{
  "confidence": "high",
  "final_recommendation": "Fix guard to enforce mandatory fingerprint block per contract and remove deepseek advisory dependency; re-issue round1 advisory with corrected scope.",
  "findings": [
    {
      "category": "boundary",
      "description": "Guard gate blocks on pending deepseek advisory, but contract defines advisory as advisory-only and does not require it to pass. This overreaches the contract.",
      "required_fix": "Remove deepseek advisory pass dependency from guard gate criteria; treat failures as warnings only.",
      "severity": "high"
    },
    {
      "category": "boundary",
      "description": "Guard gate does not block when target_source_fingerprint is absent from NOW-33 reference rerun gate, contrary to mandatory block rule in contract. It only warns instead of blocking.",
      "required_fix": "Add block condition for missing target_source_fingerprint in any required gate as per consumption guard rules; reject inference as sufficient to pass.",
      "severity": "blocker"
    },
    {
      "category": "fingerprint",
      "description": "Round1 advisory incorrectly recommends accepting fingerprint inference as a valid warning linkage and not blocking, missing the contract's must-block requirement.",
      "required_fix": "Correct round1 recommendation to enforce mandatory block when fingerprint is absent from any required gate.",
      "severity": "high"
    }
  ],
  "required_fixes": [
    "Remove deepseek advisory dependency from guard gate block criteria; log failures as warnings only.",
    "Enforce block when target_source_fingerprint is absent from NOW-33 rerun gate as required by consumption guard rules; do not accept inference as sufficient.",
    "Update round1 advisory to reflect mandatory fingerprint block requirement."
  ],
  "round1_critique": {
    "boundary_violation_detected": true,
    "fingerprint_inference_handled_honestly": true,
    "hallucination_risk_detected": false,
    "missing_assumption_detected": true,
    "operator_constraints_respected": true,
    "overreach_detected": true
  },
  "round2_verdict": "round1_needs_fix"
}