{
  "version": "deferred_uid_registry_edit_first_reconciliation_deepseek.v1",
  "created_at": "2026-06-08T05:28:14.455584Z",
  "round_id": "round1",
  "call_status": "success",
  "parse_status": "pass",
  "parse_error": "",
  "overall_verdict": "supports_with_required_corrections",
  "round2_verdict": "",
  "confidence": "high",
  "finding_counts": {
    "high": 1
  },
  "findings": [
    {
      "category": "validation",
      "description": "DeepSeek implementation Round 1 and Round 2 advisory outputs are missing, causing the gate to be blocked and the validation to fail with 'implementation_deepseek_rounds_parse_pass_no_high_or_blocker'. This is an expected bootstrap gap as the DeepSeek advisory has not yet been produced. All other aspects of the registry edit‑first reconciliation implementation – artifact counts (464 candidate records, 28 registry prerequisite records, 9 groups, 9 edit proposals, 9 conflicts), no‑writeback boundary enforcement, proposal statuses (proposed_no_writeback only), and forbidden side‑effect counts (all zero) – are consistent with the contract and free of other issues.",
      "required_fix": "Complete the DeepSeek Round 1 advisory (this review) and the subsequent Round 2 advisory. Attach the resulting JSON artifacts to the gate, then rerun the reconciliation validation so that all checks, including the deepseek parse check, pass.",
      "severity": "high"
    }
  ],
  "required_corrections": [
    "Provide the DeepSeek Round 1 advisory output (the present review).",
    "Provide the DeepSeek Round 2 advisory output.",
    "Attach both round outputs to the gate and rerun the deferred_uid_registry_edit_first_reconciliation_no_writeback validation to confirm all checks pass."
  ],
  "raw_payload": {
    "confidence": "high",
    "findings": [
      {
        "category": "validation",
        "description": "DeepSeek implementation Round 1 and Round 2 advisory outputs are missing, causing the gate to be blocked and the validation to fail with 'implementation_deepseek_rounds_parse_pass_no_high_or_blocker'. This is an expected bootstrap gap as the DeepSeek advisory has not yet been produced. All other aspects of the registry edit‑first reconciliation implementation – artifact counts (464 candidate records, 28 registry prerequisite records, 9 groups, 9 edit proposals, 9 conflicts), no‑writeback boundary enforcement, proposal statuses (proposed_no_writeback only), and forbidden side‑effect counts (all zero) – are consistent with the contract and free of other issues.",
        "required_fix": "Complete the DeepSeek Round 1 advisory (this review) and the subsequent Round 2 advisory. Attach the resulting JSON artifacts to the gate, then rerun the reconciliation validation so that all checks, including the deepseek parse check, pass.",
        "severity": "high"
      }
    ],
    "no_writeback_boundary_supported": true,
    "overall_verdict": "supports_with_required_corrections",
    "parse_status": "pass",
    "recommended_disposition": "land_after_corrections",
    "registry_edit_first_scope_supported": true,
    "required_corrections": [
      "Provide the DeepSeek Round 1 advisory output (the present review).",
      "Provide the DeepSeek Round 2 advisory output.",
      "Attach both round outputs to the gate and rerun the deferred_uid_registry_edit_first_reconciliation_no_writeback validation to confirm all checks pass."
    ]
  },
  "advisory_only": true,
  "not_evidence_or_acceptance_or_route_authority": true
}