      ],\n      \"not_landed\": [\n        \"Provider-specific prompts, adapter payloads, provider/media execution, manual/provider/operator evidence, feedback/replay, KG/overlay writeback, outputs index mutation, and old B7 continuation remain unlanded and blocked.\",\n        \"Held-row repair and chapter 18 readiness repair remain future explicit-contract work.\",\n        \"Now-32 hardening does not land real manual/provider/operator evidence, provider execution, feedback/repair/replay, KG/overlay writeback, outputs index mutation, or Now-33/34/35/36 activation.\"\n      ],\n      \"fragility_or_debt\": [\n        \"240 held rows remain visible readiness debt.\",\n        \"Chapter 18 remains held_only_no_ready_drafts.\",\n        \"P计划 closeout is not production acceptance.\",\n        \"Control-plane hardening must avoid content-specific runtime branching; held/debt checks are manifest-driven.\"\n      ],\n      \"next_stage_recommendation\": \"P计划 is closed. Continue through Now-32 control-plane hardening/evidence taxonomy only; future manual/provider/evidence/repair/activation work requires explicit contract.\"\n    },\n    \"workflow_index_notes\": [\n      \"P计划 V2 is closed after P2V-24 final closeout.\",\n      \"Now-32 next_entrypoint remains the active route authority and is unchanged.\",\n      \"Final closeout preserves 1638 neutral draft rows, 240 held rows, and 247 debt rows.\",\n      \"Chapter 18 remains held_only_no_ready_drafts and must not be promoted without future explicit repair/evidence contract.\",\n      \"DeepSeek delegated advice may substitute for expert consultation but not production acceptance or evidence writeback.\",\n      \"Provider/manual/feedback/KG/overlay/replay/output-index work remains blocked until explicit contract.\",\n      \"Post-P计划 candidate mainlines Now-33..36 are defined but inactive; Now-32 remains active route authority.\",\n      \"New thread handoff prompt is updated in docs/midterm_autopilot_prompt.md.\",\n      \"Short-entry control-plane files are compacted; historical P/P2V detail remains in patchnote.md, workflow.json, docs, and outputs.\",\n      \"Now-32 control-plane hardening contract landed; validated.\",\n      \"Round 1 DeepSeek advisory parse was deterministically repaired for one duplicate comma, then Round 2 repaired critique passed.\"\n    ],\n    \"candidate_strategy_excerpt\": \"# Post-P计划 Now-32..36 Candidate Mainline Strategy\\n\\n更新时间：`2026-06-05T13:42:00+08:00`\\n\\n## Status\\n\\n- Current active route: `Now-32 / Prompt-Readiness-Manual-Execution-Log-Contract`\\n- Active route authority: `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`\\n- P计划 status: `P计划_V2_closed_after_P2V24_final_closeout`\\n- This document is a definition-phase strategy record only. It does not activate Now-33, Now-34, Now-35, or Now-36.\\n- `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint` must remain `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`.\\n\\n## Evidence Basis\\n\\n- Operator direction on 2026-06-05: keep DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max as standing third-party consultant; use its advice dialectically; require at least two deep consultation rounds for high-impact strategy, quality gate, and schema decisions.\\n- Round 1 DeepSeek consultation: `outputs/post_p_plan_now32_36_strategy_deepseek_consultation_20260605_1232`\\n- Round 2 DeepSeek critique/refinement: `outputs/post_p_plan_now32_36_strategy_deepseek_consultation_round2_20260605_1245`\\n- Industry resources inspected:\\n  - `docs/resource/【对客】Doubao-Seedance-2.0：企业级业务场景指南.zip`\\n  - `docs/resource/火山剧创优秀短剧作品赏析--动画短片 PV 剧本：《微光巢穴》.zip`\\n- Format reference resource classified for Now-36:\\n  - `docs/resource/Dramart_标准剧本格式参考_1775308799.pdf`\\n  - sha256: `2d1dfa9e989c2218ca10115d9e2b11d5f791c7a43bd99511c78e49f0a5324f30`\\n  - size: `4708454` bytes\\n  - classification: Dramart script format reference only; not a creative-quality benchmark, not a schema migration trigger, and not an active production/evidence artifact.\\n\\n## Strategic Diagnosis\\n\\nThe pipeline should not define its value as beating `deepseek_strong_direct` in one-off prose quality. Direct generation can produce strong scripts, but it does not reliably produce a stable production graph.\\n\\nThe pipeline's durable advantage is:\\n\\n- stable KG/entity links for characters, locations, props, motifs, organizations, and narrative functions;\\n- shot-level binding from screenplay text to entity refs, location refs, prop refs, source refs, and reference assets;\\n- provider-neutral production packet lineage;\\n- deterministic validators, debt registers, review surfaces, and handoff logs;\\n- explicit separation of advisory, readiness, evidence, acceptance, and production execution.\\n\\nIndustry benchmark resources reinforce this direction. The Seedance guide treats production prompts as structured control packets: subject, action, camera language, reference assets, style/aesthetics, audio/SFX, and restrictions. The `微光巢穴` sample treats script output as a production bible: high-level style and tempo, scene/dialogue layer, time-coded shot layer, character/prop/scene asset tables, and sound/subtitle/action rhythm.\\n\\nTherefore, future work should optimize toward asset-linked, entity-linked, traceable production packets, not literary script text alone.\\n\\n## Candidate Mainlines\\n\\n### Now-32 Active: Prompt Readiness QA And Manual Execution Log Contract\\n\\nObjective: Keep the active evidence gate after P计划 closeout. Now-32 governs readiness handoff, manual execution log structure, and evidence boundaries.\\n\\nStatus: `active`\\n\\nAllowed now:\\n\\n- Define and inspect readiness/handoff controls.\\n- Keep held-row debt explicit.\\n- Prepare manual/evidence contract details without generating provider evidence.\\n- Record DeepSeek advisory as advisory-only.\\n\\nBlocked:\\n\\n- Provider execution.\\n- Media generation.\\n- Manual/provider/operator evidence creation.\\n- Feedback intake, repair replay, KG/overlay writeback, outputs index mutation, production acceptance.\\n\\n### Now-33 Candidate: KG/Entity-Link And Asset Binding Strengthening\\n\\nObjective: Define and, after explicit activation only, bind prompt/readiness rows to stable KG/entity refs and reference assets so every shot becomes part of a traceable production graph.\\n\\nStatus: `candidate_blocked_until_explicit_contract`\\n\\nActivation condition: operator issues an explicit Now-33 activation contract authorizing entity-link and asset-binding work, with canonical KG writeback remaining blocked unless separately authorized.\\n\\nDefinition-phase allowed work:\\n\\n- Design entity-link and asset-binding schemas for prompt packets.\\n- Define linkage rules, disambiguation strategy, and asset binding criteria.\\n- Create templates for `entity_link_manifest` and `asset_binding_registry`.\\n\\nBlocked until activation:\\n\\n- Running automated entity extraction/linking against production rows.\\n- Augmenting prompt packets with `entity_refs` or `asset_refs`.\\n- Mutating draft rows, prompt packets, canonical KG, accepted overlays, or production data.\\n\\n### Now-34 Candidate: Industry-Benchmark Schema And Gate Upgrade\\n\\nObjective: Translate the industry resource constraints into formal schema, validator, QA rubric, and benchmark-gate requirements.\\n\\nStatus: `candidate_blocked_until_explicit_contract`\\n\\nActivation condition: operator issues an explicit Now-34 activation contract after Now-33 completion or an explicit decision to skip Now-33.\\n\\nDefinition-phase allowed work:\\n\\n- Draft VideoPromptPacket schema v2 based on Seedance and `微光巢穴` benchmark patterns.\\n- Define validator specs and adversarial benchmark examples.\\n- Design migration rules for future approved rows.\\n\\nBlocked until activation:\\n\\n- Applying schema migration to actual prompt packets.\\n- Running validators on production data.\\n- Enforcing aesthetic or stylistic judgments as hard gate failures beyond structural checks.\\n\\n### Now-35 Candidate: DeepSeek Consultant-As-Reviewer Systematic Integration\\n\\nObjective: Operationalize DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max as a standing non-voting reviewer for prompt readiness, entity consistency, asset binding, and industry compliance.\\n\\nStatus: `candidate_blocked_until_explicit_contract`\\n\\nActivation condition: operator issues an explicit Now-35 activation contract, likely after Now-34, to build/run the review harness against approved rows.\\n\\nDefinition-phase allowed work:\\n\\n- Design review harness architecture.\\n- Define scoring dimensions, calibration methodology, and inter-rater comparison plan.\\n- Define advisory log schema and review dashboard design.\\n\\nBlocked until activation:\\n\\n- Building or executing automated review harnesses on prompt packets.\\n- Storing DeepSeek scores in evidence or production indexes.\\n- Using DeepSeek scores to auto-accept or auto-reject prompts.\\n\\n### Now-36 Candidate: Production Readiness Evidence Pack Assembly\\n\\nObjective: Assemble a self-contained pre-execution evidence pack proving readiness for provider dispatch, still without executing provider calls.\\n\\nStatus: `candidate_blocked_until_explicit_contract`\\n\\nActivation condition: operator issues an explicit Now-36 activation contract after prior candidate mainlines complete and required artifacts exist.\\n\\nDefinition-phase allowed work:\\n\\n- Design evidence pack structure and manifest schema.\\n- Define mandatory gap analysis fields for held rows, missing assets, unresolved debts, and non-ready chapters.\\n- Define operator signature validity criteria.\\n- Register downstream deliverable-format references, including Dramart script format references, as non-execution formatting constraints for future evidence pack design.\\n\\nBlocked until activation:\\n\\n- Compiling, generating, or signing an evidence pack.\\n- Claiming production readiness.\\n- Triggering downstream execution.\\n- Applying Dramart formatting to production packets or treating format conformance as provider execution readiness before Now-36 activation.\\n\\n## Two-Round DeepSeek Consultant Protocol\\n\\nFor any high-impact strategy, quality gate, schema design, route transition, evidence contract, or production-readiness decision:\\n\\n1. Minimum two DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max consultation rounds are required before finalizing the advisory basis.\\n2. Round 1 is scoping and initial advice: options, risks, artifacts, gates, and recommended direction.\\n3. Round 2 is critique and refinement: explicitly review Round 1 for overreach, hallucination, boundary violations, missing assumptions, and operator constraints; confirm or correct each major point.\\n4. If the operator adds material constraints or resources between rounds, Round 2 must address them. If the new information materially changes the advice basis, run a third round.\\n5. Consultation records must preserve input refs/fingerprints, provider/model/thinking metadata, raw response, parsed result, parse status, and skipped/timeout/unavailable status.\\n6. DeepSeek output may serve as final expert advice basis under operator delegation, but never becomes provider evidence, manual execution evidence, operator production acceptance, accepted/operator overlay, canonical/raw KG writeback, feedback intake, replay action, runtime route authority, or outputs index mutation.\\n7. DeepSeek must not propose runtime branching by work title, character/entity name, block title, or sample text. Recommendations must be generic and structural.\\n\\n## Control Plane Actions\\n\\n- Keep `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint` unchanged.\\n- Record candidate mainlines as inactive/future routes only.\\n- Record the two-round consultant protocol as a standing governance rule.\\n- Add the two consultation output directories as advisory artifacts.\\n- Keep provider/manual/feedback/KG/overlay/replay/output-index work blocked until explicit contract.\\n\\n## Do Not Do\\n\\n- Do not advance Now-33, Now-34, Now-35, or Now-36 implementation from this document alone.\\n- Do not treat DeepSeek advisory as evidence or acceptance.\\n- Do not mutate prompt packets, entity links, KG, overlays, generated indexes, or evidence stores in definition phase.\\n- Do not claim production readiness while held rows, chapter 18 held-only status, or missing assets remain unresolved or undisclosed.\\n\",\n    \"p2v24_retrospective_excerpt\": \"# P计划 V2-24 Final Closeout Retrospective\\n\\n更新时间：`2026-06-05T07:48:00+08:00`\\n\\n## Stage\\n\\n- stage_id: `P计划_V2_24_p_plan_final_closeout`\\n- implementation umbrella: `P计划 / Pipeline Rebuild Plan` V2 creative-quality redesign sidecar\\n- active route authority: `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`\\n- active route unchanged: `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`\\n- outcome: `P计划_V2_closed_after_P2V24_final_closeout`\\n\\nP2V-24 generated the final P计划 closeout gate/report, source-to-readiness traceability summary, readiness debt register, Now-32 handoff calibration, final review HTML, focused tests, and DeepSeek advisory. It did not create provider-specific prompts, adapter payloads, provider jobs, media, manual/provider/operator evidence, feedback, repair execution, replay actions, KG/overlay writeback, production acceptance, or output-index mutations.\\n\\n## Macro Mainline Served\\n\\n- Mainline 0: Governance And Evidence\\n- Mainline 5: Structured Production Packet\\n- Mainline 6: Feedback, Repair, Replay, boundary planning only\\n\\n## Actual Landed Work\\n\\n- Code module: `src/novel2video/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout.py`\\n- Deterministic runner: `scripts/run_p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout.py`\\n- DeepSeek advisory runner: `scripts/run_p_plan_v2_24_deepseek_advisory.py`\\n- Focused tests: `tests/test_p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout.py`\\n- Deterministic run: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742`\\n- DeepSeek advisory: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_deepseek_advisory_20260605_0743`\\n\\n## Evidence Basis\\n\\n### Deterministic Run\\n\\n- run: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742`\\n- gate: `pending_deepseek_advisory_and_final_control_plane_sync` / `p2v_24_final_closeout_pass_pending_deepseek_and_control_plane_sync`\\n- validator: `pass`\\n- chapter packages preserved: `20`\\n- neutral draft rows preserved: `1638`\\n- held rows preserved: `240`\\n- fully ready chapters: `13`\\n- partial-or-held chapters: `7`\\n- debt register rows: `247`\\n- chapter readiness debt rows: `7`\\n- held-row debt rows: `240`\\n- provider prompt syntax count: `0`\\n- production lane accepted count: `0`\\n- validator failures: `0`\\n- forbidden side-effect counts: `0`\\n\\nKey artifacts:\\n\\n- final gate: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_final_closeout_gate.json`\\n- final report: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_final_closeout_report.json`\\n- traceability summary: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_source_to_readiness_traceability_summary.json`\\n- readiness debt register: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_readiness_debt_register.jsonl`\\n- Now-32 handoff calibration: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_now32_handoff_calibration.json`\\n- final review HTML: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_final_closeout_review.html`\\n\\n### DeepSeek Advisory\\n\\n- run: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_deepseek_advisory_20260605_0743`\\n- gate: `pass` / `deepseek_advisory_supports_p2v_24_p_plan_final_closeout`\\n- verdict: `supports_p2v_24_p_plan_final_closeout`\\n- parse status: `pass`\\n- finding/blocker/high/medium/low: `2/0/0/0/2`\\n- recommended next entrypoint: `mark_P计划_closed_and_continue_Now32_evidence_gate`\\n\\nDeepSeek assessment:\\n\\n- final closeout is structurally complete and traceable;\\n- all remaining debt is explicitly registered and transferred to Now-32/future contracts;\\n- no forbidden operations were detected;\\n- P计划 can be marked closed after final control-plane sync.\\n\\nDeepSeek low findings:\\n\\n- `240` held rows and `7` chapter readiness debt rows remain and must be honored after closeout.\\n- Boundary enforcement is complete; no side-effect finding requires repair.\\n\\nThese low findings are final state notes, not blockers.\\n\\n## Final Retrospective Findings\\n\\n1. P计划 achieved its rebuild objective.\\n\\nThe project now has a traceable path from the accepted C-version director-level script constraints through structured extraction, first20 generation, structured packetization, neutral prompt drafting, readiness packaging, and final closeout.\\n\\n2. The pipeline is valuable as a production system, not as a one-off creativity contest.\\n\\nP计划 preserved direct strong DeepSeek output as challenger/repair oracle while making pipeline output traceable, testable, packageable, and reviewable. That answers the earlier concern that a direct prompt can produce high-quality scripts: direct generation remains a benchmark and repair source; the pipeline provides repeatable structure, auditability, extraction, packaging, and controlled handoff.\\n\\n3. P计划 does not claim full production readiness.\\n\\n`13` chapters are ready for Now-32 planning, `7` are partial-or-held, and chapter 18 is explicitly `held_only_no_ready_drafts`. P计划 closes because the rebuild and handoff boundary are complete, not because every row is production-accepted.\\n\\n4. Now-32 remains the correct next route.\\n\\nP计划 final handoff status is `ready_for_now32_planning_pending_evidence_not_execution`. Any future provider/manual execution, held-row QA/repair, feedback/replay, adapter rendering, or accepted KG/overlay writes require explicit Now-32 or downstream evidence contracts.\\n\\n## Remaining Debt\\n\\n- `240` held rows remain pending explicit QA/repair/evidence contract.\\n- Chapter 18 remains `held_only_no_ready_drafts`.\\n- No provider job, media generation, manual/provider/operator evidence, feedback, repair/replay, KG/overlay writeback, adapter payload, provider-specific prompt rendering, or outputs index mutation has occurred.\\n- `outputs/index.json` and `outputs/index-lite.json` were not manually mutated.\\n\\n## Final Control-Plane Calibration\\n\\nRecommended state:\\n\\n- P计划 status: `P计划_V2_closed_after_P2V24_final_closeout`\\n- active route: `Now-32 / Prompt-Readiness-Manual-Execution-Log-Contract`\\n- active route authority: unchanged `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`\\n- next non-P计划 work: Now-32 evidence/manual/repair planning only under explicit contract.\\n\\nNo further P计划 substage is opened by this closeout.\\n\\n## Verification\\n\\n- `PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 PYTHONPATH=src:. pytest -q tests/test_p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout.py` -> `3 passed`\\n- `python -m py_compile src/novel2video/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout.py scripts/run_p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout.py scripts/run_p_plan_v2_24_deepseek_advisory.py` -> pass\\n- P2V-24 deterministic run: `PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 PYTHONPATH=src python scripts/run_p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout.py --output-run-dir outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742` -> `validator pass`\\n- P2V-24 DeepSeek advisory: `PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 PYTHONPATH=src python scripts/run_p_plan_v2_24_deepseek_advisory.py --source-run-dir outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742 --output-run-dir outputs/p_plan_v2_24_deepseek_advisory_20260605_0743 --timeout-seconds 1200 --call-watchdog-seconds 1260 --max-tokens 32000 --temperature 0.0` -> `pass`\\n\\n## Boundary Confirmation\\n\\n- `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint` unchanged.\\n- No provider job was executed.\\n- No image/audio/TTS/video/media was generated.\\n- No manual/provider/operator evidence was created.\\n- No feedback was ingested.\\n- No repair/replay action was executed.\\n- No accepted/operator overlay, canonical KG, raw KG, or replay writeback occurred.\\n- No `outputs/index.json` or `outputs/index-lite.json` mutation occurred.\\n- Old B7 downstream was not resumed.\\n\",\n    \"now32_hardening_contract_excerpt\": \"# Now-32 Prompt Readiness Manual Execution Control Plane Hardening Contract\\n\\n更新时间：`2026-06-06T01:57:11+08:00`\\n\\n## Status\\n\\n- stage: `Now-32 / Prompt-Readiness-Manual-Execution-Log-Contract`\\n- workflow: `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`\\n- active route authority: `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`\\n- required next_entrypoint: `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`\\n- status: `now32_control_plane_hardening_contract_landed_validated`\\n\\nThis contract lands Now-32 detail rules for prompt-readiness governance and manual-execution evidence boundaries. It does not authorize provider execution, media generation, filled manual/provider/operator evidence, feedback intake, repair/replay, KG/overlay writeback, outputs-index mutation, production acceptance, or activation of Now-33/34/35/36.\\n\\nValidation status: `pass`.\\n\\n## Advisory Basis\\n\\nThis is a high-impact evidence/control-plane contract, so two DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max advisory rounds were run and logged as advisory-only:\\n\\n- Round 1: `outputs/now32_control_plane_hardening_deepseek_consultation_20260606_0136`\\n- Round 1 parse repair: `outputs/now32_control_plane_hardening_deepseek_consultation_20260606_0136/consultation_parse_repair_record.json`\\n- Round 2 final critique: `outputs/now32_control_plane_hardening_deepseek_consultation_round2_repaired_20260606_0143`\\n\\nRound 1 raw response succeeded but contained one duplicate comma in `validation_commands_or_checks`; the repair removed only that duplicate punctuation and wrote `consultation_parsed_repaired.json`. Round 2 then critiqued the repaired Round 1 and returned `parse_status=pass`, `confidence=high`.\\n\\nDeepSeek remains advisory-only. It is not provider/manual/operator evidence, not production acceptance, not route authority, not KG/overlay/replay/writeback authority, and not outputs-index authority.\\n\\n## Scope\\n\\nNow-32 hardening owns these definition-phase controls:\\n\\n- Define and version-lock the future manual execution log contract schema.\\n- Establish evidence taxonomy and storage boundaries.\\n- Define template-only artifacts for future manual execution entries; templates must remain non-evidence and contain no operational data.\\n- Specify pre-execution gate conditions for any later manual evidence creation.\\n- Bind all blocked actions to policy flags and control-plane invariants.\\n- Provide dry-run validation and integrity checks that do not modify state.\\n- Preserve all held/debt rows as unresolved until an explicit QA/repair/evidence contract releases them.\\n- Record advisory consultations with full metadata and advisory-only classification.\\n\\n## Out Of Scope\\n\\nNow-32 hardening must not perform or imply:\\n\\n- Provider-specific prompt rendering, adapter payload creation, provider dispatch, or media generation.\\n- Filled manual/provider/operator evidence entries, evidence manifests with live data, operator signatures, or production acceptance.\\n- Feedback intake, repair execution, replay execution, or replay action records.\\n- Accepted/operator overlay writeback, canonical KG writeback, raw KG writeback, or generated outputs-index mutation.\\n- Now-33/34/35/36 activation or implementation.\\n- Runtime branching by work title, entity name, character name, block title, sample text, or specific chapter title.\\n\\n## Evidence Taxonomy\\n\\n`advisory`\\n\\n- Non-execution review output from DeepSeek or another reviewer.\\n- Must carry `advisory_only=true`, provider/model/thinking metadata, input/message fingerprints, raw response or unavailable status, and parse status.\\n- May inform design decisions.\\n- Never satisfies readiness, evidence, acceptance, KG, overlay, replay, provider, or output-index gates.\\n\\n`template`\\n\\n- Schema definition or empty example for future evidence intake.\\n- Must carry `template_only=true` and a visible `TEMPLATE_ONLY_DO_NOT_EXECUTE` marker.\\n- Operational fields must be `null`, empty, or `PLACEHOLDER_*`.\\n- Must not live in evidence or production directories.\\n\\n`manual`\\n\\n- Future human-operator evidence after explicit authorization only.\\n- Requires `manual_execution_authorized=true`, verified operator identity, timestamp, signature or equivalent audit token, source readiness refs, evidence body hash, and chain of custody.\\n- Cannot be simulated, backfilled, or generated by a template.\\n\\n`provider`\\n\\n- Future external provider response evidence after explicit provider execution authorization only.\\n- Requires provider request fingerprint, adapter metadata, raw response body, parsed result, timestamps, and traceable task refs.\\n- Cannot be hand-crafted, inferred, or replayed as evidence.\\n\\n`operator`\\n\\n- Future production acceptance evidence by operator.\\n- Forbidden until production-lane acceptance is explicitly authorized and upstream manual/provider evidence exists where required.\\n\\n`pending`\\n\\n- Placeholder for expected but absent evidence.\\n- May appear only in tracking/debt/register surfaces.\\n- Does not satisfy any readiness or acceptance gate.\\n\\n## Manual Execution Log Contract Fields\\n\\nFuture real manual evidence rows, if authorized by a later contract, must include:\\n\\n- `log_entry_uuid`\\n- `schema_version`\\n- `contract_reference`\\n- `contract_fingerprint`\\n- `readiness_package_path`\\n- `readiness_package_sha256`\\n- `operator_identity`\\n- `operator_authentication_method`\\n- `execution_timestamp`\\n- `row_reference`\\n- `manual_action_description`\\n- `manual_output_evidence`\\n- `evidence_classification`\\n- `evidence_body_sha256`\\n- `digital_signature_or_audit_token`\\n- `chain_of_custody`\\n- `advisory_attestation`\\n\\nTemplate-only rows must keep all real evidence fields unpopulated and must include:\\n\\n- `template_only=true`\\n- `template_marker=TEMPLATE_ONLY_DO_NOT_EXECUTE`\\n- `manual_output_evidence=null`\\n- `digital_signature_or_audit_token=null`\\n- `execution_timestamp=null`\\n\\nForbidden defaults:\\n\\n- `operator_identity` must not default to `system`, `auto`, or `pipeline`.\\n- `execution_timestamp` must not default to current time in templates.\\n- `evidence_classification` must not default to `provider`, `operator`, or `accepted`.\\n- `digital_signature_or_audit_token` must not be dummy-filled.\\n- Example output text must not appear where real evidence would later live.\\n\\n## Held-Entity Invariant\\n\\nControl-plane logic must not hardcode a specific chapter, work title, entity name, character name, block title, or sample text.\\n\\nThe invariant is generic:\\n\\n- Every held/debt item recorded at Now-32 entry must remain held/debt unless a traceable, explicit QA/repair/evidence contract authorizes a status change.\\n- The status monitor must iterate over a held/debt manifest and compare stable IDs and statuses.\\n- Current facts such as `240` held rows and chapter 18 being `held_only_no_ready_drafts` may be reported as factual state, but runtime gates must use manifest-driven rules rather than hardcoded chapter-specific conditions.\\n\\n## Allowed Transitions\\n\\nNow-32 control-plane hardening may:\\n\\n- Create or update definition-phase contracts in docs/control-plane files.\\n- Record advisory consultation metadata and parse status as advisory-only.\\n- Define template schemas and template rules without producing real evidence rows.\\n- Run dry-run validation checks that only read, compare, hash, or parse.\\n- Update short-entry control-plane files to point to the landed contract and advisory basis.\\n\\n## Blocked Transitions\\n\\nNow-32 control-plane hardening must block:\\n\\n- Any `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint` change.\\n- Any policy flag transition from false to true for provider/manual/media/evidence/feedback/repair/replay/KG/overlay/output-index/production acceptance.\\n- Any held/debt row promotion without an explicit downstream contract.\\n- Any real evidence row in manual/provider/operator/evidence/production locations.\\n- Any activation of Now-33/34/35/36.\\n- Any outputs-index mutation.\\n- Any provider job or media-generation path.\\n\\n## Required Control-Plane Fields\\n\\nControl-plane files should keep these fields synchronized:\\n\\n- `now32_control_plane_hardening_status`\\n- `now32_control_plane_hardening_contract`\\n- `now32_control_plane_hardening_deepseek_round1`\\n- `now32_control_plane_hardening_deepseek_round1_parse_repair`\\n- `now32_control_plane_hardening_deepseek_round2`\\n- `now32_control_plane_hardening_advisory_basis`\\n- `now32_evidence_taxonomy_status`\\n- `now32_manual_execution_log_contract_status`\\n- `now32_held_entity_invariant`\\n- `now32_pre_execution_gate_status`\\n\\n## Preflight Checks\\n\\nBefore any future Now-32 closeout, candidate-route activation, or manual/provider/evidence work, run these checks:\\n\\n- Confirm `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint.id == platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`.\\n- Confirm current workflow remains `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`.\\n- Confirm P2V-24 forbidden side-effect counts remain zero.\\n- Confirm advisory records carry `advisory_only=true`, provider/model/thinking metadata, raw/unavailable status, input/message fingerprints, and parse status.\\n- Confirm all template artifacts carry `TEMPLATE_ONLY_DO_NOT_EXECUTE` and have no operational fields populated.\\n- Confirm no manual/provider/operator evidence entries exist unless explicitly authorized by a future contract.\\n- Confirm held/debt manifests preserve status for every recorded held/debt item.\\n- Confirm no runtime branch uses work title, entity name, character name, block title, sample text, or specific chapter title.\\n- Confirm Now-33/34/35/36 remain candidate-blocked unless an explicit activation contract exists.\\n\\n## Verification Commands\\n\\n- `python -m json.tool workflow.json >/dev/null && python -m json.tool execution_state.json >/dev/null && python -m json.tool phase_acceptance.json >/dev/null && python -m json.tool workflow_index.json >/dev/null && python -m json.tool retrospective_state.json >/dev/null`\\n- `PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 PYTHONPATH=src python scripts/workflow_guard.py --root .`\\n- `PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 PYTHONPATH=src:. pytest -q tests/test_p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout.py`\\n- `git diff --c\",\n    \"hard_boundaries\": [\n      \"Do not change execution_state.json.next_entrypoint.\",\n      \"Do not execute provider jobs or media generation.\",\n      \"Do not create filled manual/provider/operator evidence.\",\n      \"Do not ingest feedback, execute repair/replay, write overlays/KG, or mutate outputs index.\",\n      \"Do not activate Now-33/34/35/36; only recommend candidate direction unless explicit activation contract exists.\",\n      \"DeepSeek remains advisory-only and cannot become evidence, operator acceptance, KG/overlay/replay/writeback, route authority, or outputs index authority.\",\n      \"Held/debt facts may be reported, but runtime/control gates must be manifest-driven, not chapter/entity/title/sample-specific.\"\n    ]\n  },\n  \"required_response_schema\": {\n    \"parse_status\": \"pass\",\n    \"overall_verdict\": \"string\",\n    \"project_goal_alignment\": [\n      \"string\"\n    ],\n    \"actual_landed_work\": [\n      \"string\"\n    ],\n    \"not_landed_or_blocked\": [\n      \"string\"\n    ],\n    \"retrospective_findings\": [\n      \"string\"\n    ],\n    \"risks_and_debt\": [\n      \"string\"\n    ],\n    \"mainline_recalibration\": [\n      \"string\"\n    ],\n    \"recommended_sequence\": [\n      {\n        \"id\": \"string\",\n        \"status\": \"string\",\n        \"why\": \"string\",\n        \"activation_boundary\": \"string\",\n        \"required_artifacts_or_contracts\": [\n          \"string\"\n        ]\n      }\n    ],\n    \"control_plane_update_recommendations\": [\n      \"string\"\n    ],\n    \"do_not_do\": [\n      \"string\"\n    ],\n    \"confidence\": \"high|medium|low\"\n  }\n}",
    "role": "user"
  }
]