{ "confidence": "high", "control_plane_update_recommendations": [ "Insert a mandatory entity-binding gate in the pipeline manifest before any row can be marked as 'prompt_ready'.", "Add a canonical entity reference validator that checks every prompt packet for valid entity UIDs and reference assets.", "Update the held-row contract to require entity link resolution as a precondition for repair.", "Strengthen the advisory harness to flag any attempt to generate prompts with unlinked entities.", "Create a 'production-readiness checklist' that includes entity coverage, asset coverage, held/debt zero, schema pass.", "Do not change execution_state.next_entrypoint until all prerequisites are met and validated by a new gate review." ], "do_not_do": [ "Do not begin held-row repair until the KG entity linking advisory is complete and the mapping is available.", "Do not generate provider prompts or adapter payloads for any rows still missing canonical entity UIDs.", "Do not execute media generation or manual evidence creation.", "Do not ingest feedback, execute repair/replay, or write to outputs/index.", "Do not write to canonical KG or raw KG without explicit separate authority, even if entity linking advisory suggests it.", "Do not treat advisory artifacts as evidence of production readiness or as acceptance.", "Do not use runtime branching by chapter/entity/title/block/sample text; all logic must be manifest-driven.", "Do not proceed to NOW-36 while any of the blockers (held, debt, entity, asset) remain unresolved or undisclosed.", "Do not interpret DeepSeek or any advisory output as an execution go-ahead." ], "mainline_recalibration": { "next_primary_lane": "KG/entity-link binding contract, read-only first; writeback only by separate explicit authority", "recommended_direction": "Prioritize foundational entity integrity over incremental row repair or production staging. Bind the canonical entity model to the draft inventory before any other lane. This will unblock held/debt clearance and provide the consistent context needed for prompts and assets.", "sequence": [ { "allowed_outputs": [ "Advisory entity link manifest (draft list of row_id -> canonical_entity_uid or 'missing').", "Gap report: entities referenced in rows but missing from KG.", "Recommended action plan for KG extension (if needed).", "Closeout artifact documenting findings and coverage statistics." ], "blocked_outputs": [ "Canonical KG writeback.", "Raw KG mutations.", "Any prompt generation, adapter payload, or media execution.", "Evidence of acceptance or production readiness." ], "closeout_artifacts": [ "entity_link_advisory_manifest.json", "entity_gap_report.json", "advisory_kg_extension_plan.md", "closeout_gate.json (advisory only)." ], "entry_conditions": [ "NOW-33 advisory closeout complete (entity gap assessment).", "Clear statement that no writeback will occur without explicit separate authority.", "Manifest-driven approach: no runtime branching by chapter/entity/title/block/sample text." ], "id": "kg-entity-link-binding-contract", "purpose": "Establish a read-only advisory mapping between draft rows and canonical KG entities. Identify missing entities and flag rows with irresolvable references. Produce a proposed entity link manifest without mutating the KG. This becomes the foundation for all subsequent repair, asset, and prompt work.", "status": "recommended_next" }, { "allowed_outputs": [ "Repair recommendations for held/debt rows.", "Updated held/debt manifests with proposed status changes.", "Advisory row repair log.", "Debt clearance plan." ], "blocked_outputs": [ "Direct mutation of held/debt rows in the active manifest without review.", "Execution of repaired rows as prompts.", "Overlay or writeback to outputs index.", "NOW-36 readiness evidence." ], "closeout_artifacts": [ "held_row_repair_advisory.json", "debt_clearance_advisory.json", "row_repair_recommendations.csv" ], "entry_conditions": [ "KG entity-link advisory contract completed and entity link manifest available.", "Agreed procedure for how entity links inform held/debt resolution.", "Manifest-driven repair logic: no per-chapter/entity branching." ], "id": "held-row-repair-debt-clearance-contract", "purpose": "Utilize the entity mapping from the KG binding contract to systematically review, repair, and clear held (240) and debt (247) rows. Update row logic and metadata where entity resolution is the key fix. Ensure manifest-driven, no runtime branching.", "status": "blocked_until_prerequisites" }, { "allowed_outputs": [ "Reference asset specification manifest.", "Acquisition tracker (placeholder or real asset paths).", "Validation of asset formats and consistency.", "Advisory binding report." ], "blocked_outputs": [ "Media generation (these are input references, not outputs).", "Creation of synthetic assets without operator review.", "Modification of original prompts or execution." ], "closeout_artifacts": [ "reference_asset_manifest.json", "asset_acquisition_log.md", "missing_asset_waiver_or_plan.md" ], "entry_conditions": [ "Canonical entity list stabilized (after KG binding contract).", "Missing reference slot inventory complete.", "Acquisition strategy (operator-driven or asset library) agreed." ], "id": "reference-asset-acquisition-binding-contract", "purpose": "Address the 3276 missing real reference asset slots by acquiring, specifying, or confirming reference images/assets for canonical entities. Bind them to entity slots in a manifest. Prepare for future prompt enrichment.", "status": "blocked_until_prerequisites" }, { "allowed_outputs": [ "Schema upgrade advisory document.", "New gate validation rules (proposed).", "Updated prompt templates (advisory).", "Impact assessment on existing drafts." ], "blocked_outputs": [ "Direct modification of active prompt manifests without contract.", "Enforcement of new gates before entity/asset gaps closed.", "Provider payload generation." ], "closeout_artifacts": [ "schema_upgrade_recommendation.md", "new_validation_gates.json" ], "entry_conditions": [ "Held/debt rows cleared or reduced to negligible count.", "Entity links and reference assets integrated into prompt generation logic.", "Explicit contract defining scope of schema upgrade and non-regression tests.", "Approval to proceed with advisory-only upgrade recommendations." ], "id": "industry-benchmark-schema-gate-upgrade-contract", "purpose": "Review prompt schema and quality gates against current industry benchmarks (e.g., latest provider capabilities). Upgrade validation rules and prompt templates to meet higher creative-quality standards, but only after base data is sound.", "status": "candidate_blocked_until_explicit_contract" }, { "allowed_outputs": [ "Live advisory feedback documents.", "Consistency reports.", "Warning flags for anomalies." ], "blocked_outputs": [ "Any execution authority.", "Acceptance or rejection of rows.", "Mutation of manifests or outputs index." ], "closeout_artifacts": [ "advisory_loop_log_*.json", "consistency_warnings.md" ], "entry_conditions": [ "Access to current project state snapshots.", "Clear that its output is advisory, not evidence or acceptance.", "No write authority." ], "id": "deepseek-reviewer-harness-live-advisory-loop-contract", "purpose": "Provide continuous advisory review of each stage using DeepSeek harness. This lane is not a blocker but a quality overlay that can run independently, providing feedback on consistency, completeness, and adherence to contracts.", "status": "advisory_only" }, { "allowed_outputs": [ "Evidence of prompt packet validity.", "Readiness report.", "Manual execution log templates (pre-filled).", "Adapter payload samples (non-execution)." ], "blocked_outputs": [ "Actual provider job execution.", "Media generation.", "Feedback ingestion or repair/replay." ], "closeout_artifacts": [ "readiness_evidence_pack.json", "sample_adapter_payloads.json" ], "entry_conditions": [ "Zero held rows (all cleared).", "Debt rows removed or accepted with waivers.", "All draft rows linked to canonical entities.", "All reference asset slots filled or waived.", "Schema gates passed with updated rules.", "Explicit authority to create evidence (not yet granted)." ], "id": "manual-provider-execution-evidence-contract", "purpose": "Once all data-quality foundations are met, this lane creates the evidence pack demonstrating prompt readiness and ability to execute via provider or manual process. This is the final gate before NOW-36.", "status": "blocked_until_prerequisites" }, { "allowed_outputs": [ "Production readiness declaration.", "Final evidence pack.", "Triggers for execution (subject to authority)." ], "blocked_outputs": [ "Premature declaration.", "Execution without explicit authority." ], "closeout_artifacts": [ "NOW_36_production_readiness_gate.json", "final_evidence_bundle.zip" ], "entry_conditions": [ "All previous lanes (KG binding, held/debt cleared, references acquired, schema upgraded, evidence generated) successfully closed with validators passing.", "Explicit gate approval from pipeline orchestrator and operator.", "Execution state next_entrypoint updated (by authorized agent) to production mode." ], "id": "now-36-production-readiness-evidence-pack", "purpose": "After all prior lanes complete and evidence is validated, assemble the final production-readiness pack and proceed to execution entry point per authority. This is the ultimate goal but cannot be achieved until prerequisites are met.", "status": "blocked_until_prerequisites" } ], "why_this_lane_first": [ "All 1638 draft rows lack canonical entity UIDs; no prompt can reliably reference consistent character/prop/location identities.", "Held-row QA/repair often depends on resolving entity references; repairing without entity context may introduce new inconsistencies.", "NOW-33 advisory confirmed the gap; acting on it is the nearest high-impact gate that unlocks downstream lanes.", "Entity binding can be done advisory-only (read) without violating hard boundaries, keeping control plane safe.", "It provides a manifest-driven map that can be reviewed and approved before any writeback, aligning with contract authority." ] }, "open_questions_or_assumptions": [ "Assumption: The canonical KG is properly versioned and ready to accept proposed mappings once authority is granted.", "Open: What is the process for extending the KG if entities exist in rows but not in the KG? Who creates new canonical entities?", "Assumption: Reference asset acquisition will follow a defined operator-driven review process; synthetic placeholder generation is not allowed.", "Open: How will entity binding handle ambiguous references (e.g., pronouns, nicknames) in draft rows? Is manual disambiguation required?", "Assumption: Industry benchmark schema upgrade can be done in parallel or after core fixes, but its output should not be enforced until core data is clean.", "Open: Is there a need for a 'debt acceptance' waiver for rows that cannot be economically fixed? How does that impact NOW-36 criteria?", "Assumption: The control plane's inhibitory mechanisms will prevent any accidental side effects; these have been tested and remain zero.", "Open: Will the entity binding advisory require a full review of all 1638 rows by a human or can automated matching handle majority?" ], "overall_verdict": "The project has cleared advisory closeouts but remains in a production-blocked state. The fundamental gap is the absence of canonical entity linkage across all rows, which undermines held-row repair, prompt generation, and consistency. The primary lane must be a read-only entity binding contract to establish the entity foundation before any further repairs or execution attempts.", "parse_status": "pass", "project_retrospective": { "actual_landed": [ "P计划 V2 final closeout (P2V24) with validators pass and zero side effects.", "NOW-32 advisory held-debt audit closed without promotion.", "NOW-33 advisory entity-asset gap assessment closed without writeback.", "NOW-34 advisory schema validation closed without provider payload.", "NOW-35 advisory reviewer harness closed without acceptance.", "Advisory gate confirmations that no evidence, execution, or outputs-index mutations occurred.", "All structural failure counts at zero; draft, held, debt counts stabilized." ], "control_plane_health": [ "Execution state stable; next_entrypoint firmly set to platform_neutral_prompt_readiness manual log contract.", "All side-effect channels validated at zero; no rogue writes detected.", "Advisory gates functional; parse and validator passes confirm process integrity.", "No evidence of operator overrides or KG drift; control plane is clean but inert.", "Potential risk: long advisory cycles without execution may lead to stale state or forgotten preconditions." ], "goal_alignment": [ "Progress: advisory integrity preserved; phase gate remains open; hard boundaries respected.", "Gap: Pipeline goal of source-to-video is stalled at entity/context layer; no executable prompts exist.", "Primary blocker: Entity identity crisis (1638 rows without canonical UIDs) prevents scene/chronology consistency.", "Secondary blocker: Held rows (240) and debt rows (247) cannot be reliably cleared without entity binding." ], "not_landed": [ "No canonical entity UID assignments for any draft row (1638 rows unlinked).", "No real reference asset bindings for 3276 missing slots.", "No held-row repair or debt clearance.", "No provider prompt generation or adapter payloads.", "No media generation or manual/provider execution evidence.", "No feedback ingestion, repair, replay, or overlay writes.", "No KG writeback (canonical or raw).", "No production readiness evidence pack (NOW-36) due to blockers." ], "risks_and_debt": [ "1638 entity-unlinked rows risk producing inconsistent or hallucinated scenes if advanced prematurely.", "240 held rows represent latent quality failures; some may hide deeper structural issues.", "247 debt rows accumulate technical drift; delay increases cost of eventual repair.", "3276 missing asset references imply any generated video would lack planned visual consistency.", "Rushing to NOW-36 without entity foundation would create a false readiness signal.", "Current advisory-only posture may be misinterpreted as production-ready.", "The control plane has no exercised feedback loop; untested repair/replay paths." ] } }