{ "absorbed_round1_corrections_for_control_plane": [ "NOW-37 must start with a detail contract defining versioned schemas for resource_inventory, case_cards, platform_constraints, prompt_patterns, anti_patterns, absorption_report, and resource_ref evidence chain.", "NOW-38 must define an adapter-only shadow entity mention ledger and @entity validator; no canonical entity store/KG/raw KG/accepted overlay/writeback mutation.", "NOW-39 must produce a control-plane contract alignment matrix mapping pages/components to execution_state.json, workflow.json, phase_acceptance.json, outputs artifacts, and backend APIs before UI implementation.", "NOW-37 start gate must be explicitly scoped as post-NOW36 strategy route that preserves NOW-36 blocked/no-execution and does not require real asset/production activation authority.", "NOW-37 first cycle should be bounded: inventory all resources, then pilot extraction on a minimal resource subset before full corpus absorption." ], "created_at": "2026-06-09T05:19:57.273716Z", "hard_boundaries": { "canonical_writeback_absent": true, "deepseek_advisory_only": true, "manual_provider_evidence_absent": true, "media_generation_absent": true, "next_entrypoint_unchanged": "platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract", "outputs_index_mutation_absent": true, "provider_execution_absent": true, "real_asset_binding_absent": true }, "parse_gap_repair": { "round1_record": { "exists": true, "is_file": true, "path": "outputs/now37_39_route_plan_deepseek_round1_20260609_0603/consultation_record.json", "sha256": "829c6da09bf4e050679215ae504d6169fb4ab9029506c2a3510198a7407f28b1", "size_bytes": 599 }, "round2_previous_blocker": "R1_PARSE_FAILURE is superseded after deterministic reparse; verify no substantive blocker remains.", "round2_record": { "exists": true, "is_file": true, "path": "outputs/now37_39_route_plan_deepseek_round2_20260609_0603/consultation_record.json", "sha256": "3974f66e33302c4558c434b9a850e78d1b517a4c0a8f61801b1c69a80391b8d3", "size_bytes": 597 }, "status": "resolved_by_deterministic_reparse_from_valid_json_response" }, "previous_round1_parsed": { "boundary_assessment": { "adapter_layer_preserved": true, "asset_binding_absent": true, "canonical_layer_preserved": true, "deepseek_not_authority": true, "now36_block_preserved": true, "outputs_index_mutation_absent": true, "provider_execution_absent": true, "writeback_absent": true }, "call_status": "success", "confidence": "medium", "handoff_recommendation": "After corrections are integrated into the plan artifacts, re-submit an updated route plan for advisory review before any execution or implementation. Approve only if phase gate C-004 is satisfied and schemas C-001 to C-003 are delivered.", "high_or_blocker_findings": [ { "finding": "NOW-37 required outputs (case_cards, platform_constraints, etc.) have no defined schema or structure, risking unstructured absorption that cannot be reliably reused.", "id": "F-001", "required_correction": "Define formal schemas (JSON Schema) for each NOW-37 output artifact, including mandatory fields for source, metadata, constraints, and patterns. Require validation of outputs against these schemas.", "severity": "high" }, { "finding": "NOW-38 entity_mention_ledger and @entity validator lack explicit isolation rules from the canonical entity store, creating risk of accidental binding or confusion.", "id": "F-002", "required_correction": "Add explicit isolation contract: the ledger is a read-only adapter-specific shadow; @entity mentions must resolve against this ledger only, and must never trigger canonical writebacks. Provide a clear data model and validation steps.", "severity": "high" }, { "finding": "NOW-39 frontend plans lack concrete mapping to current control-plane artifacts (execution_state, workflow, phase_acceptance), risking misalignment with actual backend state.", "id": "F-003", "required_correction": "Produce a data contract mapping document that binds each page/component's data requirements to specific keys/paths in the existing control-plane artifacts. Validate that those artifacts can satisfy the needs before UI implementation.", "severity": "high" }, { "finding": "The plan conditions entry to NOW-37/38/39 on 'after current control-plane closeout', but closeout conditions are not defined; NOW-36 remains blocked indefinitely, creating a phase boundary ambiguity.", "id": "F-004", "required_correction": "Define a phase gate artifact (e.g., now_36_closeout_gate.json) that must pass before starting NOW-37. The gate should require either explicit human acceptance of missing assets under a future contract, or a documented decision to proceed without them under advisory conditions.", "severity": "high" } ], "low_findings": [ { "finding": "Large resource files (e.g., 66MB zip) may require chunked processing or memory management in NOW-37; no mention in plan.", "id": "L-001", "suggestion": "Consider adding resource processing guidelines (max block size, streaming) in NOW-37 preparation." }, { "finding": "The @entity validator is listed as an output of NOW-38, but no mention of how it will be tested against existing prompt templates.", "id": "L-002", "suggestion": "Include a validation suite that tests the validator against sample prompts to ensure correct mention resolution." } ], "parse_status": "pass", "parsed_at": "2026-06-09T05:19:04.850455Z", "required_corrections": [ { "applies_to": "now37", "correction": "In NOW-37 contract, add mandatory output schemas (case_cards.schema.json, platform_constraints.schema.json, etc.) with validation rules.", "id": "C-001" }, { "applies_to": "now38", "correction": "In NOW-38, specify entity ledger isolation: declare a 'shadow adapter registry' that does not touch entity_store; enforce read-only access and no-writeback rule.", "id": "C-002" }, { "applies_to": "now39", "correction": "In NOW-39, include a 'control-plane contract alignment matrix' that maps each UI element to specific fields in execution_state.json, workflow.json, and phase_acceptance.json.", "id": "C-003" }, { "applies_to": "global", "correction": "Introduce a phase readiness gate for NOW-37 start, linked to NOW-36 closeout or explicit human decision; update global boundaries accordingly.", "id": "C-004" } ], "round_id": "round1", "stage_recommendations": { "now37": [ "Adopt versioned schemas for all outputs; run a pilot on one resource file to verify structured extraction before full scale.", "Document the evidence chain for each case card linking back to source file and content blocks." ], "now38": [ "Design entity ledger as a flat JSON/JSONL file, not a database, to maintain simplicity and avoid accidental persistence alterations.", "Provide an explicit mapping between Dramart/Seedance-specific constraints and the general prompt generation model." ], "now39": [ "Before finalizing IA, conduct a walkthrough of the current UI to identify gaps; ensure new IA covers control-plane visibility, resource absorption, prompt lab, entity ledger, evidence gates, and run browser as specified.", "Produce wireframes or low-fidelity prototypes for review before implementation." ] }, "summary": "The proposed plan respects global boundaries and canonical layering, but lacks concrete structural definitions for resource absorption, entity ledger isolation, and frontend-backend contract alignment. Required corrections before execution.", "verdict": "supports_plan_with_corrections" }, "previous_round2_parsed": { "boundary_assessment": { "adapter_layer_preserved": true, "asset_binding_absent": true, "canonical_layer_preserved": true, "deepseek_not_authority": true, "now36_block_preserved": true, "outputs_index_mutation_absent": true, "provider_execution_absent": true, "writeback_absent": true }, "call_status": "success", "confidence": "high", "handoff_recommendation": "Accept the NOW-37/38/39 plan after documenting and closing the Round 1 parse gap. The plan is advisory-compliant and correctly isolates all authority-bearing actions. Begin execution with the incremental validation steps outlined in stage_recommendations.", "high_or_blocker_findings": [ { "finding": "Round 1 consultation_parsed.json could not be decoded (parse_status: fail, error: 'parsed JSON is not object'). No usable Round 1 advisory exists, breaking the intended multi-round review pipeline.", "id": "R1_PARSE_FAILURE", "required_correction": "Either re-execute Round 1 with enforced output formatting, or accept Round 2 as the effective primary review after documenting a deviation and re-confirming all boundary assertions.", "severity": "blocker" } ], "low_findings": [ { "finding": "The resource_inventory contains three large files (e.g., 63 MB zip) but the NOW-37 plan does not define a processing order or subset. Without scoping, absorption could become unbounded.", "id": "LOW_RESOURCE_PRIORITISATION", "suggestion": "Define a minimal first-cycle target (e.g., the Dramart PDF only) to maintain a tight, measurable iteration." } ], "parse_status": "pass", "parsed_at": "2026-06-09T05:19:04.853420Z", "required_corrections": [ { "applies_to": "global", "correction": "Resolve the Round 1 output parsing failure. If the proposed plan is already the Round 1 output, regenerate it with strict JSON formatting. If the plan is independently provided, record that Round 1 did not contribute a valid parsed record and that Round 2 serves as the authoritative review for this gate.", "id": "CORR_R1_PARSE" } ], "round_id": "round2", "stage_recommendations": { "now37": [ "Start absorption with a single resource to validate the pipeline before expanding.", "Keep the 'resource_ref evidence chain' strictly as read-only documentation; do not attempt to link it to canonical UID stores." ], "now38": [ "Confirm that @entity validator operates purely in the adapter layer and does not mutate entity_store or other canonical registries.", "Generate a mock shot prompt matrix against absorbed resource patterns to validate coverage early." ], "now39": [ "Produce frontend IA and data/component contracts as planned; delay implementation until contracts are reviewed and signed off.", "Consider lightweight wireframes to pressure-test the IA without coupling to live data." ] }, "summary": "The proposed NOW-37/38/39 plan correctly treats deepseek as advisory, preserves all NOW-36 blockers, avoids canonical layer mutation, includes required resource evidence chain and @entity validation, and defers frontend implementation until data contracts are landed. The plan is fundamentally sound. However, the Round 1 review output (consultation_parsed.json) failed to parse as a JSON object, leaving the first-level review trail incomplete. This process gap must be formalised before proceeding.", "verdict": "supports_plan_with_corrections" }, "round_id": "round2b", "version": "now37_39_route_plan_deepseek_round2b_input.v1" }