{
  "role": "DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max third-party expert consultant for Novel2Video",
  "authority_boundary": [
    "advisory-only; not operator acceptance",
    "no canonical KG/raw KG/accepted overlay/provider evidence/replay authority",
    "should critique and recommend, not claim project decisions are accepted"
  ],
  "project_goal": "program-first pipeline turning long novels into platform-neutral production packets for video generation",
  "current_active_route": "Now-32 / Prompt-Readiness-Manual-Execution-Log-Contract; execution_state.json.next_entrypoint remains platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract",
  "current_sidecar": "P计划 V2 creative-quality redesign; P2V-14 generated pending human review",
  "p2v14_results": {
    "lanes": {
      "direct_minimal": "P2V-13 minimal direct DeepSeek full-chapter prompt reused",
      "direct_strong": "new DeepSeek direct lane with C/P2V-12/P2V-13 director-workbench constraints, no access to other lane outputs",
      "pipeline": "P2V-13 independent pipeline lane reused"
    },
    "win_counts": {
      "direct_minimal": 0,
      "direct_strong": 3,
      "pipeline": 5,
      "top_parity": 2
    },
    "average_scores": {
      "direct_minimal": 5.24,
      "direct_strong": 8.76,
      "pipeline": 8.64
    },
    "gate": "pending_human_review; validator_failure_count=0; provider_prompt_syntax_count=0; forbidden side-effect counts=0",
    "interpretation_so_far": "P2V-13 minimal direct weakness was prompt underspecification; strong direct and pipeline are same tier. Pipeline value must be engineering traceability/extraction/review stability, not simple creative superiority over strong direct DeepSeek."
  },
  "control_plane_compaction": {
    "before": {
      "execution_state.json": "152KB/2011 lines",
      "phase_acceptance.json": "151KB/2294 lines",
      "todo.md": "67KB/754 lines",
      "projectreport.md": "79KB/745 lines"
    },
    "after": {
      "execution_state.json": "14.8KB/240 lines",
      "phase_acceptance.json": "11.5KB/197 lines",
      "todo.md": "5.6KB/76 lines",
      "projectreport.md": "7.4KB/101 lines"
    },
    "workflow_json": "still large ~1.43MB; retained as machine-readable policy/registry; future registry compaction possible",
    "minimal_md_policy": "no new md unless artifact-backed contract, retrospective, operator decision record, report, or handoff; history goes to patchnote.md, reusable policy to workflow.json"
  },
  "questions": [
    "How should we interpret P2V-14 strategically?",
    "Which next production strategy is strongest: pipeline-first with stronger constraints, DeepSeek-first deterministic wrapper, hybrid per-chapter selection, or another scale batch?",
    "What concrete changes should be made to the pipeline if we continue it?",
    "What further control-plane compaction or governance changes are advisable?",
    "How should the DeepSeek expert consultant agent be operationalized without confusing advisory output with operator acceptance?"
  ],
  "expected_json_schema": {
    "overall_recommendation": "short string",
    "recommended_strategy": "pipeline_first | deepseek_first_wrapper | hybrid_selection | more_scale_batch | other",
    "confidence": "0-1 number",
    "rationale": [
      "short bullets"
    ],
    "pipeline_changes": [
      "concrete changes"
    ],
    "control_plane_advice": [
      "concrete changes"
    ],
    "deepseek_consultant_operating_model": [
      "concrete rules"
    ],
    "risks": [
      {
        "risk": "short",
        "severity": "high|medium|low",
        "mitigation": "short"
      }
    ],
    "next_decision_gate": [
      "what human/operator should inspect next"
    ]
  }
}