{ "version": "held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_contract_deepseek.v1", "created_at": "2026-06-07T11:25:31.060139Z", "stage": "held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_contract", "round_id": "round1", "project_root": "/wwwb/aitools/writer", "output_run_dir": "outputs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_contract_deepseek_round1_20260607_1930", "contract_doc_ref": { "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/docs/held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_contract_20260607.md", "exists": true, "sha256": "9ccc8992100c8bf8bc389b3e3ab5c8e1276abcaa2d91d45e4095d27e083cc48c", "size_bytes": 7166 }, "contract_doc_excerpt": "# Held/Debt Repair Readiness Clearance Contract\n\n更新时间：`2026-06-07T19:28:00+08:00`\n\n## Status\n\n- contract id: `held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_contract`\n- status: `held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_contract_landed_pending_implementation`\n- active route remains: `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`\n- active route authority: `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`\n- basis retrospective: `docs/post_now33_code_level_retrospective_control_plane_recalibration_20260607.md`\n- detail rules: `outputs/post_now33_code_level_recalibration_final_20260607_1917/POST_NOW33_next_stage_detail_rules.json`\n\n## Purpose\n\nCreate the next explicit mainline after NOW-33/34/35 terminal boundary reconciliation: a read-only held/debt repair readiness clearance lane.\n\nThe lane classifies held/debt blockers, verifies register integrity, derives dependency groups, and prepares review/repair readiness packets. It does not promote held rows, mutate readiness rows, execute repair, write overlays/KG, bind assets, create evidence, run providers, replay, transition route, mutate outputs indexes, or claim production acceptance.\n\n## Authoritative Inputs\n\nRequired inputs for implementation:\n\n- P2V-24 final closeout gate: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_final_closeout_gate.json`\n- P2V-24 readiness debt register: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_readiness_debt_register.jsonl`\n- P2V-24 NOW-32 handoff calibration: `outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_now32_handoff_calibration.json`\n- P2V-23 held row package rows: `outputs/p_plan_v2_23_prompt_readiness_packaging_boundary_20260605_0730/P2V_23_held_row_package_rows.jsonl`\n- P2V-23 prompt readiness package: `outputs/p_plan_v2_23_prompt_readiness_packaging_boundary_20260605_0730/P2V_23_prompt_readiness_package.json`\n- NOW-33 dry-run gate: `outputs/now33_canonical_uid_binding_acceptance_advisory_dry_run_final_20260607_1830/NOW_33_canonical_uid_binding_gate.json`\n- post-NOW-33 recalibration gate: `outputs/post_now33_code_level_recalibration_final_20260607_1917/POST_NOW33_recalibration_gate.json`\n\nBaseline counts from current evidence:\n\n- draft rows: `1638`\n- held rows: `240`\n- readiness debt rows: `247`\n- chapter readiness debt rows: `7`\n- held row debt rows: `240`\n- held `qa_review_required`: `239`\n- held `repair_deferred`: `1`\n- asset slots missing real reference: `3276`\n\nThese are baseline evidence counts only. The implementation must re-derive them from authoritative input artifacts at runtime and block on unexplained drift.\n\n## Allowed Work\n\nImplementation may:\n\n- read and fingerprint required input artifacts;\n- parse P2V-24 debt register JSONL and P2V-23 held package JSONL;\n- verify row counts, unique IDs, debt type counts, hold label counts, and cross-file referential integrity;\n- group debt by chapter, held row, source/shot refs, readiness impact, hold label, and required future contract;\n- classify blocker categories using deterministic rules and optional DeepSeek advisory semantics;\n- emit read-only queues and review surfaces:\n - `HELD_DEBT_clearance_input.json`\n - `HELD_DEBT_register_integrity_report.json`\n - `HELD_DEBT_chapter_debt_queue.jsonl`\n - `HELD_DEBT_held_row_debt_queue.jsonl`\n - `HELD_DEBT_dependency_map.json`\n - `HELD_DEBT_clearance_readiness_summary.json`\n - `HELD_DEBT_clearance_validation_report.json`\n - `HELD_DEBT_clearance_gate.json`\n - `HELD_DEBT_clearance_review.html`\n - `manifest.json`\n- record two DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max advisory rounds for implementation closeout.\n\n## Forbidden Work\n\nImplementation must not:\n\n- promote held rows;\n- mutate draft, held, readiness, package, or debt rows;\n- create accepted/operator overlays;\n- write canonical UID, canonical KG, raw KG, entity store, or replay actions;\n- generate/acquire/bind assets;\n- generate provider-specific prompts or adapter payloads;\n- execute provider jobs or generate media;\n- create manual/provider/operator evidence;\n- ingest feedback, execute repair, or replay;\n- mutate `outputs/index.json` / `outputs/index-lite.json`;\n- change `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`;\n- claim production readiness or operator acceptance.\n\n## Deterministic Validation Rules\n\nImplementation gate must fail if any of the following occurs:\n\n- required input artifact is missing or hash cannot be computed;\n- P2V-24 gate is missing or validator status is not pass;\n- P2V-24 debt register row count does not match re-derived debt totals;\n- debt IDs are missing or duplicated;\n- held row debts do not resolve to exactly one held package row by `held_row_id` and `held_package_row_id`;\n- chapter readiness debts do not reconcile with chapter-level held counts;\n- any row has `production_lane_accepted=true`;\n- any output claims writeback, evidence, provider/media execution, route transition, replay, asset binding, output-index mutation, or production acceptance;\n- DeepSeek Round 1 or Round 2 is skipped, timeout, unavailable, parse-failed, or has unresolved high/blocker findings;\n- `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint` changes.\n\n## Classification Rules\n\nInitial deterministic classes:\n\n- `chapter_readiness_blocker`: `debt_type=chapter_readiness_debt`\n- `held_row_qa_review`: `debt_type=held_row_debt` and `hold_label=qa_review_required`\n- `held_row_repair_deferred`: `debt_type=held_row_debt` and `hold_label=repair_deferred`\n- `source_or_shot_dependency`: held row carries `p2v18_shot_id`, `p2v19_shot_packet_id`, `p2v20_readiness_row_id`, or `p2v21_planning_row_id`\n- `evidence_not_execution_blocker`: `required_future_contract=explicit_QA_repair_or_evidence_contract_after_P计划_closeout`\n\nLLM may advise semantic subtype or review priority, but program owns final queue IDs, schemas, validators, counts, and gate status.\n\n## DeepSeek Consultation Requirements\n\nBefore implementation closeout:\n\n- Round 1 must review contract implementation, queues, validators, review surface, and evidence boundaries.\n- Round 2 must critique Round 1 for overreach, missed drift, hidden mutation, authority confusion, missing assumptions, and operator constraints.\n- model: `deepseek-v4-pro`\n- thinking: enabled\n- reasoning effort: `max`\n- timeout: `600`\n- missing/skipped/timeout/unavailable/parse_failed blocks pass/readiness unless explicitly recorded as `blocked_unavailable`.\n\nDeepSeek is advisory-only. It may satisfy expert consultation under operator delegation, but it is not operator acceptance, provider/manual evidence, route authority, writeback authority, replay authority, or outputs-index authority.\n\n## Acceptance Criteria\n\nThe contract is landed when:\n\n- this document exists and is referenced by control-plane short files;\n- two DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max consultation rounds for the contract parse pass with no high/blocker findings;\n- `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint` remains unchanged;\n- JSON parse, workflow_guard, and git diff check pass.\n\nThe implementation is not landed by this contract. A future implementation batch must create the deterministic runner, artifacts, tests, DeepSeek implementation rounds, retrospective, and control-plane updates.\n\n", "post_now33_recalibration_gate": { "version": "post_now33_code_level_recalibration_gate.v1", "created_at": "2026-06-07T11:14:10.168048Z", "stage": "post_now33_code_level_retrospective_control_plane_recalibration", "status": "now33_34_35_terminal_boundary_reconciled_landed_validated", "gate_status": "post_now33_code_level_recalibration_pass", "pass": true, "validator_status": "pass", "validator_failure_count": 0, "failures": [], "summary": { "draft_row_count": 1638, "held_row_count": 240, "readiness_debt_row_count": 247, "asset_slots_missing_real_reference": 3276, "now32_advisory_status": "advisory_held_debt_audit_closed_no_promotion", "now33_initial_advisory_status": "advisory_entity_asset_gap_assessment_closed_no_writeback", "now34_advisory_status": "pass", "now35_advisory_status": "advisory_reviewer_harness_closed_no_acceptance", "target_registry_entity_count": 713, "target_registry_authority_satisfying_count": 28, "target_registry_blocked_for_review_count": 685, "target_source_fingerprint": "c5d6ab4f5d8bc0aa4a018ebe6daec3315b0d646cb189b1a4fb28fe9a6e23ba34", "now33_guard_candidate_ref_count": 1476, "now33_guard_registry_review_queue_rows": 28, "now33_guard_candidate_ref_review_queue_rows": 1476, "now33_dry_decision_candidate_count": 1504, "now33_dry_overlay_binding_candidate_count": 98, "now33_dry_deferred_candidate_ref_count": 1378, "now33_dry_registry_change_request_count": 28, "now33_dry_validator_failure_count": 0, "now33_dry_validator_warning_count": 0, "deepseek_round1_parse_status": "pass", "deepseek_round1_verdict": "supports_post_now33_code_level_recalibration", "deepseek_round2_parse_status": "pass", "deepseek_round2_verdict": "round1_supported_with_corrections", "validator_failure_count": 0, "provider_prompt_count": 0, "adapter_payload_count": 0, "provider_job_execution_count": 0, "media_generation_count": 0, "manual_provider_evidence_count": 0, "operator_evidence_creation_count": 0, "feedback_intake_count": 0, "repair_execution_count": 0, "replay_action_count": 0, "accepted_overlay_write_count": 0, "operator_overlay_write_count": 0, "canonical_uid_writeback_count": 0, "canonical_kg_writeback_count": 0, "raw_kg_writeback_count": 0, "entity_store_writeback_count": 0, "outputs_index_mutation_count": 0 }, "now33_34_35_terminal_boundary_reconciled": true, "now33_closed_as": "dry_run_acceptance_readiness_boundary_only_no_writeback", "now34_closed_as": "advisory_schema_validator_closed_no_provider_payload", "now35_closed_as": "advisory_reviewer_harness_closed_no_acceptance", "next_primary_lane": "held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_contract", "next_primary_lane_requires_explicit_contract": true, "active_route_unchanged": true, "next_entrypoint_unchanged": true, "canonical_uid_writeback_allowed": false, "provider_manual_execution_allowed": false, "operator_production_acceptance_claimed": false, "deepseek_advisory_is_operator_production_acceptance": false, "policy": { "stage": "post_now33_code_level_retrospective_control_plane_recalibration", "retrospective_control_plane_and_planning_only": true, "active_route_authority": "execution_state.json.next_entrypoint", "execution_state_next_entrypoint_unchanged": true, "route_transition_allowed": false, "provider_specific_prompt_allowed": false, "adapter_payload_allowed": false, "provider_job_execution_allowed": false, "media_generation_allowed": false, "manual_provider_evidence_creation_allowed": false, "operator_evidence_creation_allowed": false, "feedback_intake_allowed": false, "repair_execution_allowed": false, "replay_execution_allowed": false, "accepted_overlay_writeback_allowed": false, "operator_overlay_writeback_allowed": false, "canonical_uid_writeback_allowed": false, "canonical_kg_writeback_allowed": false, "raw_kg_writeback_allowed": false, "entity_store_writeback_allowed": false, "row_mutation_allowed": false, "asset_generation_or_acquisition_allowed": false, "asset_binding_allowed": false, "outputs_index_mutation_allowed": false, "operator_production_acceptance_claimed": false, "deepseek_advisory_may_substitute_for_expert_advice": true, "deepseek_advisory_is_operator_production_acceptance": false, "deepseek_findings_are_program_validator_inputs": true, "deepseek_findings_have_direct_state_authority": false, "runtime_branch_by_work_title_entity_name_or_sample_text_allowed": false } }, "post_now33_detail_rules": { "version": "post_now33_code_level_recalibration.v1", "stage": "post_now33_code_level_retrospective_control_plane_recalibration", "primary_lane": "held_debt_repair_readiness_clearance_contract", "contract_scope": { "type": "read_only_contract_first", "allowed": [ "load P2V-24 readiness debt register and held rows", "load NOW-32..35 advisory sidecar summaries", "load NOW-33 guard and dry-run summaries as context", "classify blocker categories deterministically", "emit held/debt repair readiness queues, dependency map, validator report, gate, and review HTML", "use DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max for semantic blocker taxonomy and critique" ], "not_allowed": [ "held-row promotion", "readiness row mutation", "accepted/operator overlay writeback", "canonical UID/KG/raw KG/entity-store writeback", "asset generation, acquisition, or binding", "provider/media/manual execution", "evidence creation", "feedback intake, repair, replay, route transition, outputs-index mutation, or production acceptance" ] }, "input_invariants": { "observed_baseline_held_rows": 240, "observed_baseline_readiness_debt_rows": 247, "observed_baseline_draft_rows": 1638, "runtime_rederive_required": true, "runtime_authorities": [ "P2V-24 final closeout readiness/debt artifacts", "NOW-32 advisory held/debt sidecars", "current manifest-driven readiness registers named by the contract input" ], "baseline_count_rule": "observed baseline counts are audit context only; the next contract must re-derive counts from authoritative registers at execution time and block on unexplained drift", "now33_dry_run_boundary": "dry_run_acceptance_readiness_boundary_only_no_writeback", "now34_boundary": "advisory_schema_validator_closed_no_provider_payload", "now35_boundary": "advisory_reviewer_harness_closed_no_acceptance", "manifest_driven_only": true, "runtime_branch_by_chapter_entity_title_or_sample_text_allowed": false }, "gate_pass_requires": [ "program-owned input hashes for readiness/debt and NOW-33 context artifacts", "held/debt row counts reconcile with current evidence or discrepancy is blocked", "every queue row carries source refs and blocker taxonomy", "no row mutation/writeback/evidence/provider/asset/route side-effect counters are nonzero", "DeepSeek Round 1 and Round 2 parse pass with no unresolved high/blocker findings", "review surface clearly separates current canonical state, advisory recommendations, blocked actions, and next allowed decisions", "execution_state.json.next_entrypoint unchanged" ], "deepseek_rules": { "required_rounds": 2, "model": "deepseek-v4-pro", "thinking_type": "enabled", "reasoning_effort": "max", "timeout_seconds": 600, "missing_skipped_timeout_or_parse_failed_blocks_pass": true, "availability_boundary_note": "DeepSeek unavailable/skipped/timeout/parse_failed blocks pass/readiness for high-impact gates under current project policy; it is not optional and never becomes operator acceptance or canonical authority.", "advisory_only": true }, "deepseek_round2_finding_disposition": { "absorbed": [ "post-slimming workflow_guard structural integrity verification", "runtime re-derivation of held/debt/draft counts from authoritative registers" ], "rejected_invalid": [ { "finding": "gate passage does not require successful DeepSeek call", "reason": "Contradicts AGENTS.md and workflow policy: missing/skipped/unparseable DeepSeek advisory blocks pass/readiness unless explicitly recorded as blocked_unavailable. DeepSeek remains advisory-only but its required availability is still a gate precondition for this high-impact decision." } ] }, "terminal_now33_34_35_acceptance": { "status": "now33_34_35_terminal_boundary_reconciled_landed_validated", "interpretation": "NOW-33/34/35 are closed at the current authorized non-execution boundaries; production/evidence/writeback extensions are blocked, not silently pending inside these NOW labels.", "now33": { "closed": true, "closed_as": "canonical_uid_binding_acceptance_dry_run_closed_no_writeback", "boundary": "dry_run_acceptance_readiness_boundary_only_no_writeback", "dry_run_overlay_binding_candidates": 98, "deferred_candidate_refs": 1378, "registry_change_requests": 28, "real_writeback_blocked": true }, "now34": { "closed": true, "closed_as": "advisory_schema_validator_closed_no_provider_payload", "boundary": "structural_schema_validator_advisory_only", "provider_payload_generation_blocked": true, "production_readiness_not_claimed": true }, "now35": { "closed": true, "closed_as": "advisory_reviewer_harness_closed_no_acceptance", "boundary": "reviewer_harness_schema_advisory_only", "live_review_cycle_blocked": true, "operator_acceptance_not_claimed": true } } }, "artifact_refs": { "execution_state": { "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/execution_state.json", "exists": true, "sha256": "53b340be603dd37c47c9990476ce255ae5061748d3ed7f5b5c7bc66a0baaae09", "size_bytes": 19420 }, "phase_acceptance": { "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/phase_acceptance.json", "exists": true, "sha256": "4779498479163420bc6df8f6252dd6266492e80e101079835ad4c92c6e3e5da6", "size_bytes": 14152 }, "workflow": { "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/workflow.json", "exists": true, "sha256": "a131b82521896a86788dd51ff7868893fe58ddd43573015aea37c718a233f845", "size_bytes": 79235 }, "todo": { "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/todo.md", "exists": true, "sha256": "0d9f3c7f328f8d39eead3e42d104fbe0a86c53daaa1c8d6a3408c21b7f669970", "size_bytes": 7008 }, "projectreport": { "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/projectreport.md", "exists": true, "sha256": "6516eccc8058045dfa66bccb36e47827b9defcd7066b43396a6292ba1bbf9df5", "size_bytes": 7496 }, "p2v24_gate": { "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_final_closeout_gate.json", "exists": true, "sha256": "5ea5e39cefc8378d4923585369bbeee4cf518622e8fd1ea806dd7157b12ce6ed", "size_bytes": 2622 }, "p2v24_debt_register": { "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_readiness_debt_register.jsonl", "exists": true, "sha256": "f11848721acf1688d4b4081e3e2491944721da098d5a386fcd7b561ea135c6d5", "size_bytes": 201325 }, "p2v24_handoff": { "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout_20260605_0742/P2V_24_now32_handoff_calibration.json", "exists": true, "sha256": "bd34848c561c09778a5a86206a3855908aa52eb7a34d7dfebd429ffc5ed745ff", "size_bytes": 3335 }, "p2v23_held_packages": { "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p_plan_v2_23_prompt_readiness_packaging_boundary_20260605_0730/P2V_23_held_row_package_rows.jsonl", "exists": true, "sha256": "4635c55a78bbb0fe95a0580a8437402dff9374ca653ff7343a305675ce3ddb36", "size_bytes": 278536 }, "p2v23_package": { "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p_plan_v2_23_prompt_readiness_packaging_boundary_20260605_0730/P2V_23_prompt_readiness_package.json", "exists": true, "sha256": "a57ebbac6bef7390e5f5ff4abf46c479f3cd2f612fb66f356541dab5eee748d5", "size_bytes": 11758 } }, "input_stats": { "p2v24_gate": { "chapter_package_count": 20, "draft_row_count": 1638, "held_row_count": 240, "fully_ready_chapter_count": 13, "partial_or_held_chapter_count": 7, "debt_row_count": 247, "chapter_readiness_debt_count": 7, "held_row_debt_count": 240, "provider_prompt_syntax_count": 0, "production_lane_accepted_count": 0, "validator_failure_count": 0, "provider_prompt_count": 0, "adapter_payload_count": 0, "provider_job_execution_count": 0, "media_generation_count": 0, "manual_provider_evidence_count": 0, "operator_evidence_creation_count": 0, "feedback_intake_count": 0, "repair_execution_count": 0, "replay_action_count": 0, "accepted_overlay_write_count": 0, "operator_overlay_write_count": 0, "canonical_kg_writeback_count": 0, "raw_kg_writeback_count": 0, "outputs_index_mutation_count": 0 }, "p2v24_debt_register": { "row_count": 247, "parse_failure_count": 0, "first_row": { "chapter_heading": "第一回　甄士隱夢幻識通靈　賈雨村風塵怀閨秀", "chapter_index": 1, "debt_id": "P2V24DEBT000001", "debt_type": "chapter_readiness_debt", "draft_row_count": 127, "held_qa_review_count": 9, "held_repair_deferred_count": 1, "held_row_count": 10, "production_lane_accepted": false, "readiness_impact": "blocks_complete_chapter_readiness", "readiness_label": "partial_ready_with_holds", "required_future_contract": "explicit_QA_repair_or_evidence_contract_after_P计划_closeout", "schema_id": "p_plan_final_closeout.v1", "stage": "P计划_V2_24_p_plan_final_closeout", "version": "p_plan_v2_24_p_plan_final_closeout.v1" }, "counts": { "debt_type": { "chapter_readiness_debt": 7, "held_row_debt": 240 }, "hold_label": { "": 7, "qa_review_required": 239, "repair_deferred": 1 } } }, "p2v23_held_packages": { "row_count": 240, "parse_failure_count": 0, "first_row": { "carried_defer_row_ids": [ "P2V21CARRY000001" ], "chapter_heading": "第一回　甄士隱夢幻識通靈　賈雨村風塵怀閨秀", "chapter_index": 1, "duration_repair_row_id": "", "held_package_row_id": "P2V23HELD000001", "held_row_id": "P2V22HELD000001", "hold_label": "qa_review_required", "hold_reasons": [ "p2v20_qa_review_required" ], "p2v18_shot_id": "P2V18CH01SC012SH007", "p2v19_shot_packet_id": "P2V19CH01SC012SH007", "p2v20_readiness_row_id": "P2V20CH01SC012SH007", "p2v21_planning_row_id": "P2V21CH01SC012SH007", "package_row_id": "P2V23PKGCH01", "production_lane_accepted": false, "provider_manual_execution_allowed": false, "qa_boundary_ids": [ "P2V20CARRY000001" ], "readiness_impact": "blocks_chapter_full_readiness", "schema_id": "prompt_readiness_package_boundary.v0_draft", "script_file": "P2V_17_chapter_01_pipeline.txt", "script_sha256": "cb20d19ed938c21ef5d0198d6222244a1acf39accb4231536e1c28453738dd05", "source_file": "P2V_17_chapter_01_source.txt", "source_sha256": "1c85a7ece733676be2d091577f93b2f6b0d8541e1974298717cf22eceacc370c", "stage": "P计划_V2_23_prompt_readiness_packaging_boundary", "version": "p_plan_v2_23_prompt_readiness_packaging_boundary.v1" }, "counts": { "debt_type": { "": 240 }, "hold_label": { "qa_review_required": 239, "repair_deferred": 1 } } } }, "previous_round": { "dir": "", "parsed": {} }, "hard_boundaries": [ "Contract landing only; no held-row promotion or readiness row mutation.", "No accepted/operator overlay, canonical UID/KG/raw KG/entity-store writeback, replay, asset binding, provider/media/manual execution, evidence, feedback, outputs-index mutation, route transition, or production acceptance.", "DeepSeek is advisory-only and cannot become operator acceptance or canonical authority.", "DeepSeek missing/skipped/timeout/unavailable/parse_failed blocks pass/readiness for this high-impact contract." ], "input_fingerprint": "2d36007c06842b62f1e351142fefb3dba0f8a216973a2fe9687559b74140becc" }