{ "boundary_confirmations": [ "No provider jobs executed or attempted.", "No image/audio/TTS/video/media generated.", "No manual/provider/operator evidence created.", "No feedback ingested.", "No repair or replay executed.", "No accepted/operator overlay, canonical KG, raw KG, or replay actions written.", "No outputs/index.json or outputs/index-lite.json mutated.", "No old B7 downstream continuation initiated.", "No runtime-branching by chapter/entity/title driven; all logic manifest-driven.", "All advice confined to advisory/control-plane schema consultation; no production state changed." ], "confidence": "high", "control_plane_update_expectations": [ "execution_state.next_entrypoint remains platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract", "All Now-32/33/34/35 artifacts written to sidecar/draft paths, not production indices.", "No acceptance or operator overlay written.", "No canonical/raw KG writeback performed.", "No provider execution authorized or queued.", "Control-plane sync includes docs only, no state promotion." ], "must_not_do": [ "Execute provider jobs.", "Generate image/audio/TTS/video/media.", "Create filled manual/provider/operator evidence.", "Ingest feedback.", "Execute repair/replay.", "Write accepted/operator overlay, canonical KG, raw KG, or replay actions.", "Manually mutate outputs/index.json or outputs/index-lite.json.", "Treat DeepSeek/advisory/template artifacts as evidence or acceptance.", "Directly continue old B7 downstream.", "Runtime-branch by chapter/entity/title/block/sample text; held/debt logic must be manifest-driven.", "Present any Now-33/34/35 output as production payload or provider prompt.", "Overwrite the proposed closeout model with any execution-authorizing action." ], "now32_scope": { "allowed": [ "Audit P2V24 debt register and draft/held rows.", "Generate a clearance-readiness manifest for each chapter.", "Classify held rows by blocked repair/evidence prerequisites.", "Flag which chapters are fully ready vs. partial/held.", "Propose ordering and priority for manual operator review.", "Produce a read-only Now-32 manifest file." ], "blocked": [ "Promote any held row to ready/production state.", "Create operator evidence or acceptance overlays.", "Execute repairs or trigger repair pipelines.", "Write to canonical KG or raw KG.", "Mutate outputs/index.json or outputs/index-lite.json.", "Ingest feedback or create feedback-linked actions.", "Authorize any provider job or media generation.", "Treat the manifest as evidence of completion." ], "closeout_condition": "Read-only manifest and debt classification produced, validated against hard boundaries, and handed off to operator for per-event authorization decisions. No state mutation." }, "now33_scope": { "allowed": [ "Deterministic entity-link binding over existing P2V22 draft prompt rows.", "Asset-slot mapping as sidecar files (e.g., identifying which assets belong to which prompt slots).", "Flag missing assets as non-evidence gaps (e.g., report missing entity or asset references).", "Output sidecar JSON/maps that can be used by future production steps.", "Operate entirely on copies or read-only views of rows." ], "blocked": [ "Write to canonical KG or raw KG.", "Generate any media or provider payload.", "Create adapter payloads or provider-specific syntax.", "Modify outputs index or production prompt files.", "Treat missing assets as hard failures that block the closeout—only flag as advisory." ], "closeout_condition": "Sidecar bindings and asset gap report generated, no KG mutation, ready for operator review to resolve missing assets manually later." }, "now34_scope": { "allowed": [ "Draft provider-neutral industry schema (e.g., structural prompt layout, required fields).", "Build a structural validator (e.g., checks field presence, word count constraints, structural integrity).", "Run dry-run on a sample set of draft rows using the validator.", "Report structural hard failures (e.g., missing mandatory segments) as advisory.", "Cover aesthetic/industry critiques only in advisory notes, not as pass/fail gates." ], "blocked": [ "Create any adapter payload or provider-specific prompt syntax.", "Generate media, images, audio, video.", "Write to production prompt files, canonical KG, or outputs index.", "Use aesthetic/industry critique as an automated gate that blocks closeout.", "Execute or simulate provider calls.", "Produce operator evidence or acceptance scores." ], "closeout_condition": "Provider-neutral schema and validator documented; structural dry-run results provided as advisory; no production-ready payloads produced; no mutations." }, "now35_scope": { "allowed": [ "Configure a DeepSeek reviewer harness (YAML/JSON configs, prompt templates, review schemas).", "Define schemas for future advisory reviews (e.g., style, consistency, compliance).", "Produce dry-run/sample advisory records on a small number of prompt rows.", "Document gates and expected inputs/outputs for a future review cycle." ], "blocked": [ "Assign acceptance scores to prompt rows.", "Write any evidence, mutate outputs index, or promote rows.", "Ingest real feedback or trigger repair/replay.", "Use reviewer output as production acceptance.", "Execute any operation that changes production state.", "Claim the harness itself constitutes evidence of readiness." ], "closeout_condition": "Harness, configs, and sample advisory records ready for operator review and activation in a future feedback loop; no production state changed." }, "overall_assessment": "The proposed controlled closeout is consistent with the system hard boundaries and current state. It advances readiness by producing structured, read-only artifacts (debt manifest, entity-asset sidecars, schema/validator, reviewer harness) while strictly avoiding any execution, evidence creation, index mutation, or state promotion. The approach reduces risk by making prerequisites explicit, surfacing held-row and missing-asset debt, and enabling operator-controlled gates before any production step. All Now-32/33/34/35 operations are defined as sidecars and remain advisory; they do not authorize production or mutate the system of record.", "overall_verdict": "supports_now32_35_controlled_closeout", "recommended_next_after_closeout": "Operator reviews Now-32 manifest and held-row debt, manually decides on promotions, resolves missing assets based on Now-33 gaps, and then—under explicit evidence contracts—authorizes provider/manual execution and media generation for ready chapters. After those production steps, outputs from Now-34/35 can be activated for real quality gates and feedback cycles.", "recommended_sequence": [ { "id": "now32_debt_audit_and_manifest", "status": "activate_as_read_only_sidecar", "why": "Surfaces all held rows and debt, classifying prerequisites that must be resolved before any production execution can be authorized. Establishes a clear gate between readiness and execution.", "must_not_do": [ "promote held rows", "create operator evidence", "execute repairs", "write canonical KG" ], "required_artifacts": [ "now32_clearance_readiness_manifest.json", "now32_blocked_prerequisites_map.json", "now32_chapter_readiness_report.json" ] }, { "id": "now33_entity_asset_sidecar", "status": "activate_as_read_only_sidecar", "why": "Pre-computes entity links and asset-slot bindings needed for eventual media generation, without creating media or mutating KG. Flags missing assets as gaps for operator resolution.", "must_not_do": [ "write canonical/raw KG", "generate media", "modify outputs index", "create provider payload" ], "required_artifacts": [ "now33_entity_link_map.json", "now33_asset_slot_map.json", "now33_missing_asset_report.json" ] }, { "id": "now34_provider_neutral_schema_and_validator", "status": "activate_as_read_only_sidecar", "why": "Defines structural quality standards before any provider-specific prompt is written. The dry-run gives early visibility into hard structural issues without coupling to any adapter.", "must_not_do": [ "create adapter payloads", "generate provider syntax", "write to production", "use aesthetic critique as automated gate" ], "required_artifacts": [ "now34_provider_neutral_schema.json", "now34_structural_validator.py", "now34_dry_run_structural_report.txt" ] }, { "id": "now35_deepseek_reviewer_harness", "status": "activate_as_read_only_sidecar", "why": "Prepares a reusable review harness for future advisory quality checks, enabling operator-controlled feedback loops without auto-acceptance or production impact.", "must_not_do": [ "assign acceptance scores", "create evidence", "mutate outputs index", "ingest feedback" ], "required_artifacts": [ "now35_deepseek_reviewer_config.yaml", "now35_review_schemas/", "now35_advisory_sample_records.json" ] } ], "required_artifacts": [ "now32_clearance_readiness_manifest.json", "now32_blocked_prerequisites_map.json", "now32_chapter_readiness_report.json", "now33_entity_link_map.json", "now33_asset_slot_map.json", "now33_missing_asset_report.json", "now34_provider_neutral_schema.json", "now34_structural_validator.py", "now34_dry_run_structural_report.txt", "now35_deepseek_reviewer_config.yaml", "now35_review_schemas/", "now35_advisory_sample_records.json" ], "risks_and_debt": [ "239 held rows with 'qa_review_required' and 1 with 'repair_deferred': manual operator review required; unresolved issues may delay production.", "7 out of 20 chapters have partial or held-only readiness; operator must decide on chapter promotion and may need additional repair contracts.", "Now-33 entity and asset binding depends on completeness of draft rows; if rows change later, sidecars may need regeneration.", "Now-34 structural validator only covers structural checks; full semantic/aesthetic quality remains unscoped until Now-35 and future feedback cycles.", "Now-35 reviewer harness is advisory-only; if mistakenly used as production evidence, it violates boundaries and creates false confidence.", "All artifacts are advisory and do not automatically authorize execution—operator inattentiveness could lead to stalled pipeline if not actively managed.", "Now-32 closeout condition requires explicit per-event operator authorization; without timely operator action, the pipeline stays in limbo." ], "validator_expectations": [ "Ensure no acceptance/operator overlay written during any Now-32..35 step.", "Verify no canonical KG, raw KG, or outputs index mutation in any log or artifact.", "Confirm no provider payload, provider syntax, adapter payload, or media file generated.", "Scan all output paths: they must be dedicated sidecar/draft locations, never overwriting production files.", "Check that the execution_state.next_entrypoint remains unchanged and is still platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract.", "For Now-32, validate that the manifest does not include any promoted row assertions.", "For Now-33, ensure entity links and asset maps reference only existing draft row IDs, and no KG write calls.", "For Now-34, confirm validator only outputs structural pass/fail and advisory text; no payload artifacts.", "For Now-35, verify harness outputs are sample/advisory records; no acceptance scores or index changes.", "Overall, run a boundary trace: no evidence of hard-boundary violations listed in must_not_do." ] }