{ "version": "now33a_current_canonical_registry_deepseek_consultation.v1", "created_at": "2026-06-06T10:22:04.362941Z", "stage": "NOW_33A_current_canonical_registry_build_import_preflight", "round_id": "round2", "project_root": "/wwwb/aitools/writer", "output_run_dir": "outputs/now33a_current_registry_deepseek_consultation_revised_round2_20260606_1819", "contract_excerpt": { "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/docs/now33a_current_canonical_registry_build_import_contract_20260606.md", "exists": true, "sha256": "83a3f436b6b37841214d889c5b7a2f23771c79881b4b6d3c01263f78ef1ee9c8", "char_count": 8608, "text": "# NOW-33A Current Canonical Registry Build/Import Preflight Contract\n\n更新时间：`2026-06-06T17:58:00+08:00`\n\n## Status\n\n- stage: `NOW_33A_current_canonical_registry_build_import_preflight`\n- active route authority: `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`\n- active route must remain: `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`\n- purpose: validate whether any existing registry candidate can become the current canonical registry basis before UID binding replay, KG/raw KG writeback, asset binding, held/debt final classification, evidence-pack assembly, or provider/manual execution.\n- expected closeout shape: read-only authority preflight, not successful current registry creation.\n\n## Why This Exists\n\nNOW-33 closed honestly as `advisory_entity_link_binding_closed_missing_registry_no_writeback`: all `1638` P2V-22 draft rows are represented, but no current canonical registry is available, so no canonical UID binding can be claimed.\n\nThe next prerequisite is not another entity-link pass. It is a current registry authority check:\n\n- collect target source fingerprints from the current P2V source line;\n- inspect candidate entity registries;\n- reject candidates whose source lineage does not overlap the target source fingerprints;\n- reject candidates with invalid entity UID/name schema;\n- reject path/name/title hints as authority;\n- report whether a candidate can be explicitly configured for read-only use;\n- keep all writeback, UID binding, assets, evidence, execution, feedback, replay, and route transition blocked.\n\n## Inputs\n\nRequired source artifacts:\n\n- `outputs/p_plan_v2_17_first20_scale_generation_calibration_density_repair_20260605_0505/P2V_17_chapters.jsonl`\n- `outputs/p_plan_v2_22_neutral_prompt_draft_hold_boundary_20260605_0713/P2V_22_neutral_prompt_draft_rows.jsonl`\n- `outputs/now33_entity_link_binding_advisory_20260606_1544/NOW_33_entity_link_gate.json`\n- `outputs/now33_entity_link_binding_advisory_20260606_1544/NOW_33_entity_gap_report.json`\n- `outputs/now33_entity_link_binding_advisory_20260606_1544/NOW_33_registry_discovery_report.json`\n- DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max Round 1 and Round 2 consultation records for this contract.\n\nOptional input:\n\n- `--configured-registry-path`: a candidate registry path. Configuration alone is not sufficient; the candidate must still pass deterministic source fingerprint and entity schema checks.\n\n## Output Artifacts\n\nThe preflight run writes only advisory/control artifacts:\n\n- `NOW_33A_current_registry_input.json`\n- `NOW_33A_source_fingerprint_report.json`\n- `NOW_33A_registry_candidate_manifest.jsonl`\n- `NOW_33A_registry_authority_gap_report.json`\n- `NOW_33A_current_registry_import_plan.md`\n- `NOW_33A_current_registry_validation_report.json`\n- `NOW_33A_current_registry_gate.json`\n- `NOW_33A_current_registry_review.html`\n- `manifest.json`\n\nThese artifacts are not manual/provider/operator evidence and do not mutate canonical storage.\n\n## Deterministic Validation Rules\n\nThe program must:\n\n- preserve `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`;\n- compute target source fingerprints from P2V-17 chapter source rows and P2V-22 draft source refs;\n- verify P2V-22 draft source hashes are covered by P2V-17 chapter hashes;\n- inspect registry candidates under `outputs/**/02e_entity_registry.json` and configured candidate path;\n- validate candidate entity rows have unique non-empty `entity_uid` values and canonical/display names;\n- validate `entities` is a non-empty JSON array of objects before checking entity row fields;\n- inspect nearby `project.json` / `run_manifest.json` lineage and registry KG refs where present;\n- require fingerprint overlap with target full-source or chapter-source fingerprints before a candidate can be eligible;\n- record rejected candidates with explicit rejection reasons;\n- allow at most one configured selected candidate and only as read-only;\n- keep all forbidden side-effect counters at zero;\n- fail if DeepSeek Round 1 or Round 2 is missing, unavailable, unparseable, or has blocker/high findings.\n\n## Fingerprint Computation And Overlap Rule\n\nTarget source fingerprint computation is deterministic:\n\n- `target_chapter_sha256s`: sorted unique `P2V_17_chapters.jsonl[*].sha256` values.\n- `target_full_source_sha256s`: SHA-256 of each distinct existing `P2V_17_chapters.jsonl[*].source_path` file.\n- `draft_source_sha256s`: sorted unique `P2V_22_neutral_prompt_draft_rows.jsonl[*].source_sha256` values.\n- `p2v22_subset_check`: every `draft_source_sha256s` value must appear in `target_chapter_sha256s`.\n- `source_fingerprint`: stable JSON fingerprint over `target_chapter_sha256s`, `target_full_source_sha256s`, and `draft_source_sha256s`.\n\nCandidate registry overlap is also deterministic:\n\n- candidate full-source SHA values come from nearby `project.json.input_sha256`, `run_manifest.json.input_sha256`, registry `target_source_sha256s`, registry `target_full_source_sha256s`, registry `source_full_sha256s`, registry `full_source_sha256s`, or the same keys under registry `source_fingerprints`;\n- candidate chapter SHA values come from registry `target_chapter_sha256s`, `source_chapter_sha256s`, `chapter_sha256s`, or the same keys under registry `source_fingerprints`;\n- `source_fingerprint_status=pass` only when either:\n - at least one candidate full-source SHA matches `target_full_source_sha256s`; or\n - candidate declares a non-empty chapter SHA set and that set is a subset of `target_chapter_sha256s`.\n\nThe preflight deliberately does not treat path names, work title hints, entity names, or sample text as authority. A configured candidate still fails if it lacks the source fingerprint overlap above.\n\n## DeepSeek Advisory Protocol\n\nThis is a high-impact registry authority contract, so two DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max rounds are required:\n\n- Round 1: scope/options/risks/artifacts audit.\n- Round 2: critique Round 1 for overreach, hallucination, boundary violations, missing assumptions, and operator constraints.\n\nDeepSeek output may substitute for human advice-style consultation under operator delegation, but only as advisory input considered by the program and project agent. It remains non-binding and advisory-only. It cannot become:\n\n- current registry authority;\n- operator production acceptance;\n- provider/manual/operator evidence;\n- accepted/operator overlay;\n- canonical/raw KG writeback;\n- UID binding writeback;\n- asset binding;\n- feedback/replay action;\n- route authority;\n- runtime routing logic;\n- `outputs/index.json` or `outputs/index-lite.json` mutation.\n\n## Exit Criteria\n\nThe stage can close as `current_registry_preflight_pass_no_eligible_registry_recorded` when:\n\n- source fingerprint report is valid;\n- all candidates are inspected or none exist;\n- no candidate is eligible;\n- the missing/invalid current registry basis is recorded;\n- validators pass;\n- DeepSeek Round 1 and Round 2 support the preflight boundary.\n\nThe stage can close as `current_registry_preflight_pass_eligible_candidates_require_explicit_configuration` when:\n\n- one or more candidates pass source fingerprint and schema checks;\n- no candidate is configured as current;\n- validators pass;\n- no writeback or registry creation occurs.\n\nThe stage can close as `current_registry_preflight_pass_configured_candidate_selected_read_only_no_writeback` when:\n\n- the configured candidate passes source fingerprint and schema checks;\n- exactly one configured candidate is selected for read-only authority reference;\n- no current registry file is created;\n- no UID binding, KG/raw KG writeback, row mutation, asset binding, evidence, execution, feedback, replay, route transition, or output-index mutation occurs.\n\n## Explicit Non-Goals\n\nThis contract does not:\n\n- build a new entity registry;\n- import a registry into canonical storage;\n- write or rewrite canonical KG/raw KG/entity store;\n- bind P2V rows to entity UIDs;\n- bind or acquire assets;\n- classify held/debt rows as final;\n- assemble NOW-36 evidence pack;\n- create manual/provider/operator evidence;\n- execute provider/media jobs;\n- ingest feedback, repair, or replay;\n- change route or output indexes;\n- claim production acceptance.\n\n## Next Step After Closeout\n\nIf no eligible candidate exists, the next required contract is a target-source-grounded entity registry build contract.\n\nIf a candidate is eligible but not configured, explicitly configure it and rerun this preflight.\n\nIf a configured candidate is selected read-only, rerun NOW-33 read-only entity linking against that configured registry. A separate writeback/asset/evidence contract is still required before any canonical mutation or execution work.\n", "truncated": false }, "input_counts": { "p2v17_chapter_count": 20, "p2v22_draft_row_count": 1638, "p2v17_distinct_source_path_count": 1, "p2v17_distinct_chapter_sha256_count": 20, "now33_status": "advisory_entity_link_binding_closed_missing_registry_no_writeback", "now33_current_canonical_registry_status": "missing_current_canonical_registry", "now33_discovered_candidate_count": 11, "local_registry_candidate_path_sample": [ "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/archive/p0_entity_replay_pre_20260520_115434/02e_entity_registry.json", "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/daozu_first50_deepseek_foundation_entity_20260515_094504/02e_entity_registry.json", "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/daozu_first50_deepseek_foundation_entity_clean_20260521_125249/02e_entity_registry.json", "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/daozu_first50_deepseek_foundation_entity_20260515_094504/logs/_archive/20260515T014513318333Z__before__20260515T030544098193Z/stage_artifacts/entity_registry/20260515T014513318333Z__02e_entity_registry.json", "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/daozu_first50_deepseek_foundation_entity_20260515_094504/logs/_archive/20260515T030544098193Z__before__20260515T030724291180Z/stage_artifacts/entity_registry/20260515T030544098193Z__02e_entity_registry.json", "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/daozu_first50_deepseek_foundation_entity_20260515_094504/logs/_archive/20260515T030724291180Z__before__20260515T030826045872Z/stage_artifacts/entity_registry/20260515T030724291180Z__02e_entity_registry.json", "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/daozu_first50_deepseek_foundation_entity_20260515_094504/logs/stage_artifacts/entity_registry/20260515T030826045872Z__02e_entity_registry.json", "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/daozu_first50_deepseek_foundation_entity_clean_20260521_125249/logs/_archive/20260521T045256791991Z__before__20260521T051836498989Z/stage_artifacts/entity_registry/20260521T045256791991Z__02e_entity_registry.json", "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/daozu_first50_deepseek_foundation_entity_clean_20260521_125249/logs/stage_artifacts/entity_registry/20260521T052028443017Z__02e_entity_registry.json", "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/tri_novel_b730_source_kg_entity_context_rebuild_execution_20260528_123019/isolated_artifacts/source_refs/B71SRC000007_02e_entity_registry.json", "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/tri_novel_b730_source_kg_entity_context_rebuild_execution_20260528_123019/isolated_artifacts/source_refs/B71SRC000016_02e_entity_registry.json" ] }, "active_route": { "execution_state_ref": { "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/execution_state.json", "exists": true, "sha256": "e13988906fadf37efd4d9e75f2486c6f9b6b4af9afbae12571695ef007ec54a3", "size_bytes": 60704 }, "next_entrypoint_id": "platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract" }, "previous_round": { "dir": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/now33a_current_registry_deepseek_consultation_revised_20260606_1818", "parsed": { "parse_status": "pass", "round_id": "round1", "confidence": "high", "findings": [ { "category": "boundary", "description": "DeepSeek advisory protocol requires program to fail on blocker/high findings, effectively granting DeepSeek hard gate authority despite the non-binding advisory label.", "required_fix": "Reconcile the language: either make the DeepSeek checks truly advisory (fail only if explicitly overridden by operator) or acknowledge the veto as an explicit design choice.", "severity": "medium" }, { "category": "source_fingerprint", "description": "Lineage discovery uses 'nearby project.json / run_manifest.json' without scoping rules, risking non-deterministic candidate inspection.", "required_fix": "Define exact relative paths or a strict discovery algorithm from the candidate registry location.", "severity": "medium" }, { "category": "registry_schema", "description": "Multiple source fingerprint key names are listed without priority or conflict resolution, which could lead to ambiguous matching if a candidate carries multiple keys with divergent values.", "required_fix": "Specify key precedence and type expectations (e.g., array vs string) and a deterministic resolution strategy.", "severity": "low" }, { "category": "artifact", "description": "Advisory outputs include a manifest.json that could be mistaken for a canonical manifest, risking accidental downstream use.", "required_fix": "Write all preflight artifacts to a dedicated advisory subdirectory or prefix filenames with 'NOW_33A_' consistently.", "severity": "low" } ], "finding_counts": { "medium": 2, "low": 2 }, "required_contract_corrections": [ "Define 'nearby' discovery for project.json/run_manifest.json explicitly.", "Clarify the DeepSeek fail rule to avoid contradiction with non-binding advisory status.", "Add key precedence and type handling for candidate registry source fingerprint discovery." ], "raw_parsed": { "confidence": "high", "findings": [ { "category": "boundary", "description": "DeepSeek advisory protocol requires program to fail on blocker/high findings, effectively granting DeepSeek hard gate authority despite the non-binding advisory label.", "required_fix": "Reconcile the language: either make the DeepSeek checks truly advisory (fail only if explicitly overridden by operator) or acknowledge the veto as an explicit design choice.", "severity": "medium" }, { "category": "source_fingerprint", "description": "Lineage discovery uses 'nearby project.json / run_manifest.json' without scoping rules, risking non-deterministic candidate inspection.", "required_fix": "Define exact relative paths or a strict discovery algorithm from the candidate registry location.", "severity": "medium" }, { "category": "registry_schema", "description": "Multiple source fingerprint key names are listed without priority or conflict resolution, which could lead to ambiguous matching if a candidate carries multiple keys with divergent values.", "required_fix": "Specify key precedence and type expectations (e.g., array vs string) and a deterministic resolution strategy.", "severity": "low" }, { "category": "artifact", "description": "Advisory outputs include a manifest.json that could be mistaken for a canonical manifest, risking accidental downstream use.", "required_fix": "Write all preflight artifacts to a dedicated advisory subdirectory or prefix filenames with 'NOW_33A_' consistently.", "severity": "low" } ], "overall_verdict": "supports_current_registry_preflight_contract", "recommended_closeout_label": "contract_validated_read_only_preflight_feasible", "required_contract_corrections": [ "Define 'nearby' discovery for project.json/run_manifest.json explicitly.", "Clarify the DeepSeek fail rule to avoid contradiction with non-binding advisory status.", "Add key precedence and type handling for candidate registry source fingerprint discovery." ], "scope_audit": { "deepseek_advisory_only": true, "kg_writeback_blocked": true, "path_or_name_hint_rejected_as_authority": true, "read_only_preflight_allowed": true, "registry_creation_blocked": true, "route_transition_blocked": true, "source_fingerprint_validation_required": true, "uid_binding_blocked": true } }, "overall_verdict": "supports_current_registry_preflight_contract", "scope_audit": { "deepseek_advisory_only": true, "kg_writeback_blocked": true, "path_or_name_hint_rejected_as_authority": true, "read_only_preflight_allowed": true, "registry_creation_blocked": true, "route_transition_blocked": true, "source_fingerprint_validation_required": true, "uid_binding_blocked": true }, "recommended_closeout_label": "contract_validated_read_only_preflight_feasible" }, "record": { "version": "now33a_current_canonical_registry_deepseek_consultation.v1", "created_at": "2026-06-06T10:18:53.662509Z", "stage": "NOW_33A_current_canonical_registry_build_import_preflight", "round_id": "round1", "call_status": "success", "parse_status": "pass", "provider_meta": { "provider": "deepseek_reviewer", "model": "deepseek-v4-pro", "base_url": "https://api.deepseek.com/chat/completions", "thinking_type": "enabled", "reasoning_effort": "max", "max_tokens": 32000, "timeout_seconds": 600, "temperature": 0.0, "skipped": false }, "message_fingerprint": "f5446ed5a6aba092f450a16cc2b578b5d9fffd909f35a018c89043076e340d39", "advisory_only": true, "not_evidence_or_acceptance_or_route_authority": true } }, "hard_boundaries": { "stage": "NOW_33A_current_canonical_registry_build_import_preflight", "preflight_only": true, "current_registry_file_creation_allowed": false, "current_registry_selection_requires_explicit_config": true, "path_or_title_name_matching_authorizes_registry": false, "registry_import_writeback_allowed": false, "canonical_entity_uid_binding_allowed": false, "canonical_kg_writeback_allowed": false, "raw_kg_writeback_allowed": false, "row_mutation_allowed": false, "asset_binding_allowed": false, "provider_specific_prompt_allowed": false, "adapter_payload_allowed": false, "provider_job_execution_allowed": false, "media_generation_allowed": false, "manual_provider_evidence_creation_allowed": false, "operator_evidence_creation_allowed": false, "feedback_intake_allowed": false, "repair_execution_allowed": false, "replay_execution_allowed": false, "accepted_overlay_writeback_allowed": false, "operator_overlay_writeback_allowed": false, "outputs_index_mutation_allowed": false, "operator_production_acceptance_claimed": false, "deepseek_advisory_may_substitute_for_expert_advice": true, "deepseek_advisory_is_operator_production_acceptance": false, "runtime_branch_by_work_title_entity_name_or_sample_text_allowed": false, "active_route_authority": "execution_state.json.next_entrypoint", "execution_state_next_entrypoint_unchanged": true }, "advisory_question": "Round 2: critique Round 1 and the contract for overreach, hallucination, missing assumptions, target-source authority gaps, and boundary violations.", "input_fingerprint": "5496f2a954b8d082779e9b882b00c1558d1bc8b188b44f2556a2948d76777f78" }