{ "confidence": "high", "findings": [ { "category": "boundary", "description": "DeepSeek advisory protocol requires program to fail on blocker/high findings, effectively granting DeepSeek hard gate authority despite the non-binding advisory label.", "required_fix": "Reconcile the language: either make the DeepSeek checks truly advisory (fail only if explicitly overridden by operator) or acknowledge the veto as an explicit design choice.", "severity": "medium" }, { "category": "source_fingerprint", "description": "Lineage discovery uses 'nearby project.json / run_manifest.json' without scoping rules, risking non-deterministic candidate inspection.", "required_fix": "Define exact relative paths or a strict discovery algorithm from the candidate registry location.", "severity": "medium" }, { "category": "registry_schema", "description": "Multiple source fingerprint key names are listed without priority or conflict resolution, which could lead to ambiguous matching if a candidate carries multiple keys with divergent values.", "required_fix": "Specify key precedence and type expectations (e.g., array vs string) and a deterministic resolution strategy.", "severity": "low" }, { "category": "artifact", "description": "Advisory outputs include a manifest.json that could be mistaken for a canonical manifest, risking accidental downstream use.", "required_fix": "Write all preflight artifacts to a dedicated advisory subdirectory or prefix filenames with 'NOW_33A_' consistently.", "severity": "low" } ], "overall_verdict": "supports_current_registry_preflight_contract", "recommended_closeout_label": "contract_validated_read_only_preflight_feasible", "required_contract_corrections": [ "Define 'nearby' discovery for project.json/run_manifest.json explicitly.", "Clarify the DeepSeek fail rule to avoid contradiction with non-binding advisory status.", "Add key precedence and type handling for candidate registry source fingerprint discovery." ], "scope_audit": { "deepseek_advisory_only": true, "kg_writeback_blocked": true, "path_or_name_hint_rejected_as_authority": true, "read_only_preflight_allowed": true, "registry_creation_blocked": true, "route_transition_blocked": true, "source_fingerprint_validation_required": true, "uid_binding_blocked": true } }