{ "boundary_violation_detected": false, "confidence": "high", "final_recommendation": "Proceed with control-plane slimming and next-contract design as proposed, with the minor corrections and verifications listed.", "findings": [ { "category": "control_plane", "description": "Post-slimming verification must explicitly confirm that all data structures required by workflow_guard (e.g., classification rules in workflow_index.json) remain intact and functional.", "required_fix": "Extend post_slimming_verification_required to include a structural check that the workflow_guard can parse and classify all workflows without error and that its pass/warn/fail counts remain consistent with the pre-slimming state.", "severity": "medium" }, { "category": "strategy", "description": "The expected row counts (draft, held, readiness debt) in proposed_detail_rules.input_invariants are static and could drift from the actual state at contract execution time.", "required_fix": "Implement a runtime check that re-derives these counts from the authoritative registers (P2V-24, NOW-32 sidecars) before accepting them as invariants, rather than relying solely on the static values.", "severity": "low" }, { "category": "boundary", "description": "The deepseek_rules setting 'missing_skipped_timeout_or_parse_failed_blocks_pass: true' makes advisory consultation effectively optional for gate passage; this should be explicitly noted as intentional to avoid later misinterpretation.", "required_fix": "Add a comment in the contract or gate documentation clarifying that the gate can succeed without DeepSeek input if the call fails, and that operator acceptance remains the sole authority.", "severity": "low" } ], "operator_constraints_respected": true, "overreach_detected": false, "parse_status": "pass", "required_corrections": [ "Verify workflow_guard structural integrity after slimming by re-running the guard and confirming no regressions in classification, pass/warn/fail counts, or gate status.", "Replace static expected row counts in input_invariants with runtime lookups to authoritative registers to prevent drift.", "Document that gate passage does not require a successful DeepSeek call; the system treats unavailable/skipped advisory as a non-blocking event." ], "round2_verdict": "round1_supported_with_corrections" }