{ "confidence": "medium", "final_recommendation": "Proceed with preflight after clarifying fingerprint overlap criteria and expanding registry schema validation.", "findings": [ { "category": "source_fingerprint", "description": "Fingerprint computation and overlap validation rules are underspecified. The contract does not define fingerprint format, fields to hash, or the minimum overlap condition.", "required_fix": "Specify exact fingerprint computation method and overlap rule (e.g., match all target fingerprints against candidate lineage).", "severity": "medium" }, { "category": "registry_schema", "description": "Registry candidate validation only checks entity_uid and names; a structurally invalid registry could pass and cause downstream issues.", "required_fix": "Add a structural schema check (JSON array of objects with required fields).", "severity": "low" }, { "category": "boundary", "description": "Discovery glob 'outputs/**/02e_entity_registry.json' may include unrelated registries, increasing noise in candidate manifest.", "required_fix": "Limit discovery scope to recent or configured runs to reduce false candidates.", "severity": "low" }, { "category": "scope", "description": "The clause allowing DeepSeek advice to 'substitute for human advice under operator delegation' may be misinterpreted as granting decision authority, despite the advisory-only limitation.", "required_fix": "Clarify that substitution is for consideration only, not for binding decisions or production acceptance.", "severity": "low" } ], "required_contract_corrections": [ "Define fingerprint computation and overlap criteria explicitly.", "Add minimal structural registry schema validation.", "Optionally restrict candidate discovery scope." ], "round1_critique": { "boundary_violation_detected": false, "hallucination_risk_detected": false, "missing_assumption_detected": true, "operator_constraints_respected": true, "overreach_detected": false }, "round2_verdict": "round1_supported_with_corrections" }