[ { "role": "system", "content": "You are DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max acting as advisory-only reviewer. Return strict JSON only." }, { "role": "user", "content": "{\"input\": {\"artifact_refs\": {\"chapter_queue\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_pending_20260607_1948/HELD_DEBT_chapter_debt_queue.jsonl\", \"sha256\": \"a9814b6c6971af5d61bddf9f1d5342638758c924a09a38c2a3330efb22931c62\", \"size_bytes\": 12504}, \"dependency_map\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_pending_20260607_1948/HELD_DEBT_dependency_map.json\", \"sha256\": \"0e698893b4b245daba979b13dc62a8dbc6d5e647dd4da3f394d0e77540f895b8\", \"size_bytes\": 42094}, \"gate\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_pending_20260607_1948/HELD_DEBT_clearance_gate.json\", \"sha256\": \"458174f16f7f70e62efcc20879791b08bf28f2e8f6ba797c1f6bdbd495007643\", \"size_bytes\": 3684}, \"held_queue\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_pending_20260607_1948/HELD_DEBT_held_row_debt_queue.jsonl\", \"sha256\": \"f0b937c59b0e7b8c06b4caf085ce6e4193f31b9d1742093628226d4f3e08d54a\", \"size_bytes\": 319050}, \"integrity\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_pending_20260607_1948/HELD_DEBT_register_integrity_report.json\", \"sha256\": \"980ad95b371ba8014d7aec979ea557a7978575ddc76bf89dc08e6d22c82becef\", \"size_bytes\": 4217}, \"summary\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_pending_20260607_1948/HELD_DEBT_clearance_readiness_summary.json\", \"sha256\": \"afb7a286fec1a0caa96aa7aec3a406cf818448373105b786588f248119a406f1\", \"size_bytes\": 962}, \"validation\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_pending_20260607_1948/HELD_DEBT_clearance_validation_report.json\", \"sha256\": \"b02331e04ae8d22a2a021bddac1a9d58ccc216a322a93dfcba57b34e849cc2ff\", \"size_bytes\": 3320}}, \"clearance_run_dir\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_pending_20260607_1948\", \"created_at\": \"2026-06-07T11:47:11.489044Z\", \"gate\": {\"created_at\": \"2026-06-07T11:47:04.570867Z\", \"failures\": [\"deepseek_round1_parse_not_pass\", \"deepseek_round1_not_supporting\", \"deepseek_round1_call_not_success\", \"deepseek_round2_parse_not_pass\", \"deepseek_round2_not_supporting\", \"deepseek_round2_call_not_success\"], \"gate_status\": \"blocked_held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance\", \"next_entrypoint_unchanged\": true, \"operator_production_acceptance_claimed\": false, \"pass\": false, \"policy\": {\"accepted_overlay_writeback_allowed\": false, \"active_route_authority\": \"execution_state.json.next_entrypoint\", \"asset_binding_allowed\": false, \"asset_generation_or_acquisition_allowed\": false, \"canonical_kg_writeback_allowed\": false, \"canonical_uid_writeback_allowed\": false, \"deepseek_advisory_only\": true, \"entity_store_writeback_allowed\": false, \"execution_state_next_entrypoint_unchanged\": true, \"feedback_intake_allowed\": false, \"held_row_promotion_allowed\": false, \"manual_provider_evidence_creation_allowed\": false, \"media_generation_allowed\": false, \"operator_evidence_creation_allowed\": false, \"operator_overlay_writeback_allowed\": false, \"operator_production_acceptance_claimed\": false, \"outputs_index_mutation_allowed\": false, \"provider_job_execution_allowed\": false, \"raw_kg_writeback_allowed\": false, \"read_only_clearance\": true, \"readiness_row_mutation_allowed\": false, \"repair_execution_allowed\": false, \"replay_execution_allowed\": false, \"route_transition_allowed\": false, \"stage\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance\"}, \"provider_manual_execution_allowed\": false, \"repair_execution_allowed\": false, \"row_mutation_allowed\": false, \"stage\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance\", \"status\": \"blocked\", \"summary\": {\"accepted_overlay_write_count\": 0, \"adapter_payload_count\": 0, \"asset_binding_count\": 0, \"asset_slots_missing_real_reference\": 3276, \"blocker_class_counts\": {\"chapter_readiness_blocker\": 7, \"evidence_not_execution_blocker\": 247, \"held_row_qa_review\": 239, \"held_row_repair_deferred\": 1, \"source_or_shot_dependency\": 240}, \"canonical_kg_writeback_count\": 0, \"canonical_uid_writeback_count\": 0, \"chapter_package_mismatch_count\": 0, \"chapter_queue_rows\": 7, \"chapter_readiness_debt_count\": 7, \"debt_register_parse_failure_count\": 0, \"debt_row_count\": 247, \"draft_row_count\": 1638, \"duplicate_held_package_pair_count\": 0, \"entity_store_writeback_count\": 0, \"feedback_intake_count\": 0, \"held_package_parse_failure_count\": 0, \"held_package_qa_review_required_count\": 239, \"held_package_repair_deferred_count\": 1, \"held_qa_review_required_count\": 239, \"held_queue_rows\": 240, \"held_repair_deferred_count\": 1, \"held_row_count\": 240, \"held_row_debt_count\": 240, \"manual_provider_evidence_count\": 0, \"media_generation_count\": 0, \"operator_evidence_creation_count\": 0, \"operator_overlay_write_count\": 0, \"outputs_index_mutation_count\": 0, \"production_lane_accepted_count\": 0, \"provider_job_execution_count\": 0, \"provider_prompt_count\": 0, \"raw_kg_writeback_count\": 0, \"read_only\": true, \"repair_execution_allowed\": false, \"repair_execution_count\": 0, \"replay_action_count\": 0, \"row_mutation_allowed\": false, \"row_mutation_count\": 0, \"unresolved_held_package_ref_count\": 0, \"validator_failure_count\": 6}, \"validator_failure_count\": 6, \"validator_status\": \"blocked\", \"version\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_gate.v1\", \"writeback_allowed\": false}, \"hard_boundaries\": [\"Read-only clearance review only.\", \"No row mutation, repair execution, writeback, evidence, provider/media execution, asset binding, replay, route transition, outputs-index mutation, or production acceptance.\", \"DeepSeek is advisory-only.\"], \"input_fingerprint\": \"41ebefa9d59a8bb2ced649051c1097d63dde08613d65b0ed3d4aeb6412f53b29\", \"integrity\": {\"chapter_package_mismatch_count\": 0, \"checks\": {\"handoff_next_entrypoint_id\": \"platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract\", \"now33_dry_run_boundary\": \"dry_run_acceptance_readiness_boundary_only_no_writeback\", \"now33_dry_run_gate_status\": \"now33_canonical_uid_binding_acceptance_dry_run_pass_non_authoritative\", \"p2v23_package_next_entrypoint_id\": \"platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract\", \"p2v24_gate_validator_status\": \"pass\", \"post_now33_gate_status\": \"post_now33_code_level_recalibration_pass\"}, \"created_at\": \"2026-06-07T11:47:04.561469Z\", \"debt_type_counts\": {\"chapter_readiness_debt\": 7, \"held_row_debt\": 240}, \"duplicate_held_package_pair_count\": 0, \"held_package_hold_label_counts\": {\"qa_review_required\": 239, \"repair_deferred\": 1}, \"hold_label_counts\": {\"qa_review_required\": 239, \"repair_deferred\": 1}, \"production_lane_accepted_count\": 0, \"read_only\": true, \"source_artifacts\": {\"contract\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/docs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_contract_20260607.md\", \"sha256\": \"2bb6a1af204802c203c79d6e968d068fc8ebad63981ed9adcdea107613932da3\", \"size_bytes\": 11530}, \"execution_state\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/execution_state.json\", \"sha256\": \"cd9f671f29ce031898bcf4f47bd3a139f07c8985f1471fe39a385c4f5dfb08cc\", \"size_bytes\": 20608}, \"now33_dry_gate\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/now33_canonical_uid_binding_acceptance_advisory_dry_run_final_20260607_1830/NOW_33_canonical_uid_binding_gate.json\", \"sha256\": \"f50834c4f0a3b3b82099a6196af1d776935eff55d4a7bc234ef042e0739da0b6\", \"size_bytes\": 14533}, \"p2v23_held_packages\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p_plan_v2_23_prompt_readiness_packaging_boundary_20260605_0730/P2V_23_held_row_package_rows.jsonl\", \"sha256\": \"4635c55a78bbb0fe95a0580a8437402dff9374ca653ff7343a305675ce3ddb36\", \"size_bytes\": 278536}, \"p2v23_package\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p_plan_v2_23_prompt_readiness_packaging_boundary_20260605_0730/P2V_23_prompt_readiness_package.json\", \"sha256\": \"a57ebbac6bef7390e5f5ff4abf46c479f3cd2f612fb66f356541dab5eee748d5\", \"size_bytes\": 11758}, \"p2v24_debt_register\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_readiness_debt_register.jsonl\", \"sha256\": \"f11848721acf1688d4b4081e3e2491944721da098d5a386fcd7b561ea135c6d5\", \"size_bytes\": 201325}, \"p2v24_gate\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_final_closeout_gate.json\", \"sha256\": \"5ea5e39cefc8378d4923585369bbeee4cf518622e8fd1ea806dd7157b12ce6ed\", \"size_bytes\": 2622}, \"p2v24_handoff\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_now32_handoff_calibration.json\", \"sha256\": \"bd34848c561c09778a5a86206a3855908aa52eb7a34d7dfebd429ffc5ed745ff\", \"size_bytes\": 3335}, \"phase_acceptance\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/phase_acceptance.json\", \"sha256\": \"bf67ac85ad4fd7792835d164287d3c99676f13e7281993572084fad8089b007e\", \"size_bytes\": 14481}, \"post_now33_gate\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/post_now33_code_level_recalibration_final_20260607_1917/POST_NOW33_recalibration_gate.json\", \"sha256\": \"adbe23758af3773595065045ea8371fe6c77f5ee39ad3f60731a228a968ee3d1\", \"size_bytes\": 4631}, \"workflow\": {\"exists\": true, \"path\": \"/wwwb/aitools/writer/workflow.json\", \"sha256\": \"ac9bac2fffcb551bbd22a7d17bfe7a6c716c369c791af9b8cfd5d020cd9bb0cd\", \"size_bytes\": 80544}}, \"stage\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance\", \"unresolved_held_package_ref_count\": 0, \"version\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance.v1\"}, \"previous_round\": {\"dir\": \".\", \"parsed\": {}}, \"round_id\": \"round1\", \"stage\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance\", \"summary\": {\"asset_slots_missing_real_reference\": 3276, \"blocker_class_counts\": {\"chapter_readiness_blocker\": 7, \"evidence_not_execution_blocker\": 247, \"held_row_qa_review\": 239, \"held_row_repair_deferred\": 1, \"source_or_shot_dependency\": 240}, \"chapter_package_mismatch_count\": 0, \"chapter_queue_rows\": 7, \"chapter_readiness_debt_count\": 7, \"debt_register_parse_failure_count\": 0, \"debt_row_count\": 247, \"draft_row_count\": 1638, \"duplicate_held_package_pair_count\": 0, \"held_package_parse_failure_count\": 0, \"held_package_qa_review_required_count\": 239, \"held_package_repair_deferred_count\": 1, \"held_qa_review_required_count\": 239, \"held_queue_rows\": 240, \"held_repair_deferred_count\": 1, \"held_row_count\": 240, \"held_row_debt_count\": 240, \"production_lane_accepted_count\": 0, \"read_only\": true, \"repair_execution_allowed\": false, \"row_mutation_allowed\": false, \"unresolved_held_package_ref_count\": 0}, \"validation\": {\"created_at\": \"2026-06-07T11:47:04.570750Z\", \"failure_count\": 6, \"failures\": [\"deepseek_round1_parse_not_pass\", \"deepseek_round1_not_supporting\", \"deepseek_round1_call_not_success\", \"deepseek_round2_parse_not_pass\", \"deepseek_round2_not_supporting\", \"deepseek_round2_call_not_success\"], \"policy\": {\"accepted_overlay_writeback_allowed\": false, \"active_route_authority\": \"execution_state.json.next_entrypoint\", \"asset_binding_allowed\": false, \"asset_generation_or_acquisition_allowed\": false, \"canonical_kg_writeback_allowed\": false, \"canonical_uid_writeback_allowed\": false, \"deepseek_advisory_only\": true, \"entity_store_writeback_allowed\": false, \"execution_state_next_entrypoint_unchanged\": true, \"feedback_intake_allowed\": false, \"held_row_promotion_allowed\": false, \"manual_provider_evidence_creation_allowed\": false, \"media_generation_allowed\": false, \"operator_evidence_creation_allowed\": false, \"operator_overlay_writeback_allowed\": false, \"operator_production_acceptance_claimed\": false, \"outputs_index_mutation_allowed\": false, \"provider_job_execution_allowed\": false, \"raw_kg_writeback_allowed\": false, \"read_only_clearance\": true, \"readiness_row_mutation_allowed\": false, \"repair_execution_allowed\": false, \"replay_execution_allowed\": false, \"route_transition_allowed\": false, \"stage\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance\"}, \"stage\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance\", \"status\": \"blocked\", \"summary\": {\"accepted_overlay_write_count\": 0, \"adapter_payload_count\": 0, \"asset_binding_count\": 0, \"asset_slots_missing_real_reference\": 3276, \"blocker_class_counts\": {\"chapter_readiness_blocker\": 7, \"evidence_not_execution_blocker\": 247, \"held_row_qa_review\": 239, \"held_row_repair_deferred\": 1, \"source_or_shot_dependency\": 240}, \"canonical_kg_writeback_count\": 0, \"canonical_uid_writeback_count\": 0, \"chapter_package_mismatch_count\": 0, \"chapter_queue_rows\": 7, \"chapter_readiness_debt_count\": 7, \"debt_register_parse_failure_count\": 0, \"debt_row_count\": 247, \"draft_row_count\": 1638, \"duplicate_held_package_pair_count\": 0, \"entity_store_writeback_count\": 0, \"feedback_intake_count\": 0, \"held_package_parse_failure_count\": 0, \"held_package_qa_review_required_count\": 239, \"held_package_repair_deferred_count\": 1, \"held_qa_review_required_count\": 239, \"held_queue_rows\": 240, \"held_repair_deferred_count\": 1, \"held_row_count\": 240, \"held_row_debt_count\": 240, \"manual_provider_evidence_count\": 0, \"media_generation_count\": 0, \"operator_evidence_creation_count\": 0, \"operator_overlay_write_count\": 0, \"outputs_index_mutation_count\": 0, \"production_lane_accepted_count\": 0, \"provider_job_execution_count\": 0, \"provider_prompt_count\": 0, \"raw_kg_writeback_count\": 0, \"read_only\": true, \"repair_execution_allowed\": false, \"repair_execution_count\": 0, \"replay_action_count\": 0, \"row_mutation_allowed\": false, \"row_mutation_count\": 0, \"unresolved_held_package_ref_count\": 0, \"validator_failure_count\": 6}, \"version\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance.v1\"}, \"version\": \"held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_deepseek.v1\"}, \"round_id\": \"round1\", \"schema\": {\"confidence\": \"high | medium | low\", \"findings\": [{\"category\": \"validator | evidence | boundary | review_surface | other\", \"description\": \"issue\", \"required_fix\": \"fix\", \"severity\": \"blocker | high | medium | low\"}], \"overall_verdict\": \"supports_held_debt_clearance_read_only_implementation | supports_with_required_corrections | does_not_support\", \"parse_status\": \"pass\", \"recommended_disposition\": \"land_as_written | land_after_corrections | block\", \"required_corrections\": [\"fix\"]}, \"task\": \"Review held/debt read-only clearance implementation output.\"}" } ]