{
  "version": "project_retrospective_next_route_deepseek.v1",
  "created_at": "2026-06-11T20:29:31.224757Z",
  "round_id": "round2",
  "previous_round_dir": "outputs/project_retrospective_next_route_deepseek_round1_20260612_0427",
  "previous_round_parsed": {
    "parse_status": "pass",
    "overall_verdict": "recommend_route",
    "confidence": "high",
    "recommended_next_marker": "dramart_seedance_operator_preview_review_packet_contract_no_execution",
    "recommended_next_step_kind": "contract_only_no_execution",
    "recommended_route_summary": "Define an operator-facing review/decision packet contract for preview acceptance, requested repairs, or future final-prompt authorization boundary. This directly addresses the operator acceptance gap without execution, writeback, evidence intake, or final prompt export, and prepares the project for unblocking while staying within strict boundaries.",
    "option_assessment": [
      {
        "marker": "remain_blocked_pending_operator_final_prompt_authorization_no_execution",
        "verdict": "acceptable",
        "rationale": "Safest option; performs no work and waits for operator. However, it does not advance the project and may prolong the blocked state indefinitely.",
        "risk_level": "low"
      },
      {
        "marker": "dramart_seedance_operator_preview_review_packet_contract_no_execution",
        "verdict": "recommended",
        "rationale": "Contract-only step that creates a decision packet for operator review of the adapter preview, enabling structured feedback, repair requests, or final-prompt authorization. No execution, evidence intake, or writeback required. Directly supports unblocking the current gate.",
        "risk_level": "low"
      },
      {
        "marker": "dramart_seedance_preview_quality_audit_and_repair_plan_no_writeback",
        "verdict": "acceptable",
        "rationale": "An audit and repair plan could improve preview quality and inform operator decision. However, without execution capability, repairs cannot be implemented; may be a useful supplementary step but less directly unblocking.",
        "risk_level": "medium"
      },
      {
        "marker": "future_operator_evidence_intake_implementation_contract_no_execution",
        "verdict": "not_recommended",
        "rationale": "Evidence intake design is out of sequence while final-prompt authorization is blocked and operator inputs are missing; premature focus could delay resolving the immediate gate and create false progress.",
        "risk_level": "medium"
      },
      {
        "marker": "public_review_surface_productization_plan_no_execution",
        "verdict": "not_recommended",
        "rationale": "Public frontend improvements are not directly tied to the current blocked state and would distract from advancing toward production readiness; better deferred until core pipeline unblocked.",
        "risk_level": "low"
      }
    ],
    "required_boundaries": [
      "no-execution",
      "no-final-prompt-export",
      "no-evidence-intake",
      "no-writeback-to-canonical-stores",
      "no-route-mutation",
      "no-NOW36-activation"
    ],
    "risks_or_debts": [
      "Operator preview acceptance and final-prompt authorization remain unresolved",
      "3276 real asset voice profile gaps persist as external dependency",
      "Current preview is bounded (5 scenes/20 shots) and not production-scale",
      "No provider or NOW-36 activation path available without operator authorization"
    ],
    "required_corrections": [
      "Obtain operator feedback on preview via structured review packet",
      "Resolve final-prompt authorization gate before proceeding to evidence intake or production activation"
    ],
    "remaining_high_or_blocker_count": 4,
    "forbidden_authority_confirmed_false": true,
    "call_status": "success"
  },
  "previous_round_input_fingerprint": "8936eab3d298b12505c3cab881fb8c3a6a78ce9772abb5f2733dfc41e5c402c5",
  "control_plane": {
    "next_entrypoint": "platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract",
    "current_status": "dramart_seedance_final_prompt_authorization_decision_gate_closed_blocked_no_execution_landed_validated",
    "next_implementation_kind": "remain_blocked_pending_operator_final_prompt_authorization_no_execution",
    "phase_status": "dramart_seedance_final_prompt_authorization_decision_gate_closed_blocked_no_execution_landed_validated"
  },
  "artifacts": {
    "final_prompt_gate": {
      "path": "outputs/dramart_seedance_final_prompt_authorization_decision_gate_20260612_012707_final/DRAMART_SEEDANCE_FINAL_PROMPT_AUTH_DECISION_gate.json",
      "exists": true,
      "sha256": "800b54b6ea3d1e459c8c736732dd7a2778d5e772d6b497dafd8b83da13a6c7d3",
      "size_bytes": 3273
    },
    "preview_gate": {
      "path": "outputs/dramart_seedance_adapter_preview_no_writeback_20260612_012535_fresh/DRAMART_SEEDANCE_ADAPTER_PREVIEW_gate.json",
      "exists": true,
      "sha256": "a81d616243ae8739cc948ed68e70f2fc3bf18e2d36388f555ae8b4ecf6537b04",
      "size_bytes": 3032
    },
    "projectreport": {
      "path": "projectreport.md",
      "exists": true,
      "sha256": "e99a3c1b2d93fa36bfd4d23f429d189216fd22904e31db4a407412ae4089de15",
      "size_bytes": 5211
    },
    "todo": {
      "path": "todo.md",
      "exists": true,
      "sha256": "ceb46f194c77b9608df9a19207405e243f742059e3b6dc44f451a3b8cd05b39a",
      "size_bytes": 5318
    }
  },
  "critique_questions": [
    "Does Round 1 over-authorize final prompt export, provider payload/execution, media/assets, evidence intake, writeback, route transition, outputs index mutation, NOW-36 activation, readiness, or production acceptance?",
    "Should the recommended marker remain contract-only/no-execution?",
    "Are Round 1 required_corrections actually external authorization blockers that should be encoded as packet decisions rather than blockers to selecting the route?",
    "Would a quality audit or frontend productization be a better immediate next step than an operator preview review packet contract?",
    "What exact artifacts and forbidden boundaries must the next contract define?"
  ],
  "candidate_final_choice": {
    "recommended_next_marker": "dramart_seedance_operator_preview_review_packet_contract_no_execution",
    "next_step_kind": "contract_only_no_execution",
    "purpose": "Define a review/decision packet contract so the operator can explicitly accept review-only preview, request repairs, or later authorize a final-prompt contract; it must not intake evidence or export final prompt."
  },
  "hard_constraints": [
    "Do not change execution_state.json.next_entrypoint",
    "No provider execution, media/assets, final prompt export, provider payload, evidence intake, writeback, row mutation, route transition, outputs-index mutation, NOW-36 activation, readiness claim, or production acceptance",
    "DeepSeek advisory-only"
  ],
  "input_fingerprint": "43565390a71e407e6adffae862538ec69a6dd70128e81acd86039b734e02e761"
}