[ { "role": "system", "content": "You are DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max acting as advisory-only reviewer. Return strict JSON only. Evaluate this stage against its stated read-only clearance contract, not against downstream production readiness." }, { "role": "user", "content": "{\"input\": {\"artifact_refs\": {\"chapter_queue\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_pending_20260607_1956/HELD_DEBT_chapter_debt_queue.jsonl\", \"sha256\": \"a9814b6c6971af5d61bddf9f1d5342638758c924a09a38c2a3330efb22931c62\", \"size_bytes\": 12504}, \"dependency_map\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_pending_20260607_1956/HELD_DEBT_dependency_map.json\", \"sha256\": \"5a8aa2672480f46cdc396f623a135c378b269e8a364efa5b8b6ff447490b5ff8\", \"size_bytes\": 42094}, \"gate\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_pending_20260607_1956/HELD_DEBT_clearance_gate.json\", \"sha256\": \"7b33f28565842a137ad1321dea9a42d5d6c2ef386545fbed3253f909ae645c64\", \"size_bytes\": 3684}, \"held_queue\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_pending_20260607_1956/HELD_DEBT_held_row_debt_queue.jsonl\", \"sha256\": \"f0b937c59b0e7b8c06b4caf085ce6e4193f31b9d1742093628226d4f3e08d54a\", \"size_bytes\": 319050}, \"integrity\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_pending_20260607_1956/HELD_DEBT_register_integrity_report.json\", \"sha256\": \"a73d3c2d759d1781cc7d6637dcd214099b235fc0eb6a669f0be741c8da5408be\", \"size_bytes\": 4217}, \"summary\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_pending_20260607_1956/HELD_DEBT_clearance_readiness_summary.json\", \"sha256\": \"afb7a286fec1a0caa96aa7aec3a406cf818448373105b786588f248119a406f1\", \"size_bytes\": 962}, \"validation\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_pending_20260607_1956/HELD_DEBT_clearance_validation_report.json\", \"sha256\": \"0b64e386193b874c02cd1e1d8f027369676b23be979c108ab04e018a0d8dc20e\", \"size_bytes\": 3320}}, \"bootstrap_review_context\": {\"actual_failures\": [\"deepseek_round1_parse_not_pass\", \"deepseek_round1_not_supporting\", \"deepseek_round1_call_not_success\", \"deepseek_round2_parse_not_pass\", \"deepseek_round2_not_supporting\", \"deepseek_round2_call_not_success\"], \"deterministic_checks_pass_if_non_deepseek_failure_count_is_zero\": true, \"expected_bootstrap_failures\": [\"deepseek_round1_call_not_success\", \"deepseek_round1_not_supporting\", \"deepseek_round1_parse_not_pass\", \"deepseek_round2_call_not_success\", \"deepseek_round2_not_supporting\", \"deepseek_round2_parse_not_pass\"], \"final_gate_expected_after_round1_round2_refs\": \"Rerun the clearance with implementation Round 1/2 directories; final pass is allowed only if deterministic failures remain zero and both consultations support with no high/blocker findings.\", \"non_deepseek_validator_failures\": [], \"pending_gate_may_be_blocked_only_by_missing_deepseek_round_refs\": true, \"purpose\": \"This consultation reviews the read-only clearance implementation before its own advisory refs can be embedded in the final rerun.\"}, \"clearance_run_dir\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_pending_20260607_1956\", \"created_at\": \"2026-06-07T11:49:31.874379Z\", \"gate\": {\"created_at\": \"2026-06-07T11:49:25.463996Z\", \"failures\": [\"deepseek_round1_parse_not_pass\", \"deepseek_round1_not_supporting\", \"deepseek_round1_call_not_success\", \"deepseek_round2_parse_not_pass\", \"deepseek_round2_not_supporting\", \"deepseek_round2_call_not_success\"], \"gate_status\": \"blocked_held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance\", \"next_entrypoint_unchanged\": true, \"operator_production_acceptance_claimed\": false, \"pass\": false, \"policy\": {\"accepted_overlay_writeback_allowed\": false, \"active_route_authority\": \"execution_state.json.next_entrypoint\", \"asset_binding_allowed\": false, \"asset_generation_or_acquisition_allowed\": false, \"canonical_kg_writeback_allowed\": false, \"canonical_uid_writeback_allowed\": false, \"deepseek_advisory_only\": true, \"entity_store_writeback_allowed\": false, \"execution_state_next_entrypoint_unchanged\": true, \"feedback_intake_allowed\": false, \"held_row_promotion_allowed\": false, \"manual_provider_evidence_creation_allowed\": false, \"media_generation_allowed\": false, \"operator_evidence_creation_allowed\": false, \"operator_overlay_writeback_allowed\": false, \"operator_production_acceptance_claimed\": false, \"outputs_index_mutation_allowed\": false, \"provider_job_execution_allowed\": false, \"raw_kg_writeback_allowed\": false, \"read_only_clearance\": true, \"readiness_row_mutation_allowed\": false, \"repair_execution_allowed\": false, \"replay_execution_allowed\": false, \"route_transition_allowed\": false, \"stage\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance\"}, \"provider_manual_execution_allowed\": false, \"repair_execution_allowed\": false, \"row_mutation_allowed\": false, \"stage\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance\", \"status\": \"blocked\", \"summary\": {\"accepted_overlay_write_count\": 0, \"adapter_payload_count\": 0, \"asset_binding_count\": 0, \"asset_slots_missing_real_reference\": 3276, \"blocker_class_counts\": {\"chapter_readiness_blocker\": 7, \"evidence_not_execution_blocker\": 247, \"held_row_qa_review\": 239, \"held_row_repair_deferred\": 1, \"source_or_shot_dependency\": 240}, \"canonical_kg_writeback_count\": 0, \"canonical_uid_writeback_count\": 0, \"chapter_package_mismatch_count\": 0, \"chapter_queue_rows\": 7, \"chapter_readiness_debt_count\": 7, \"debt_register_parse_failure_count\": 0, \"debt_row_count\": 247, \"draft_row_count\": 1638, \"duplicate_held_package_pair_count\": 0, \"entity_store_writeback_count\": 0, \"feedback_intake_count\": 0, \"held_package_parse_failure_count\": 0, \"held_package_qa_review_required_count\": 239, \"held_package_repair_deferred_count\": 1, \"held_qa_review_required_count\": 239, \"held_queue_rows\": 240, \"held_repair_deferred_count\": 1, \"held_row_count\": 240, \"held_row_debt_count\": 240, \"manual_provider_evidence_count\": 0, \"media_generation_count\": 0, \"operator_evidence_creation_count\": 0, \"operator_overlay_write_count\": 0, \"outputs_index_mutation_count\": 0, \"production_lane_accepted_count\": 0, \"provider_job_execution_count\": 0, \"provider_prompt_count\": 0, \"raw_kg_writeback_count\": 0, \"read_only\": true, \"repair_execution_allowed\": false, \"repair_execution_count\": 0, \"replay_action_count\": 0, \"row_mutation_allowed\": false, \"row_mutation_count\": 0, \"unresolved_held_package_ref_count\": 0, \"validator_failure_count\": 6}, \"validator_failure_count\": 6, \"validator_status\": \"blocked\", \"version\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_gate.v1\", \"writeback_allowed\": false}, \"hard_boundaries\": [\"Read-only clearance review only.\", \"No row mutation, repair execution, writeback, evidence, provider/media execution, asset binding, replay, route transition, outputs-index mutation, or production acceptance.\", \"The 239 QA review rows, 1 repair-deferred row, 7 chapter blockers, 247 evidence-not-execution blockers, and 3276 missing asset references are the debts this stage inventories and routes. They are not required to be resolved, promoted, evidenced, or asset-bound inside this read-only clearance implementation.\", \"Do not request provider/manual evidence creation, asset acquisition/binding, held-row promotion, repair execution, or production activation as a required fix for this stage.\", \"For a pending bootstrap run, do not treat missing DeepSeek Round 1/2 references as an implementation defect if they are the only validator failures.\", \"DeepSeek is advisory-only.\"], \"input_fingerprint\": \"59e79a3affada71ff1e649db5306595edeaa90dd66f6487903c3d5689ca58cf6\", \"integrity\": {\"chapter_package_mismatch_count\": 0, \"checks\": {\"handoff_next_entrypoint_id\": \"platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract\", \"now33_dry_run_boundary\": \"dry_run_acceptance_readiness_boundary_only_no_writeback\", \"now33_dry_run_gate_status\": \"now33_canonical_uid_binding_acceptance_dry_run_pass_non_authoritative\", \"p2v23_package_next_entrypoint_id\": \"platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract\", \"p2v24_gate_validator_status\": \"pass\", \"post_now33_gate_status\": \"post_now33_code_level_recalibration_pass\"}, \"created_at\": \"2026-06-07T11:49:25.454986Z\", \"debt_type_counts\": {\"chapter_readiness_debt\": 7, \"held_row_debt\": 240}, \"duplicate_held_package_pair_count\": 0, \"held_package_hold_label_counts\": {\"qa_review_required\": 239, \"repair_deferred\": 1}, \"hold_label_counts\": {\"qa_review_required\": 239, \"repair_deferred\": 1}, \"production_lane_accepted_count\": 0, \"read_only\": true, \"source_artifacts\": {\"contract\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/docs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_contract_20260607.md\", \"sha256\": \"2bb6a1af204802c203c79d6e968d068fc8ebad63981ed9adcdea107613932da3\", \"size_bytes\": 11530}, \"execution_state\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/execution_state.json\", \"sha256\": \"cd9f671f29ce031898bcf4f47bd3a139f07c8985f1471fe39a385c4f5dfb08cc\", \"size_bytes\": 20608}, \"now33_dry_gate\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/now33_canonical_uid_binding_acceptance_advisory_dry_run_final_20260607_1830/NOW_33_canonical_uid_binding_gate.json\", \"sha256\": \"f50834c4f0a3b3b82099a6196af1d776935eff55d4a7bc234ef042e0739da0b6\", \"size_bytes\": 14533}, \"p2v23_held_packages\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p_plan_v2_23_prompt_readiness_packaging_boundary_20260605_0730/P2V_23_held_row_package_rows.jsonl\", \"sha256\": \"4635c55a78bbb0fe95a0580a8437402dff9374ca653ff7343a305675ce3ddb36\", \"size_bytes\": 278536}, \"p2v23_package\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p_plan_v2_23_prompt_readiness_packaging_boundary_20260605_0730/P2V_23_prompt_readiness_package.json\", \"sha256\": \"a57ebbac6bef7390e5f5ff4abf46c479f3cd2f612fb66f356541dab5eee748d5\", \"size_bytes\": 11758}, \"p2v24_debt_register\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_readiness_debt_register.jsonl\", \"sha256\": \"f11848721acf1688d4b4081e3e2491944721da098d5a386fcd7b561ea135c6d5\", \"size_bytes\": 201325}, \"p2v24_gate\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_final_closeout_gate.json\", \"sha256\": \"5ea5e39cefc8378d4923585369bbeee4cf518622e8fd1ea806dd7157b12ce6ed\", \"size_bytes\": 2622}, \"p2v24_handoff\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_now32_handoff_calibration.json\", \"sha256\": \"bd34848c561c09778a5a86206a3855908aa52eb7a34d7dfebd429ffc5ed745ff\", \"size_bytes\": 3335}, \"phase_acceptance\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/phase_acceptance.json\", \"sha256\": \"bf67ac85ad4fd7792835d164287d3c99676f13e7281993572084fad8089b007e\", \"size_bytes\": 14481}, \"post_now33_gate\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/post_now33_code_level_recalibration_final_20260607_1917/POST_NOW33_recalibration_gate.json\", \"sha256\": \"adbe23758af3773595065045ea8371fe6c77f5ee39ad3f60731a228a968ee3d1\", \"size_bytes\": 4631}, \"workflow\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/workflow.json\", \"sha256\": \"ac9bac2fffcb551bbd22a7d17bfe7a6c716c369c791af9b8cfd5d020cd9bb0cd\", \"size_bytes\": 80544}}, \"stage\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance\", \"unresolved_held_package_ref_count\": 0, \"version\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance.v1\"}, \"previous_round\": {\"dir\": \".\", \"parsed\": {}}, \"round_id\": \"round1\", \"stage\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance\", \"summary\": {\"asset_slots_missing_real_reference\": 3276, \"blocker_class_counts\": {\"chapter_readiness_blocker\": 7, \"evidence_not_execution_blocker\": 247, \"held_row_qa_review\": 239, \"held_row_repair_deferred\": 1, \"source_or_shot_dependency\": 240}, \"chapter_package_mismatch_count\": 0, \"chapter_queue_rows\": 7, \"chapter_readiness_debt_count\": 7, \"debt_register_parse_failure_count\": 0, \"debt_row_count\": 247, \"draft_row_count\": 1638, \"duplicate_held_package_pair_count\": 0, \"held_package_parse_failure_count\": 0, \"held_package_qa_review_required_count\": 239, \"held_package_repair_deferred_count\": 1, \"held_qa_review_required_count\": 239, \"held_queue_rows\": 240, \"held_repair_deferred_count\": 1, \"held_row_count\": 240, \"held_row_debt_count\": 240, \"production_lane_accepted_count\": 0, \"read_only\": true, \"repair_execution_allowed\": false, \"row_mutation_allowed\": false, \"unresolved_held_package_ref_count\": 0}, \"validation\": {\"created_at\": \"2026-06-07T11:49:25.463951Z\", \"failure_count\": 6, \"failures\": [\"deepseek_round1_parse_not_pass\", \"deepseek_round1_not_supporting\", \"deepseek_round1_call_not_success\", \"deepseek_round2_parse_not_pass\", \"deepseek_round2_not_supporting\", \"deepseek_round2_call_not_success\"], \"policy\": {\"accepted_overlay_writeback_allowed\": false, \"active_route_authority\": \"execution_state.json.next_entrypoint\", \"asset_binding_allowed\": false, \"asset_generation_or_acquisition_allowed\": false, \"canonical_kg_writeback_allowed\": false, \"canonical_uid_writeback_allowed\": false, \"deepseek_advisory_only\": true, \"entity_store_writeback_allowed\": false, \"execution_state_next_entrypoint_unchanged\": true, \"feedback_intake_allowed\": false, \"held_row_promotion_allowed\": false, \"manual_provider_evidence_creation_allowed\": false, \"media_generation_allowed\": false, \"operator_evidence_creation_allowed\": false, \"operator_overlay_writeback_allowed\": false, \"operator_production_acceptance_claimed\": false, \"outputs_index_mutation_allowed\": false, \"provider_job_execution_allowed\": false, \"raw_kg_writeback_allowed\": false, \"read_only_clearance\": true, \"readiness_row_mutation_allowed\": false, \"repair_execution_allowed\": false, \"replay_execution_allowed\": false, \"route_transition_allowed\": false, \"stage\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance\"}, \"stage\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance\", \"status\": \"blocked\", \"summary\": {\"accepted_overlay_write_count\": 0, \"adapter_payload_count\": 0, \"asset_binding_count\": 0, \"asset_slots_missing_real_reference\": 3276, \"blocker_class_counts\": {\"chapter_readiness_blocker\": 7, \"evidence_not_execution_blocker\": 247, \"held_row_qa_review\": 239, \"held_row_repair_deferred\": 1, \"source_or_shot_dependency\": 240}, \"canonical_kg_writeback_count\": 0, \"canonical_uid_writeback_count\": 0, \"chapter_package_mismatch_count\": 0, \"chapter_queue_rows\": 7, \"chapter_readiness_debt_count\": 7, \"debt_register_parse_failure_count\": 0, \"debt_row_count\": 247, \"draft_row_count\": 1638, \"duplicate_held_package_pair_count\": 0, \"entity_store_writeback_count\": 0, \"feedback_intake_count\": 0, \"held_package_parse_failure_count\": 0, \"held_package_qa_review_required_count\": 239, \"held_package_repair_deferred_count\": 1, \"held_qa_review_required_count\": 239, \"held_queue_rows\": 240, \"held_repair_deferred_count\": 1, \"held_row_count\": 240, \"held_row_debt_count\": 240, \"manual_provider_evidence_count\": 0, \"media_generation_count\": 0, \"operator_evidence_creation_count\": 0, \"operator_overlay_write_count\": 0, \"outputs_index_mutation_count\": 0, \"production_lane_accepted_count\": 0, \"provider_job_execution_count\": 0, \"provider_prompt_count\": 0, \"raw_kg_writeback_count\": 0, \"read_only\": true, \"repair_execution_allowed\": false, \"repair_execution_count\": 0, \"replay_action_count\": 0, \"row_mutation_allowed\": false, \"row_mutation_count\": 0, \"unresolved_held_package_ref_count\": 0, \"validator_failure_count\": 6}, \"version\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance.v1\"}, \"version\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_deepseek.v1\"}, \"review_instructions\": [\"Support the implementation if deterministic counts, refs, no-side-effect policy, review surface, and boundary checks are correct, even when the pending gate is blocked solely because this very DeepSeek round and its paired round are not embedded yet.\", \"Do not require resolving QA-held rows, repair-deferred rows, chapter debt, evidence debt, missing assets, provider/manual execution, or production acceptance inside this read-only stage.\", \"Raise blocker/high findings only for implementation defects: missing authoritative refs, count drift, unresolved cross-file package refs, hidden mutation/writeback/evidence/provider/asset/replay/route side effects, inadequate validators, or authority confusion.\"], \"round_id\": \"round1\", \"schema\": {\"confidence\": \"high | medium | low\", \"findings\": [{\"category\": \"validator | evidence | boundary | review_surface | other\", \"description\": \"issue\", \"required_fix\": \"fix\", \"severity\": \"blocker | high | medium | low\"}], \"overall_verdict\": \"supports_held_debt_clearance_read_only_implementation | supports_with_required_corrections | does_not_support\", \"parse_status\": \"pass\", \"recommended_disposition\": \"land_as_written | land_after_corrections | block\", \"required_corrections\": [\"fix\"]}, \"task\": \"Review held/debt read-only clearance implementation output.\"}" } ]